Cubs Fans Have Another Reason To Question This Bullpen Decision

After being cut loose by the Cubs, Hoby Milner aims to boost the Mariners' struggling bullpen in a late-season playoff push.

Hoby Milner has found a new landing spot after his brief stay with the Cubs ended in a DFA. The left-hander has signed a minor-league deal with the Seattle Mariners, putting a quick end to a confusing stretch in Chicago that wrapped with the Cubs designating him for assignment.

Seattle is taking a flier on Milner at a time when the club still has work to do if it wants to push into the playoff race. The Mariners came into Tuesday with playoff odds just north of 11 percent and are chasing the Houston Astros and Texas Rangers in what is described as a soft American League West.

If they’re going to make a September charge, the bullpen has to do more. Mariners relievers rank 23rd in the majors with a 4.44 ERA, even though Gabe Speier has been excellent from the left side with a 2.58 ERA in 45 appearances and José A.

Ferrer has also been a solid left-handed option.

Milner’s time with the Cubs was steady, if not flashy. His 2026 season got knocked off course by an emergency appendectomy in late June, and he still hasn’t returned to a big-league mound since. Before that, he was basically tracking with his usual numbers, logging 38 appearances with a 3.53 ERA and a 1.206 WHIP.

Chicago brought Milner in last winter on a one-year deal, hoping he could give the bullpen another dependable lefty alongside Caleb Thielbar after Thielbar’s strong 2025. That plan hasn’t really played out. Thielbar has slipped, and with Milner out, Ryan Rolison has become the club’s main southpaw, putting up a 3.08 ERA across 52 2/3 innings.

The Cubs’ offseason bullpen moves have been under the microscope all year, especially with Hunter Harvey lasting only four innings before landing on the shelf and Phil Maton either ineffective or unavailable for much of the season. Milner doesn’t belong in that same bucket, but the overall return on Chicago’s bullpen investment has still been disappointing.

In Other News...

Former Cubs Prospect Is Making The Gausman Trade Look Riskier

Brett Bateman is already making a strong first impression in Toronto, and that matters for Cubs fans because his path there traces back to the Kevin Gausman deal. Since his debut with the Blue Jays on Aug. 8, Bateman has hit well enough to become a useful part of a team that is pushing its way deeper into the playoff picture, which adds an early layer of intrigue to a trade that was supposed to be centered on pitching.

For Chicago, the more immediate concern is how the other side of the swap has gone. Gausman has struggled in his first five starts with the Cubs, carrying a 5.14 ERA, and the contrast has only sharpened with Batemans early production north of the border. It is still early in the story of the trade, but the opening chapter already looks a lot different depending on which clubhouse you are watching. [Read more 🡒]

Cubs Give Craig Counsell A New Bench Option For The Stretch Run

When rosters expand, the Cubs are planning to add another layer of depth for the stretch run by selecting the contract of corner infielder B.J. Murray. The 26-year-old switch-hitter is not currently on the 40-man roster, but Chicago has room to make the move, and his profile fits the kind of late-season insurance contenders tend to value.

Murray, a 2021 draft pick, has built a reputation for providing offense along with flexibility around the diamond. He has spent his pro career showing he can handle both infield and outfield duties, which gives Craig Counsell another potential bench piece as the Cubs navigate the final weeks of the season and look for ways to keep matchups in their favor. [Read more 🡒]

Shelby Miller Suddenly Looks Like A Bigger Cubs Bullpen Concern

Shelby Millers rehab process has become one of the quieter health watch items for the Cubs, and not in a way that offers much comfort. He was pulled from a minor-league outing after hitting a 15-pitch limit, then sat out the next two scheduled games, which only reinforces how carefully the club is handling his return. Chicago has made clear it wants to see more than a single clean appearance before it considers him ready for the bullpen.

The bigger issue now is whether Miller can show he is built to work on consecutive days, since that has been the standard the Cubs have been waiting on throughout the rehab. Until he does, the timeline remains unsettled, and the next update is expected once the roster expansion period begins. For a bullpen that could use another dependable arm, the delay leaves another question hanging over the late-season picture. [Read more 🡒]