Alex Bregman has given the Cubs something Kyle Tucker never really did: a star presence that held up when the season got long and the spotlight got hotter.
That contrast matters because Tucker’s lone year in Chicago was always going to be judged by more than the raw totals. Some defenders point to his overall numbers last season and argue it wasn’t a failure, but that view skips the part where he faded badly in the final two months of the regular season and then all but vanished once the playoffs arrived.
Bregman’s first months with the Cubs weren’t exactly smooth, and there was even a short-lived heel turn in there. But the second half changed the conversation. By the end of the regular season, his production had climbed to the level people expected from the start, and in some ways beyond it.
Through 681 plate appearances this season, Bregman is hitting .264/.354/.458 with a 126 wRC+. His 5.2 fWAR is the fourth-best total of his career, and he still has a shot to pass the 5.4 mark he posted with the Houston Astros in 2022.
The Cubs’ decision not to engage with Tucker’s free agency last year is still the backdrop for all of this. Jed Hoyer and Co. were clearly willing to push outside their usual comfort zone, but Tucker was not the player they chose to do it for.
If the 2026 season is any guide, Bregman is the guy they were actually waiting for.
Tucker, meanwhile, has not looked anything like the version Chicago once had in mind. Through 588 plate appearances with the Los Angeles Dodgers, he is slashing .226/.327/.373 with a 96 wRC+.
That gap is the real story. Bregman hasn’t just outproduced Tucker; he’s blown past him. And now that the bat has matched the expectations, the difference off the field stands out even more.
“I said, 'Alex, you don't get to see things like this.' ... (the fans are) gonna tell their kids about it, they're gonna tell their grandkids about it, seasons like this."
Craig Counsell and Alex Bregman paused to soak in the historic season PCA is having 👏 pic.twitter.com/LIfgOwyaRl
- Marquee Sports Network (@WatchMarquee) September 17, 2026
Tucker, for better or worse, came off like a mercenary. He was in Chicago to do a job: post numbers, set himself up for free agency, and help put the Cubs in position to contend.
On that level, it worked well enough. But once the production dipped, it became easier to see how much the arrangement was built around him.
Bregman has been different. The report from this season is of a player who keeps the team in the center of everything, whether that means texting Craig Counsell late at night or working with teammates like Pete Crow-Armstrong. He still handles his own business, but he does it without making the Cubs feel like an afterthought.
That’s the piece Chicago never had with Tucker.
In Other News...
Former Cubs Draft Pick Just Lost His Shot At October
Rob Zastryznys season took another turn this week when the Milwaukee Brewers designated the former Cubs draft pick for assignment after a minor-league rehab assignment, closing the book on what had been a possible route back into a postseason bullpen. Injuries and a drop in velocity have clouded his 2026 campaign, and the timing leaves little room for another club to jump in and turn him into an October option.
For the Cubs, it is another reminder that bullpen help is more likely to come from within than from a familiar name elsewhere. Chicago has already been looking at its own internal arms for late-season support, with Gavin Hollowell among the pitchers in the conversation, while Zastryznys path now looks more like a reset than a race to the playoffs. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs' October Lineup Debate Just Got A Lot More Interesting
Dansby Swanson is expected back with the Cubs this weekend, and his return should give Chicago the kind of full-strength position-player group teams spend all summer trying to preserve for October. It also pushes the playoff conversation into a more interesting place, because the Cubs now have to map out how they want to balance their best defenders, their most dangerous bats and the matchups that can tilt a short series.
Michael Busch, Ian Happ and Michael Conforto are all part of that planning, and the shape of the lineup could change depending on whether the opponent is starting a right-hander or a left-hander. Once the games matter most, the question is no longer who belongs on the roster, but who gets the at-bats when every decision feels like it could decide an inning, a game or an entire series. [Read more 🡒]
Pete Crow-Armstrong Is Turning The Cubs' MVP Dream Into A Rout
Pete Crow-Armstrong has gone from exciting young centerpiece to the kind of player who can shape an entire MVP race. His 2026 season has stood out on both sides of the ball, with the Cubs benefiting from impact offense and elite defense in center field, the sort of all-around profile that gives a team real star power every night.
Bradford Doolittles AXE metric at ESPN reflects just how far ahead Crow-Armstrong has pulled from the rest of the National League field. With some of the other usual contenders dealing with injuries, including Shohei Ohtani, the Cubs are watching the conversation narrow around their own breakout star, and the rest of the league may be running out of time to catch him. [Read more 🡒]