The Chicago Cubs finally pushed their payroll into unfamiliar territory in 2026, but the results didn’t match the price tag.
At $248.8 million, the Cubs checked in eighth in the MLB payroll rankings, the highest figure the organization has ever carried. On paper, that looked like the kind of all-in move fans had been asking for. In practice, only one major swing really paid off.
That exception was Alex Bregman. After missing on him the year before, Jed Hoyer got his man last winter, landing the veteran third baseman on a five-year, $175 million contract that, once deferred money is factored in, works out to about 5/150 in net present value. The start was uneven, but Bregman turned the season around in the second half and completely changed the conversation around the deal.
He finished with a 5.6 fWAR, his best single-season mark since 2019. Bregman also handled the hot corner well defensively and delivered at the plate with 28 home runs and 92 RBI, while helping likely NL MVP Pete Crow-Armstrong carry more of the offensive load.
That’s why the contract has gone from looking like a possible overpay to feeling like an absolute steal.
The rest of the Cubs’ big-ticket spending told a much rougher story, especially on the pitching side. The trade for Edward Cabrera from the Miami Marlins last winter did not deliver the return Chicago wanted. Cabrera made $4.45 million and posted a 5.96 ERA across just 80 innings, which was a tough outcome for a club expecting more from that addition.
The bullpen spending was even harder to defend. Hunter Harvey, Phil Maton and Hoby Milner were supposed to be the headline relief additions, but none of them gave the Cubs much.
Harvey, who came with obvious health concerns, was paid $6 million and appeared in only four games. Maton spent much of the year injured and then saw a knee issue cut his 2026 season short, and when he was available, he wasn’t consistently effective.
Milner didn’t last, either, and the Cubs moved him late in the summer.
Chicago also brought back Caleb Thielbar, a move that ended up backfiring as well. For a fan base that had long wanted the front office to spend more, especially on the bullpen, this was the moment it finally happened - and the payoff fell well short.
The Cubs did reach the postseason for a second straight year, but that only softened the edge of a season that opened with division-title and World Series expectations. When the spending spree is measured against the results, the gaps are obvious.
In Other News...
Cubs Get A Meaningful Playoff Boost Fans Did Not Expect
The Cubs are headed into a best-of-three Wild Card Series against the Padres with the kind of October backdrop that always sharpens the edges a little, and this one comes with a small but welcome comfort for longtime fans. Games will air on NBCSN and Peacock, and the broadcast booth will include a familiar name in Jim Deshaies, the Marquee Sports Network analyst who put off hip surgery so he could call the series.
For a club trying to turn a short postseason window into something bigger, having Deshaies on the call adds a layer of continuity at a time when everything else feels compressed and high-stakes. The schedule, start times and umpire assignments are all set, but Chicagos crowd will also have a voice attached to the games that has become part of the teams recent rhythm, even as the real drama waits to unfold on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Craig Counsell's Game 1 Pitching Choice Says Everything About This Series
Craig Counsell opened the Wild Card Series with a familiar hand, turning to Matthew Boyd to start Game 1 against the Padres. Boyd has been a trusted option for the Cubs in recent playoff stretches, and he has already taken the ball in a Game 1 matchup with San Diego before, a sign that Chicago is leaning into experience and comfort as the margin for error shrinks.
The Padres will counter with right-hander Michael King, while Counsell also confirmed Kevin Gausman will get into the series for the Cubs. In a short series, every pitching decision can shape the tone fast, and Boyds assignment suggests the Cubs are prioritizing a starter they know they can trust in a pressure spot while keeping the rest of the plan flexible. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Just Gave The Cubs A Wild-Card Twist To Worry About
The Cubs now have a little more to factor into their wild-card preparation after San Diego revealed its 26-man roster for the upcoming series. The Padres are carrying 15 position players and 11 pitchers, and the group includes some choices that signal how they plan to manage the matchup, including three catchers who could all be part of the mix over the series.
One of the biggest developments for Chicago is the return of Joe Musgrove, who had not pitched in the postseason since the 2024 wild-card round and sat out this season after Tommy John surgery. San Diego also made a few notable roster calls at the margins, bringing in Andujar and Sheets while leaving Sung-Mun Song, Wandy Peralta and Randy Vasquez off the list, another reminder that the Cubs will be facing a postseason opponent with some fresh pieces and a few familiar threats back in the fold. [Read more 🡒]