Cubs Could Feel David Peterson Loss More Than Fans Expect

Rockies intensify their pursuit of pitching prowess as David Peterson emerges as a prime target for their rotation upgrade.

The Rockies are still shopping for more help on the mound, and David Peterson has emerged as one of the names on their list.

Colorado already added two rotation pieces in last night’s trade for Luis Castillo and Davis Martin from the White Sox, but the search isn’t done. Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic reported that the Rockies are interested in Peterson, while ESPN’s Jeff Passan said this week that the club has been “aggressive” in its hunt for free agent starters and has been dangling multi-year deals at prices that reflect the realities of pitching in their home park.

Peterson could make sense for more than one reason. He was born in California, but he spent his teen years in Colorado and went to high school just 20 miles southeast of Coors Field, which gives the Rockies a possible homecoming angle as they try to sell him on the move.

The left-hander turned 31 in September and has spent most of his career with the Mets. His platform year got off to a rough start, and that stretch helped drag down New York before the Mets traded him to the Cubs in June. Peterson’s first outing in Chicago was ugly, but he settled down after that, which fits the profile of a ground-ball pitcher changing scenery from one of baseball’s weakest defensive teams to one of its best infield groups.

With the Mets, Peterson made 16 appearances, including eight starts, and was hit hard for a 6.09 ERA. Even so, his strikeout, walk and ground-ball numbers stayed in line with his 2024-25 levels, when he logged 289 2/3 innings and posted a 3.67 ERA. The big difference in New York was a .350 average on balls in play, roughly 60 points above league average.

In 16 games for the Cubs, including 15 starts, Peterson put up a 3.70 ERA over 80 1/3 innings with a roughly average .293 BABIP. His strikeout rate ticked up, but so did his walk and home run rates. After giving up 10 earned runs in his second start for Chicago, he steadied himself and finished the year with a 2.66 ERA over his final 71 innings.

The fit with Colorado is easy to see. Peterson has now finished four straight seasons with a ground-ball rate above 50%, and he sat at 49.2% and 49.4% in the two years before that.

Coors Field is tough on pitchers because of the home-run risk and the big gaps that can turn balls into extra bases, but the Rockies do have quality defenders at third base, shortstop and first base in Kyle Karros, Ezequiel Tovar and TJ Rumfield, even if Tovar didn’t have his best defensive season in ’26. The park also plays a little friendlier for left-handed hitters, and Peterson has handled them well over his career, holding them to a .235/.299/.363 line compared with .262/.348/.400 against righties.

His late-season work with the Cubs and his broader track record suggest the rough 2026 in Queens may have been more blip than warning sign. From 2022-25, Peterson posted a 4.00 ERA with a strikeout per inning and a 52.5% ground-ball rate. That kind of profile should put him in line for a multi-year deal no matter where he lands, and Colorado could try to win the bidding by going heavier on the annual salary or by adding a third year.

Even if Peterson signs elsewhere, the Rockies’ interest, their trade with the White Sox and their willingness to talk multi-year offers point to a different approach than the one they used last winter. In the 2025-26 offseason, Colorado leaned on one-year deals for pitchers with deep arsenals, bringing in Michael Lorenzen, Jose Quintana and Tomoyuki Sugano for $8 million or less.

That plan didn’t work. Sugano led the team with 29 starts and 154 1/3 innings but finished with a 5.37 ERA and nearly two homers allowed per nine innings.

Lorenzen was released after putting up an ERA above 7.00 in 115 2/3 innings, and injuries limited Quintana to 48 innings with a 5.44 ERA.

In Other News...

Cubs Just Got A New Problem In Their Rotation Search

The White Soxs decision to move Luis Castillo to Colorado, with the Rockies taking on the contract and the $24.15 million owed in 2027, adds another wrinkle to the market the Cubs are watching closely. Chicagos crosstown rival also included Davis Martin in the deal, a move that frees up financial room and gives the Sox more flexibility heading into the offseason.

For the Cubs, the timing matters because they are still sorting through the starting pitching market, and any team with extra spending power can complicate the chase. If the White Sox decide to use that newfound flexibility aggressively, it could affect both the price and the competition for the kind of arms the Cubs are likely targeting as they try to strengthen the rotation. [Read more 🡒]

Cubs Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Catcher Plans

The Cubs added another layer to their catching picture by claiming Joey Bart off waivers from the White Sox after he was designated for assignment earlier in the week. It is the kind of move that usually flies under the radar in November, but it says plenty about how Chicago is sorting through its options behind the plate and trying to build some stability around the position.

Bart now lands in a spot where the next step appears to be more than just a short-term look. The Cubs are expected to tender him a contract for 2027 before the deadline, a sign they see enough value to keep him in the fold and let the situation develop from there. [Read more 🡒]

Cubs May Be Running Out Of Time To Fix A Major Weakness

The Cubs are still trying to do some late offseason repair work before the MLB lockout freezes the market on Dec. 1, and the front office's priority is clear: add pitching and shore up the roster around the edges. Chicago has already brought in a few arms through minor league deals and waiver claims, including Justin Lawrence, Bruno Lpez and Chayce McDermott, while also keeping tabs on free-agent options overseas and in the domestic market.

There is still a need for more than depth, though. The Cubs want additional pitching help and could use another outfield piece as well, which makes the clock feel even tighter with the deadline approaching. The longer the market stays open without a move, the more this becomes a question of whether Chicago can address a major weakness in time or has to carry it into the winter pause. [Read more 🡒]