Matt Shaw has been floating through trade chatter for months, and the Cubs’ search for starting pitching has only kept his name in the mix. But one of the most obvious landing spots for that kind of deal just disappeared.
On Wednesday, the Seattle Mariners and Kansas City Royals completed a blockbuster that sent right-handed pitcher Bryce Miller to Kansas City in a six-player trade. That move matters in Chicago because Seattle had been viewed as a possible match for Shaw, who was once handed the third-base job after the Cubs missed out on Alex Bregman heading into the 2025 season and then was asked to learn the outfield after Chicago signed Bregman this past year.
The Mariners had been linked to the Cubs in trade rumors for a while, and the fit made sense on paper. Seattle wanted to improve its defense heading into 2027, and it already checked one box by acquiring Maikel Garcia, the 26-year-old who won a 2025 American League Gold Glove Award at third base with the Royals. Shaw, despite his rookie struggles, was a Gold Glove finalist at third base in the National League in 2025, which is why his name got pulled into the conversation with Seattle this month.
For the Cubs, the appeal was just as clear. They’re still looking for help in the rotation, and a deal with the Mariners could have brought back one of Seattle’s starters. That path is now closed, at least for the moment, with Miller off the board.
Miller, 28, is under team control through the 2029 season, but injuries have slowed him down recently. An elbow issue was among the problems that limited him to 18 and 21 starts over the past two seasons.
Chicago baseball insider Bruce Levine said just last week that the Cubs would look to move Shaw for pitching this offseason, and he specifically mentioned the Mariners as a possible partner. With Seattle now dealing Miller to Kansas City, the Cubs will need to find another team if they want to turn Shaw into rotation help.
It also weakens Chicago’s position in those talks. The Cubs can’t lean on a Mariners deal as a live option anymore, which takes away a bit of leverage. So, yes, that’s a double hit for the Cubs.
Or, as the last line of this whole situation suggests, they could simply spend in free agency to add starting pitching.
In Other News...
Cubs Silver Slugger Honor Highlights A Bigger Problem With Milwaukee
The Cubs 2026 Silver Slugger team award is a tidy reminder of just how dangerous their lineup was over the course of the regular season. Led by Pete Crow-Armstrong, who also captured National League MVP honors, Chicago piled up enough offensive production to sit atop several league categories, a profile that usually points to a club built for a division run.
Instead, the bigger picture still circles back to Milwaukee, where the Brewers pitching kept the Cubs from turning that firepower into a division title. Chicago finished 14 games back, and the gap raises a tougher question for the offseason and beyond: if the Cubs offense is already this good, what happens if roster changes trim some of that edge while the Brewers keep leaning on run prevention? [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Just Sent A Clear Pitching Message For Their Future
The Cubs made their intentions pretty clear with Wednesdays roster move, adding right-handers Jaxon Wiggins and Brody McCullough to the 40-man roster to keep both out of the upcoming Rule 5 draft. It is the kind of decision that says as much about the organizations internal pitching depth as it does about the immediate roster crunch, especially with several free-agent starters on the market and a rotation spot or two available for next season.
Wiggins remains one of the more intriguing arms in the system even as he works back from elbow issues, while McCulloughs path has been shaped by his own recovery from forearm surgery after being taken in the 10th round. Protecting both pitchers now gives Chicago a better chance to see what they can become in camp and beyond, and it also underscores how much of the Cubs next pitching wave may already be in-house. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Just Lost A Realistic Pitching Trade Path Before The Lockout
The market for starting pitching just got a little thinner for the Cubs, and the timing matters with the lockout looming. Seattle had been one of the more logical places to shop because of its surplus on the mound, but a move involving Bryce Miller has changed that picture and trimmed away some of the depth that made the Mariners such a tempting trade partner.
For Chicago, that matters because Seattle had been viewed as a possible source of frontline help, with the Cubs previously connected to arms like George Kirby and Emerson Hancock. Now the front office may have to pivot quickly and look elsewhere, with clubs such as the Angels or Rangers potentially becoming more realistic avenues if the Cubs want to add a starter before the freeze hits. [Read more 🡒]
