The Chicago Cubs have some big decisions ahead after their NL Wild Card exit, and the biggest one in the outfield may come down to which fan favorite they can realistically keep.
Pete Crow-Armstrong is going to win the NL MVP award, and the Cubs already have plenty of good pieces locked in. But Ian Happ and Seiya Suzuki are both headed toward uncertainty, and that gives Chicago a tricky offseason wrinkle with two popular outfielders at once.
Joel Reuter of Bleacher Report thinks the Cubs will choose Suzuki.
“Chicago Cubs: OF Seiya Suzuki (Age: 32)... With a 131 OPS+ and 26 home runs in a 5.1-WAR season, Suzuki looks like the hardest to replace, given the lack of impact bats on the market," Reuter writes. "Verdict: Re-sign."
That’s the key issue for Chicago: both Happ and Suzuki reaching the market at the same time makes it tough to keep everybody unless Happ is willing to take a discount. Reuter’s read is that the Cubs are more likely to lock up one of the two on a long-term deal, and Suzuki is the likelier choice.
And it’s not hard to see why. Suzuki just put together the best season of his five years with the Cubs, finishing at 5.1 bWAR in 143 games. He also crossed the 100-homer mark for his big league career, slugged 26 home runs, drove in 86 runs, and hit .270 with an .841 OPS.
The bat was strong, but the full package mattered too. His overall value to the Cubs went well beyond offense this year, making him a tough player to replace if Chicago has to choose.
Losing both Suzuki and Happ in the same offseason would be a heavy blow. Keeping at least one would be the goal, and based on the way Suzuki just performed, he looks like the safer bet to stay in Chicago.
In Other News...
Jed Hoyer Just Put Trade Pressure On Key Cubs Youngsters
The Cubs are staring at a roster reset that could arrive sooner than most fans might expect. With a wave of pitchers heading toward free agency in 2027 and more than $100 million in salary set to come off the books, Chicago will have room to rework the roster in a serious way, whether that means chasing outside help or using its financial flexibility to make bigger swings in the trade market.
For the young players trying to establish themselves now, that future matters. Matt Shaw, Pedro Ramirez, Kevin Alcantara and Jordan Wicks all sit in the conversation as possible trade pieces as the Cubs look ahead to reshaping the team, which puts a different kind of pressure on their development and staying power. In a market like this, the organizations next moves may depend as much on which prospects prove indispensable as on who becomes available elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Still Have One Edward Cabrera Decision Hanging Over This Offseason
The Cubs have been busy filling out their organizational depth with a wave of international free-agent minor-league signings, another reminder that this front office is already looking well beyond the headline moves of the winter. There is also plenty to like on the big-league side, with Pete Crow-Armstrong earning Baseball Americas Player of the Year honors after a season in which he led MLB in home runs, runs and OPS.
Still, one pitching question hangs over the offseason picture: Edward Cabrera. Chicago has been studying the right-handers struggles and views blister problems and mechanical issues as part of the explanation, which makes his case more than a simple talent evaluation. For a club trying to sharpen its rotation plans, figuring out what Cabrera is and what he can still become feels like one of the decisions that could shape the rest of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Dansby Swanson Is Becoming A Bigger Cubs Problem Than Expected
Dansby Swansons place in the Cubs lineup has become a more complicated talking point than anyone expected after a rough 2026 at the plate. His bat slipped below league average, and the underlying numbers backed up the eye test, with career lows in batting average and on-base percentage plus noticeable drops in hard-hit rate and exit velocity. For a player who has been a fixture in the middle of the infield and part of the clubs core plan, the offensive dip has started to weigh on more than just his own production.
Chicago can live with some glove-first value from a shortstop, but not forever when the contract is still carrying through the next three seasons. The Cubs are facing a roster-building choice now: keep banking on a rebound from Swanson in 2027, or lean into other areas of the roster, especially pitching, while sorting out how much offense they can afford to lose from a premium position. [Read more 🡒]