The Edmonton Oilers have leaned hard into second chances in recent years, but that approach is starting to carry a real cost with their own fan base.
It began with two notable additions who arrived with serious baggage: Evander Kane and Corey Perry. Edmonton took a swing on both after their previous contracts were terminated, and both players went on to become strong contributors. But the success of those gambles hasn’t softened the bigger concern around the organization’s direction.
That concern only grew when the Oilers hired Stan Bowman as general manager in July 2024. Bowman brought a championship résumé, including three Stanley Cup titles with the Chicago Blackhawks, but his name was also tied to the fallout from the Blackhawks scandal.
He resigned as Chicago’s GM in October 2021 after an investigation found the organization mishandled and failed to act on sexual assault allegations against video coach Brad Aldrich in 2010. Edmonton brought him in just three years later.
The front office doubled down on that path with Mike Babcock, another hire that came loaded with controversy. Babcock had not won anything in over 15 years, and after leaving the Toronto Maple Leafs in 2019, Brendan Shanahan said Babcock’s coaching tactics “weren’t appropriate or acceptable.”
There were also allegations of mental abuse. His next stop with the Columbus Blue Jackets never got off the ground; he resigned in 2023 before coaching a game, and while the NHL investigated and cleared him to find employment, that didn’t erase the baggage surrounding him.
The latest move is the one that seems to have pushed things too far for some supporters. Edmonton signed Alex Formenton to a one-year deal with an $850,000 cap hit.
Formenton had spent the last few seasons in the Swiss league and, according to the source, wasn’t impressive there. He was also one of five players from Canada’s 2018 World Junior team charged with sexual assault.
After a highly publicized trial, all five were acquitted in July 2025 and later reinstated into the NHL.
Even with the acquittal, the signing has been enough to alienate at least one of the team’s most visible supporters. Mary Loewen, known to Oilers fans as “Momma Stanley” for dressing as the Stanley Cup during the playoffs, said she would no longer back the team.
“I am deeply disappointed by the Edmonton Oilers’ decision to sign Alex Formenton. Although he was acquitted in court, I cannot ignore my conscience or what this decision represents to me.
As a sexual assault survivor, I must stand by my morals and stand with the woman at the centre of this case. For that reason, as long as Formenton remains an Oiler, I cannot and will not support or cheer for this team”, she stated.
The Oilers were one win away from the Stanley Cup in 2024, but the source argues these moves have turned them into a team many outside Edmonton won’t want to see succeed. More than that, they may be pushing away some of the very people who once rode hardest with them.
In Other News...
Blackhawks Fans Are Still Waiting On One Key Prospect Showcase Detail
The Blackhawks 2026 Prospect Showcase is set to get underway this week, with practices and games centered at the Blackhawks Ice Center and a roster of prospects coming in from a mix of leagues and teams. Fans can watch the practices in person, and tickets for the games are being sold through Ticketmaster, giving the start of camp a familiar late-summer feel as the organization begins another look at its next wave of talent.
One detail remains unsettled, though, and it is the one plenty of fans are watching closest: there has been no official confirmation yet on whether the scrimmages will be live-streamed this year. For a fan base that likes to track every development in the pipeline, the difference matters, especially with the showcase serving as one of the first chances to see how Chicagos prospects stack up in a competitive setting. [Read more 🡒]
Blackhawks Owe Jonathan Toews The Farewell He Never Got
Jonathan Toews closed the book on his NHL career on June 19, announcing his retirement after one season with the Winnipeg Jets following a two-year hiatus. For Blackhawks fans, it was another reminder of how abruptly one of the defining players in franchise history slipped into the next chapter, leaving behind three Stanley Cups and the distinction of being the youngest captain in team history.
Kyle Davidson has said Chicago would like to give Toews the sort of farewell his career deserves, but nothing has been finalized. The idea is simple enough: find a proper way to let him finish where so much of his legacy was built, and make sure the ending matches the impact he had on the organization, even if the details of that sendoff are still being worked out. [Read more 🡒]
Blackhawks Blue-Line Rebuild Still Hinges On One Bowen Byram Decision
The Blackhawks blue-line rebuild has a promising foundation, but it still comes with a familiar roster question: how to make Bowen Byram fit best. Chicago has a strong cluster of young left-handed defensemen, which gives the organization some real upside on the back end, yet the alignment problem remains. Byram brings a lot to the table, and the challenge is finding the right partner and the right side of the ice to get the most out of him.
For now, the team can look at short-term fixes, but none of them feel like a clean answer for the long haul. A veteran right-shot defenseman would make the most sense as a complement, though those players are hard to come by, especially for a team trying to keep building around youth. Until that piece shows up, the Blackhawks are left weighing whether to shuffle Byram into a temporary role or keep searching for the kind of fit that can stabilize the entire defensive picture. [Read more 🡒]