Stephen Vogt got the Guardians exactly where they wanted to be: Game 5 of the American League Division Series. The problem now is the part that comes next - figuring out how to get through it on the mound.
Cleveland’s 9-5 win over the White Sox on Thursday at Rate Field came with a heavy price tag. Vogt emptied plenty of his bullpen, stretched closer Cade Smith beyond the usual lane, and then had to call on Gavin Williams, the starter who had been lined up for Saturday’s winner-take-all game at Progressive Field, to finish the night.
That was not the original plan. Williams was supposed to stay on schedule for Game 5, with Vogt saying before Game 4 that he would throw a bullpen session during Thursday’s game if Cleveland was in position to win. Instead, Williams ended up warming in the ninth with the Guardians protecting a five-run lead and then took over in relief for the final three outs.
Does that mean he’s out as the Game 5 starter? Not automatically. But it definitely puts Cleveland in a bind.
“The script tonight got ripped up in the third,” Vogt said. “And when you have to go to the bullpen early, you’ve got to get creative in a win-or-go-home.”
The trouble began when rookie Parker Messick lost his command in the third inning, forcing Vogt to go to Shawn Armstrong earlier than expected. Cleveland later used three pitchers in the fifth, which kept chipping away at the group of arms it had left.
By the time the game reached the eighth, Vogt had already tapped into his high-leverage relievers. Hunter Gaddis was still available, and Daniel Espino was another possible option with Cleveland holding a comfortable lead. Vogt instead chose Smith.
That was notable enough on its own. Smith had thrown only 19 pitches while recording six outs, five of them strikeouts, in Wednesday’s Game 3 win.
On Thursday, he needed 19 more pitches to get through the eighth, then came back out for the ninth. That’s when the night turned.
Smith gave up a leadoff homer to Miguel Vargas and then walked Munetaka Murakami, which brought Vogt to the mound again. Williams entered from there, allowed a single to Sam Antonacci, struck out Andrew Benintendi on three pitches, got Kyle Teel to ground into a force out, and watched Braden Montgomery line out to Steven Kwan in left to end it.
Vogt said Williams was only available for one inning, though that still wasn’t the preferred route.
“Obviously, didn’t want to have to do that,” Vogt said. “But in that moment, with Cade - Colson Montgomery, it was a great at-bat off Cade pushing the pitch count up. It was time to go get Gavin.”
He added that he wanted Williams to face a hitter before the tying run could reach the plate.
Now Cleveland has questions hanging over two of its biggest pitchers. Smith finished Thursday with 31 pitches after also working two innings Wednesday.
Williams, who threw six innings in Monday’s Game 2 loss, now has just one day of rest after his relief outing before a possible Game 5 start. Vogt still said Smith would be available Saturday.
“Outside of Cade, don’t feel like we’ve really overextended too many bullpen guys,” Vogt said. “Cade is a warrior and he steps up for these guys every night, and I know he’ll be ready to go on Saturday.”
White Sox manager Will Venable noticed the workload Cleveland had to absorb just to keep the series alive.
“Small victories there, I think,” Venable said when asked about forcing Smith to work and getting Williams into the game. “I also think that those guys will be ready to go.”
Venable also said Sean Burke will pitch for Chicago in Game 5, though he did not officially name him the starter. Chicago will sort through its arms before settling on a plan.
Cleveland is in the same spot, only with its presumed Game 5 starter already used in emergency relief.
Vogt still could go back to Williams, maybe with a shorter leash than originally planned. Espino, Joey Cantillo and other available pitchers could also be part of another unconventional plan.
And if the Guardians get through Saturday and move on to face Tampa Bay in Monday’s AL Championship Series opener, the pitching puzzle gets even bigger. Vogt isn’t looking that far ahead.
“We’ll worry about that on Monday if we’re fortunate to get there,” Vogt said. “This is what playoff baseball is about. It’s about all hands on deck.”
In Other News...
Jed Hoyer Just Put Trade Pressure On Key Cubs Youngsters
The Cubs are staring at a roster reset that could arrive sooner than most fans might expect. With a wave of pitchers heading toward free agency in 2027 and more than $100 million in salary set to come off the books, Chicago will have room to rework the roster in a serious way, whether that means chasing outside help or using its financial flexibility to make bigger swings in the trade market.
For the young players trying to establish themselves now, that future matters. Matt Shaw, Pedro Ramirez, Kevin Alcantara and Jordan Wicks all sit in the conversation as possible trade pieces as the Cubs look ahead to reshaping the team, which puts a different kind of pressure on their development and staying power. In a market like this, the organizations next moves may depend as much on which prospects prove indispensable as on who becomes available elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Still Have One Edward Cabrera Decision Hanging Over This Offseason
The Cubs have been busy filling out their organizational depth with a wave of international free-agent minor-league signings, another reminder that this front office is already looking well beyond the headline moves of the winter. There is also plenty to like on the big-league side, with Pete Crow-Armstrong earning Baseball Americas Player of the Year honors after a season in which he led MLB in home runs, runs and OPS.
Still, one pitching question hangs over the offseason picture: Edward Cabrera. Chicago has been studying the right-handers struggles and views blister problems and mechanical issues as part of the explanation, which makes his case more than a simple talent evaluation. For a club trying to sharpen its rotation plans, figuring out what Cabrera is and what he can still become feels like one of the decisions that could shape the rest of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Face A Tough Fan Favorite Decision In The Outfield
The Cubs could be staring at one of their trickiest offseason calls in the outfield, and it involves two players who matter for very different reasons. Seiya Suzuki turned in a strong season with a 5.1 WAR, 26 home runs and a .270 batting average, giving Chicago the kind of middle-of-the-order production that is hard to replace, while Ian Happ remains one of the more familiar and popular faces on the roster.
Financial reality may end up forcing the issue, because keeping both free-agent outfielders will not be easy. Joel Reuter of Bleacher Report sees the Cubs leaning toward a Suzuki reunion over Happ, a sign that the front office may have to make a choice between roster continuity and the kind of offensive impact that Suzuki provided this year. [Read more 🡒]