The 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot brings 14 first-time names into the mix, and that alone is a milestone. Most of them won’t clear the 5% threshold needed to stick around for another year - over the last five ballots, 78% of first-timers have been one-and-done - but one is expected to get elected, and one or two more should survive to the next round. Every one of the newcomers has a case worth noting.
Jake Arrieta’s path to the ballot runs through Baltimore and Chicago, and the contrast is stark. With the Orioles, he was a 5.46 ERA pitcher who also fought with the club over its effort to get him away from his crossfire delivery.
The Cubs let him go back to throwing across his body, a motion that put stress on his body but also helped unlock the best stretch of his career. From 2014-17 in Chicago, Arrieta went 64-29 with a 2.67 ERA and won the 2015 Cy Young Award after one of the most dominant second halves ever: 12-1 with a 0.75 ERA in 15 starts.
He also started and won two road games in the 2016 World Series without giving up more than two runs, a feat achieved only nine times by a series winner.
Jay Bruce’s career is tied to the era of extreme defensive shifts. He was a left-handed pull hitter whose prime landed right in the narrow window when teams stacked three infielders on one side of the field.
Two years after he retired, MLB ended the extreme shifts. His career line, like Brian McCann’s, makes the point: a productive hitter whose grounders and liners too often found short right field.
Asdrubal Cabrera’s value came from versatility and longevity. A switch hitter who handled all four infield spots, he spent eight seasons with Cleveland before moving on to seven teams over his final seven years, including the 2019 Nationals, who went on to win the World Series. Cabrera started five of the seven games in that Fall Classic.
Starlin Castro once looked like he might become something much bigger. By age 22, he was one of only 18 players in history with 529 hits and a .297 batting average.
The big leap never came, though he still put together nine more seasons with the Cubs, Yankees, Marlins and Nationals. Washington released him after he served a 30-game suspension for domestic violence.
He finished with a 97 OPS+ and earned $70 million.
Greg Holland’s peak was short, but it was loud enough to get him here. In December 2017, the Rockies gave him a three-year, $52 million deal, making him the most expensive reliever in history at the time.
That contract was a nod to four dominant seasons after he moved to the bullpen: 23-6 with a 1.45 ERA and 79 saves. Then came the Denver version of the free-agent pitcher story.
He went 4-13 with a 6.49 ERA.
Brett Gardner was never the flashy type, but he lasted 14 years in pinstripes by doing a lot of little things well. He walked on at College of Charleston, got cut, earned another chance and made the team.
The Yankees took heat for drafting the 5-foot-10 corner outfielder as early as the third round, but Gardner brought speed, elite left-field defense and a knack for spoiling pitches over and over until he found one he could hit. He ranks third in stolen bases in Yankees history.
He made only one All-Star team, never reached 100 runs in a season and hit .256 for his career, yet he made the most of every bit of it.
Jon Lester built a Hall-worthy resume without ever leading the league in a major pitching category. He’s one of only 20 pitchers to win 200 games with a .631 winning percentage, and only five left-handers are in that group: Clayton Kershaw, Whitey Ford, Lefty Grove, Randy Johnson and Lester.
He won World Series titles with the Red Sox in 2007 and 2013 and with the Cubs in 2016, and he pitched in clinchers twice. The ace label fits, too: he started 12 Game 1s, with only Justin Verlander starting more.
Lester made five All-Star teams, finished in the top five in Cy Young voting three times and reached 30 starts 12 times, sixth most in the wild card era.
Andrew Miller changed how teams thought about the fireman role. After moving to the bullpen full time in 2012, he became a star even though he spent only one season as a closer.
His most famous work came in the 2016 postseason. Over 16 seasons and seven teams, he posted a 2.95 ERA as a reliever with 12.9 strikeouts per nine innings.
Buster Posey’s résumé is packed with the kind of accomplishments that define a generation: Rookie of the Year, MVP, batting champion, seven-time All-Star and three-time world champion. He also belongs to an extremely small club.
Among the 129 players who have caught 1,000 games in the majors, only six are career .300 hitters: Hall of Famers Mickey Cochrane, Bill Dickey, Mike Piazza and Ernie Lombardi, along with Virgil Davis and Posey. Piazza and Posey are the only catchers to hit .300 for their careers in the last 80 years.
Pablo Sandoval made his name in seven seasons with the Giants, where he won two World Series, hit three homers in one World Series game, made two All-Star teams, posted a 123 OPS+ and sold thousands of fuzzy panda hats. He could barrel just about anything, even pitches well off the plate.
But the chase rate and the body that came with it caught up to him, especially after he signed a five-year, $95 million deal with the Red Sox. Over his post-Giants career, which covered only 511 games across seven years, he hit .239/.294/.393 with an 83 OPS+.
Jered Weaver’s career had durability, a no-hitter and two All-Star nods, plus a winning record of 151-129. He made 30 starts nine times, including five straight seasons, which says plenty about how often he took the ball. But the bigger numbers don’t quite reach Hall level: his ERA+ was 101, and his postseason record was 1-5 with a 6.57 ERA.
Kyle Seager walked away after the 2021 season at age 33, right after setting career highs with 35 home runs and 101 RBI. Once the Mariners made it clear they did not want him back, he retired.
Seager and David Ortiz are the only players to call it a career after hitting 35 homers and driving in 100. He earned $103 million, made one All-Star team, never appeared in the postseason and hit .238 at home and .262 on the road while playing in pitcher-friendly T-Mobile Park.
Fernando Rodney spent 14 seasons and nine teams piling up numbers no pitcher born in Mexico has matched. He appeared in 773 games, all but one in relief, and saved 229, both records for a Mexico-born pitcher. One strange footnote stands out: he never came to the plate, finishing 13 games shy of the record held by Buddy Groom.
Ryan Zimmerman’s case starts with two nicknames and ends with a career that defined the Nationals. He spent all 16 seasons with Washington, represented the franchise and the game well, and hit 11 walk-off homers, including the winner to open Nationals Park in 2008.
He was the fourth overall pick in the 2005 draft, the one that also included Bruce, and none of the first-rounders from that class are headed for the Hall. Among those first-round picks, Zimmerman ranks fourth in WAR, behind Andrew McCutchen, Ryan Braun and Troy Tulowitzki.
In Other News...
This Cubs Lineup Could Be Headed For Another Huge Statement
The Cubs offense is in the spotlight again as the 2026 Silver Slugger Awards are set to be announced Tuesday night, with Pete Crow-Armstrong among the National League outfield finalists after his recent MVP season. Seiya Suzuki is also in the mix, giving Chicago multiple chances to add more hardware to a year in which the lineup was one of the leagues most dangerous groups.
Chicago is also a finalist for the team award after leading the National League in several offensive categories during the regular season, a sign of just how complete the lineup was from top to bottom. Alex Bregman is in the running at third base against Max Muncy, but for the Cubs, the bigger story is whether a group that kept producing all year can turn that regular-season dominance into another statement on awards night. [Read more 🡒]
Jed Hoyer Just Changed The Cubs Timeline In A Big Way
Jed Hoyers new five-year extension gives the Cubs a much clearer sense of continuity at the top of the baseball operation, and it does so at a moment when the organization is still trying to define its next sustained run of contention. Confirmed by The Athletics Patrick Mooney and Sahadev Sharma, the deal keeps Hoyer under contract through the 2030 season and signals that ownership is willing to let him keep steering the roster, development pipeline and long-term planning without the constant backdrop of contract uncertainty.
For a front office that has spent the past few years balancing patience with urgency, the timing matters as much as the length. Hoyers stay is now set to stretch well beyond the kind of shorter executive window that often shapes baseball decisions, and it invites an obvious question about how aggressively the Cubs will pursue the next phase of their build while he has the runway to see it through. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Could Make A Quiet Prospect Move Before A Costly Deadline
With Tuesdays 5 p.m. CT deadline looming, the Cubs are in the familiar spot of deciding which prospects are worth protecting from the Rule 5 draft and which ones they can afford to leave exposed. Chicago has several openings on its 40-man roster, which gives the front office some flexibility, but it also leaves room for a few quiet moves if the club wants to avoid losing players without getting anything back.
Grant Kipp is among the names that could factor into that calculus, and the Cubs may not need a splashy deal to sort it out. A recent trade between the Brewers and Giants offers one possible blueprint for how these last-minute roster maneuvers can unfold, but for now Chicago has not announced any transactions, leaving the final shape of the roster protection plan still to be determined. [Read more 🡒]
