The Chicago Cubs may have to cross one trade partner off the board after the Seattle Mariners shut down a fresh round of pitching rumors.
Seattle’s move on Wednesday, sending starting pitcher Bryce Miller to the Kansas City Royals in a deal for third baseman Maikel Garcia, changed the landscape quickly. The Mariners had been exploring the idea of swapping pitching for offense for the past two years, and this was the deal that finally fit. They got the infield bat they wanted and used a starter to get it done.
That matters for the Cubs because it makes a Matt Shaw-centered deal with Seattle look far less likely. If the Mariners were willing to move another starter, Chicago could have stayed in the conversation. But Mariners president of baseball operations Jared Dipoto ended that speculation fast, saying there is "zero chance" the Mariners trade another starting pitcher from their rotation this offseason.
Seattle’s rotation surplus has already been whittled down. The Mariners traded Luis Castillo to the White Sox at the deadline, then moved Miller to the Royals on Wednesday and also dealt right-handed pitcher Logan Evans.
For the Cubs, the Mariners had been a possible fit at the deadline with Logan Gilbert and Emerson Hancock. Gilbert would have looked like the kind of arm who could anchor the Cubs’ rotation in 2027, and he comes with one more season of team control. Hancock would have projected closer to the back end of the rotation, but with four additional years of control.
The problem for Chicago is that Seattle just found a different kind of return in Garcia. The comparison is tough for the Cubs to beat.
Shaw may have a higher ceiling, but Garcia brings a more established expectation and a contract that runs through the 2030 season. With the Mariners aiming to get back into contention in 2027, it makes sense that they chose the known piece over the possibility of what Shaw might become.
That doesn’t make Shaw untouchable. Under the right circumstances, he remains a useful trade chip for the Cubs if they want to chase a cost-controlled starting pitcher. And with the free-agent pitching market still carrying a hefty price tag, the trade market may be the route Chicago takes before the lockout in December.
In Other News...
Cubs Just Got A New Problem In Their Rotation Search
The White Soxs decision to move Luis Castillo to Colorado, with the Rockies taking on the contract and the $24.15 million owed in 2027, adds another wrinkle to the market the Cubs are watching closely. Chicagos crosstown rival also included Davis Martin in the deal, a move that frees up financial room and gives the Sox more flexibility heading into the offseason.
For the Cubs, the timing matters because they are still sorting through the starting pitching market, and any team with extra spending power can complicate the chase. If the White Sox decide to use that newfound flexibility aggressively, it could affect both the price and the competition for the kind of arms the Cubs are likely targeting as they try to strengthen the rotation. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Could Feel David Peterson Loss More Than Fans Expect
The Rockies search for starting pitching has taken an interesting turn, and David Peterson is now part of that conversation. Colorado already added Luis Castillo and Davis Martin from the White Sox, and its reported interest in the left-hander fits a broader change in approach after an offseason that was built around one-year contracts. For the Cubs, Peterson is a familiar name by now, a pitcher who spent most of his career with the Mets before arriving in Chicago and giving them a useful stretch down the back end of the 2026 season.
Petersons year was uneven overall, but the way he finished with the Cubs is the kind of detail that can matter when a club is trying to sort out its rotation depth for the next season. If Colorado keeps pushing on him, Chicago could be looking at more than just a lost arm on paper. It would also mean one fewer experienced lefty in the mix, and one more reminder that solid late-season work can quickly turn a pitcher into a target elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Catcher Plans
The Cubs added another layer to their catching picture by claiming Joey Bart off waivers from the White Sox after he was designated for assignment earlier in the week. It is the kind of move that usually flies under the radar in November, but it says plenty about how Chicago is sorting through its options behind the plate and trying to build some stability around the position.
Bart now lands in a spot where the next step appears to be more than just a short-term look. The Cubs are expected to tender him a contract for 2027 before the deadline, a sign they see enough value to keep him in the fold and let the situation develop from there. [Read more 🡒]
