The Cubs’ offseason decisions are already coming into focus, and one of the biggest questions is what happens with a pair of veteran outfielders.
Joel Reuter of Bleacher Report is predicting Chicago will keep Seiya Suzuki and catcher Carson Kelly, while Ian Happ heads elsewhere. In Reuter’s view, the Cubs will work out a new two-year deal for Kelly and bring Suzuki back, but not Happ.
“The Cubs have some decisions to make with Seiya Suzuki and Ian Happ both ticketed for free agency, along with catcher Carson Kelly's mutual option,” Reuter writes. “The safe bet right now is that they will retain one, but not both, of those outfielders, while also working out a new two-year pact to keep Kelly.”
If that projection plays out, Suzuki would return to right field, Kelly would remain behind the plate, and Matt Shaw would take over in left field.
The Cubs are also staring at bigger issues in the pitching staff, with Shota Imanaga, Clay Holmes, Kevin Gausman, and others all reaching free agency at the same time. That makes it easier to understand why one of the veteran outfielders could end up being the odd man out.
If Chicago has to choose between Happ and Suzuki, Suzuki’s 2026 season gives him the edge. He’s at 4.7 bWAR in what has been a career year, while Happ has posted 2.7 bWAR with 23 homers and a .219 batting average.
Happ has been steady, but he hasn’t matched the level he showed over the previous four seasons. His 102 OPS+ is the lowest of his career since 2018.
Whether that’s a one-year dip or the start of something more, the numbers are pushing the Cubs toward a tough call. Right now, the case for moving on from Happ is stronger than the one for letting Suzuki go.
In Other News...
Craig Counsell Faces Growing Heat As Cubs' Real Problem Gets Harder To Ignore
Craig Counsell has spent much of the 2026 season absorbing frustration from Cubs fans, and it has not been hard to understand why. A team that entered September still with a strong playoff chance has also spent long stretches dealing with the kind of uneven pitching that can make every series feel like a strain, especially when injuries have thinned the rotation and the bullpen has struggled to hold things together.
Counsell is the most visible target when the pressure rises, but the bigger issue in Chicago has been larger than the managers lineup card. The Cubs have had to patch together innings and work around the absence of key arms, and that has made the margin for error awfully thin. Even with the criticism growing louder, the real test for this club is whether it can keep surviving those pitching problems long enough to turn a promising position into something more. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Bench Decision Suddenly Looks Riskier In A Tight Playoff Race
The Cubs September roster shuffle was supposed to give Craig Counsell more flexibility as the playoff push tightens, but one of the younger additions has already been put in a tough spot. B.J. Murray Jr. was called up as part of the expanded roster, yet his limited major league time has brought little offense, which made the decision to use him in a high-leverage moment stand out all the more.
Counsell has leaned on roster depth to navigate a crowded race, but every late-game choice now carries extra weight with the postseason picture so compressed. When a bench bat is asked to handle a critical matchup against a strong reliever, the stakes are bigger than one at-bat, because those are the kinds of decisions that can shape how a team is judged when October arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Top Prospect Is Suddenly Facing A Much Bigger Test
Josiah Hartshorns rise through the Cubs farm system is moving fast enough to make the next step feel imminent. Chicagos top prospect is reportedly expected to jump from High-A South Bend to Double-A Knoxville, a move the organization has not officially announced yet but one that would match the kind of season he has put together across Single-A and High-A.
For a player in his first minor league season, the challenge changes quickly once he gets to Knoxville. The offensive success that put Hartshorn on the map has already carried him through two levels, and a debut with the Smokies would give the Cubs a better read on how his game plays against more advanced pitching while also potentially stretching his 2026 season deeper into the summer. [Read more 🡒]