The Cubs are still in the part of the offseason where the smaller swings matter, and Frankie Montas fits that lane if Chicago decides to take one. Jed Hoyer has already shown a willingness to hunt for low-cost reclamation arms, with the team claiming Eric Orze and Chayce McDermott off waivers and signing former Pittsburgh Pirates reliever Justin Lawrence to a minor-league deal. A Montas addition would be a bigger bet than those moves, but it would still live in the same world: upside first, price second.
Montas is coming off a lost 2026 season while rehabbing from Tommy John surgery, and he recently put on a bullpen session in front of several teams. Given how much pitching the Cubs need, it would not be a surprise if they were among the clubs watching closely.
His track record is exactly why this is a conversation instead of a slam dunk. Montas showed flashes early with the Athletics, but he never turned that into a full, stable season.
The Yankees grabbed him at the 2022 deadline, only to get a rough stretch right away, as he put up a 6.35 ERA in his first eight starts in New York. Then 2023 disappeared because of injury, and by the time he resurfaced in 2024, the picture had changed: he looked less like a dependable starter and more like a project.
The last time he pitched, in 2025 with the Mets before the Tommy Surgery, Montas logged just under 39 innings and carried a 6.28 ERA.
There were still signs that would make a team look twice. Reports from that bullpen session said his fastball sat around his career norm of 95 MPH and touched 98 MPH, and his mechanics were described as encouraging.
That has led some evaluators to believe he could land a big-league deal rather than the minor-league pact many would expect. Even so, the injury history and the version of Montas teams last saw should keep the price in check.
There is a path where the Cubs make it work. When Montas has been at his best, his ground-ball rate has hovered around 45%, which gives him a trait worth betting on.
But Chicago would need to be careful about what this signing is supposed to be. He should not be treated as a rotation answer handed a job on the spot, and it may be that the bullpen is the better fit anyway.
That is the real condition here: Montas only makes sense if the Cubs see him as a low-risk project for the staff, not as a move that is supposed to fix the rotation right away in 2027. If he turns into more than that, great. But the smarter view is simple - add him only if the rest of the offseason brings bigger pieces too.
In Other News...
Cubs Fans Know This Rotation Search Feels Uncomfortably Familiar
The Cubs are back in the familiar winter lane of trying to patch a rotation without diving into the top of the free-agent market, a pattern that has defined much of the Jed Hoyer era. Instead of chasing the biggest names, the front office has often gravitated toward lower-cost arms with some pedigree but plenty of questions, and this search is shaping up the same way as it weighs options like Sean Newcomb, Kyle Freeland and Frankie Montas.
Each comes with a reason to pause. Newcomb has bounced around trying to reclaim consistency, Freeland has had stretches where he looks like a stabilizing starter but not always enough of one, and Montas brings the kind of recent uncertainty that makes any commitment feel risky. For a Cubs team still trying to build a dependable rotation, the issue is not finding pitchers who are available. It is finding one who can be trusted to hold up over a full season, and that is the part of this search that remains unresolved. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Linked To Former Top Pitching Prize As Rotation Search Deepens
The Cubs are already working through the kind of offseason pitching shopping list that usually signals bigger intentions ahead, with the starting rotation clearly at the center of the conversation. Chicago is looking at a blend of reclamation arms and more established additions as it tries to build toward the 2027 season, and one name now in the mix is a pitcher who only recently looked like one of the more intriguing young arms in the game.
Luis Gils profile still carries plenty of appeal because of what he once represented, even if his recent path has been interrupted by injuries and a reduced workload. For the Cubs, the question is whether a club willing to bet on upside can find enough value in a pitcher whose recent stretches have been uneven, but whose ceiling still makes him worth monitoring as the rotation picture continues to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Face A Risky Rotation Decision With This Free Agent Target
The Cubs are again staring at the kind of rotation gamble that can look smart in November and feel very different by July. Kris Bubic, a left-hander with real upside when he is on the mound, has become one of the more intriguing free-agent names because the talent has always been there, even if the availability has not. His recent injury history, including a rotator cuff strain and Tommy John surgery, has kept him from building much momentum, but the performance indicators when he has been healthy are enough to keep clubs interested.
For Chicago, the appeal is obvious: a pitcher with starting experience and enough arm talent to make a front office wonder if it can buy low and get a useful rotation piece in return. The risk is just as clear, since Bubic enters the market with durability questions that no projection model can fully smooth over. Industry sources believe he may land as a starter this offseason, and that is exactly what makes him the sort of reclamation project teams like the Cubs have to weigh carefully. [Read more 🡒]
