Cubs Just Got A Bigger Carson Kelly Problem Than Expected

With Ryan Jeffers staying put, Carson Kelly's prospects with the Cubs take a turn, raising intriguing implications for the team's catching strategy in 2027.

Ryan Jeffers’ decision to take the qualifying offer on Tuesday afternoon sent a ripple through the catcher market, and Carson Kelly may be the biggest beneficiary of the whole thing.

Jeffers, who had been viewed as the top catcher in this winter’s free-agent class, chose to return to the Minnesota Twins instead of testing the market. The move surprised plenty of people, especially with projections pointing to a strong payday. Spotrac had him at three years and $40 million, while MLB Trade Rumors was even higher at four years and $75 million.

David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers have accepted the qualifying offer.

  • Robert Murray (@ByRobertMurray) November 17, 2026

Jeffers has been a steady presence for Minnesota for years, and his bat has taken another step since the start of the 2023 season, when he’s posted a 116 OPS+. This year, he was one of the better offensive catchers in the sport before an injury interrupted what had looked like a major breakout at the plate. His defense has never been his calling card, but the offensive production made him the headliner of the catching market.

That’s where Kelly comes in. The Cubs were never considered a real threat for Jeffers, but his staying put changes the landscape anyway. With Jeffers off the board, Kelly’s stock rises, and he now has a strong argument as the best catching option available.

Chicago would still like to have Kelly back after his two-year run on the North Side, but the price was always going to be a problem. Even before Jeffers accepted the qualifying offer, the Cubs weren’t expected to meet what Kelly could command in a thin market.

So while Kelly’s market gets stronger, the Cubs appear headed in a different direction. Miguel Amaya is lined up to take over at the top of the depth chart in 2027, with Owen Ayers positioned as the No.

  1. Ayers has climbed quickly through the system and looks ready to back up Amaya next season.

Chicago could still add veteran catching depth on a low-cost or minor-league deal, but Kelly’s asking price now looks even further out of reach for the Cubs.

In Other News...

Cubs Linked To A Pitching Answer They May Need Fast

The Cubs may not be done shopping for pitching, and Freddy Peralta is already shaping up as one of the most interesting names on the market. After helping the Rays push all the way to the World Series before falling to the Brewers, Peralta heads into free agency with the kind of profile that tends to draw serious attention, especially from clubs looking to stabilize the top end of a rotation.

Chicago has been connected to him as a likely destination, which makes sense given the need for impact arms and the urgency that often comes with the winter market. The Rays, meanwhile, are staring at a rotation reset of their own, with Peralta and Nick Martinez both gone from the mix, and the ripple effect could leave Tampa Bay scrambling while the Cubs watch to see whether this turns into the kind of long-term deal that changes the conversation. [Read more 🡒]

Cubs Rotation Search Just Hit A Frustrating Trade Reality

The Cubs have been working the phones with the Rangers as they look for rotation help, and the names in those conversations tell you how aggressively theyre trying to solve the problem. MacKenzie Gore is believed to be the preferred target, while Jacob deGrom and Nathan Eovaldi have also come up as part of the broader discussion, a sign that Chicago is at least exploring every tier of the market before the offseason clock gets tighter.

The catch is that this kind of pursuit is never just about talent, and the Cubs are running into the usual trade complications of player preference and money. There is also uncertainty around how qualifying offer rules could change under the new CBA, which only adds another layer of hesitation for teams weighing whether to move now or wait. If Chicago does push for pitching before the lockout, Eovaldi may end up being the more realistic path, even if he is not the flashiest one. [Read more 🡒]

Pete Crow-Armstrong Has One More Chance To Cap His Cubs Season

The Cubs still have one more awards-stage moment left on the calendar, with the 2026 Silver Slugger winners set to be announced Tuesday on the Baseball Insiders podcast. Chicago has three players in the mix this time, with Pete Crow-Armstrong, Seiya Suzuki and Alex Bregman all finalists at their respective positions, a nice bit of recognition for a lineup that spent much of the season carrying real weight.

Crow-Armstrongs inclusion is the headline for Cubs fans, of course, after a season that put him squarely in the center of the National League conversation and made him one of the sports most visible breakout stars. The award reveal offers one more chance for his year to end with hardware, even if the final word on where he lands among the leagues best is still waiting to be delivered. [Read more 🡒]