Justin Steele’s latest rehab outing may have put the Cubs at a crossroads.
The left-hander turned in his sharpest work yet Friday night, and it came in a way that was hard to miss: 2.0 scoreless, hitless innings against Omaha, five strikeouts, and just 33 pitches. He faced seven batters, missed plenty of bats, and looked far more comfortable than he had in his earlier rehab appearances.
That kind of step forward matters because Steele has been working his way back from left elbow surgery since April of 2025. The return has been slow, but the signs have started to stack up over the past couple of weeks. In four rehab outings so far, he owns a 4.70 ERA with 11 strikeouts, a small sample that still shows a pitcher trending in the right direction.
Friday may also have marked the end of that ramp-up. The source of the next move is now the Cubs’ call, and it’s a real one: bring Steele back for the stretch run, or play it safe and hold him back. He is 31, and the question is whether the team saw enough to trust him with a role in the push for October.
Chicago has already made a conservative call with Shelby Miller, another pitcher returning from Tommy John Surgery. Miller was flashing high-90s velocity and looking like a possible lift for the bullpen, but the Cubs chose to shut him down for the rest of the year instead.
That precedent hangs over Steele’s situation now.
There’s also the workload piece. Steele has thrown just 7.2 innings since September 2, so the sample remains tiny.
The expectation is that if he returns, it would be in a bullpen role, which could let Craig Counsell monitor his innings more closely. Even so, it would still mean a major change in responsibility for a pitcher who has spent the rehab process rebuilding step by step.
The risk is obvious: bring him up too fast, ask for too much, and set back the progress he’s made. With the future of the rotation still open-ended, there’s even an argument for waiting and letting him reset for 2027 in a starting role.
But the Cubs are also staring at a tense situation right now. The Wild Card race is tight, the fight for home-field advantage is real, and the bullpen hasn’t inspired much confidence. Against that backdrop, Steele looks like the kind of arm who could matter immediately.
So the decision is sitting right there in front of them. After his best rehab appearance yet, the Cubs have to decide how aggressive they want to be.
In Other News...
Cubs Fans Have One More Reason To Love Their Core Right Now
The Cubs have spent the past stretch making a clear point about where theyre headed, and Pete Crow-Armstrong is now part of that long-term picture after signing a six-year, $115 million extension. It comes on the heels of the club locking in Nico Hoerner on a six-year, $135 million deal and adding Alex Bregman in free agency, a set of moves that gives Chicago a legitimate core to build around for years rather than months.
For a fan base that has waited to see a plan sharpen into something concrete, the timing matters almost as much as the money. Chicago has secured its own foundation, while elsewhere in the division theres still uncertainty around top talent and long-range commitment, which only adds to the sense that the Cubs are trying to get ahead of the usual roster churn before it arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Pete Crow-Armstrongs MVP Rise Started With One Big Change
Pete Crow-Armstrongs breakout season has given the Cubs exactly the kind of star turn they have spent years hoping to see, and the latest surge only added to the sense that something bigger is unfolding. In a recent game, he launched two home runs and added a triple, pushing his OPS to .956 and layering more milestones onto a year already packed with them. He now owns the Cubs record for most single-season home runs by a left-handed hitter and has tied Ernie Banks for the most homers by a Cub before age 25 with 44.
Behind the power, though, there has been a quieter evolution that helps explain why this has looked sustainable rather than fleeting. Hitting coach Dustin Kelly has pointed to better plate discipline, more selective aggression and Crow-Armstrongs ability to do damage across the strike zone as the foundation of the jump. For the Cubs, the appeal is obvious: this is not just a hot streak from a young player, but a version of him that seems built to keep forcing pitchers into tough choices. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs May Face A Brutal Matt Shaw Decision This Offseason
The Cubs are heading into an offseason that could reshape a lot of the roster, with the entire starting rotation among the groups set to hit free agency and several position players joining them. That kind of turnover puts pressure on the front office to find pitching help, and it also forces some hard conversations about which younger pieces can be moved to fill the biggest needs.
Matt Shaw has become part of that discussion because of his versatility, which makes him useful to the Cubs and appealing to other clubs at the same time. Teams such as the Mariners and Blue Jays have been floated as possible fits if Chicago decides to use Shaw as a trade chip, but for now it remains a matter of fit and leverage, with no deal actually lined up and the bigger question still hanging over how far the Cubs are willing to go to patch the rotation. [Read more 🡒]