The Blackhawks’ Stanley Cup era already looks loaded on paper, but one 2005 draft decision still hangs over it: Jack Skille at No. 7 instead of Anze Kopitar.
That choice is the kind of fork in the road that can reshape everything. Skille played 368 NHL games, but he never came close to matching the value of a seventh overall pick.
His NHL line ended at 43 goals and 84 points, even though he put together solid AHL numbers with the Rockford IceHogs, posting 59 goals and 128 points in 180 games. In Chicago, he appeared in 79 games across parts of four seasons, with his best stretch coming in 2010-11, when he scored seven goals and 17 points in 49 games before being traded to the Florida Panthers.
Stan Bowman later turned that deal into Michael Frolik, who became part of the 2013 Stanley Cup team.
Kopitar, meanwhile, became exactly the kind of center a franchise dreams about landing. He did not make his NHL debut until 2006, so he would not have affected the Blackhawks’ 2006 draft decision on Jonathan Toews. But if Chicago had taken him in 2005, the team would have had a very different spine almost immediately.
In his rookie season, Kopitar scored 20 goals and 61 points. If those numbers had come in a Blackhawks sweater, he would have led the team in points and tied for second in goals.
Chicago finished that season with the fifth-worst record, which left it eligible for the first overall pick in the draft lottery. The source of the what-if gets even more interesting from there: if Kopitar had been on the 2006-07 roster, maybe the Blackhawks finish higher and miss out on Kane.
Or maybe they still land the lottery win. For the sake of the scenario, assume the draft order stays the same and Kane still arrives.
That’s where the imagination really takes off. Kopitar and Toews down the middle would have given Chicago a pair of Hall of Fame centers, and the Blackhawks would have been even tougher defensively.
Bowman’s later search for a second-line center might never have happened, which means moves like Michal Handzus, Brad Richards, and Antoine Vermette may not have been necessary. The idea here is simple: with Kopitar in the mix, Chicago might have been good enough to win three straight Cups.
There’s also the ripple effect beyond Chicago. The source points out that the Kings likely would not have reached the 2014 Western Conference Finals without Kopitar.
Kopitar spent his entire career in Los Angeles, piling up 452 goals and 1,316 points in 1,521 games. Whether he would have played all 20 of his NHL seasons in Chicago is another matter.
Probably not, especially if Kyle Davidson eventually moved on from Toews and Kane during the rebuild. But even if the ending changed, the middle could have looked very different.
That’s the bigger lure of this alternate timeline. Kopitar’s presence could have stretched the Blackhawks’ championship window.
In 2017-18, Chicago missed the playoffs for the first time, but Kopitar was coming off a career year with 35 goals and 92 points, a total that would have led the Blackhawks. Put that production on that roster, and maybe the season doesn’t collapse the same way.
The next year brought another twist. Toews and Kane both had career seasons, Alex DeBrincat scored 41 goals, and the Blackhawks still missed the playoffs. With Kopitar in Chicago, maybe Joel Quenneville doesn’t get fired 15 games into the season and replaced by Jeremy Colliton, a move that turned out badly.
None of it can be proven, of course. But the idea is hard to shake: one different first-round pick in 2005, and the greatest era in Blackhawks history might have looked even greater.
In Other News...
The Yzerplan Just Hit A Stunning Turning Point In Detroit
The ripple effects of the NHL offseason keep reaching Chicago, where the Blackhawks are still watching a league-wide reset unfold around them. Detroits long-running Yzerplan has reached a major turning point, while several other clubs have been busy locking up young talent and filling out their staffs, a reminder that the leagues next wave of moves is already taking shape.
For the Blackhawks, the more immediate focus is their own schedule and the challenge that comes with it. Chicago has learned its first four home and road opponents, and the season will open with three straight road games against playoff teams, all without Connor Bedard, a difficult early test for a team trying to build momentum while the rest of the conference keeps shifting. [Read more 🡒]
Blackhawks Fans Still Have One Big Connor Murphy Debate
Connor Murphys run with the Blackhawks was never going to be the flashiest part of the rebuild, but it still left a mark. In 60 games in Chicago, the veteran defenseman settled into a third-pairing role, chipped in 13 points and did plenty of the quiet work that tends to matter more when a team is trying to stabilize its blue line than when it is chasing headlines.
The debate for Blackhawks fans is whether that kind of dependable presence was worth moving on from when the front office had a chance to cash in. Chicago did land a 2028 second-round pick in the deal, which gives the trade some long-term appeal, but Murphys value was always tied to the kind of minutes and matchup work that are hard to replace cleanly. For a team still sorting out its defensive identity, the question lingers over whether the return matched the role he filled. [Read more 🡒]
Blackhawks May Have Passed On A Better Way To Fix Defense
The Blackhawks made their biggest defensive swing of the summer in June, sending a premium 2026 first-rounder, a second-round pick and Louis Crevier to Buffalo for Bowen Byram and Jordan Greenway, then quickly locking Byram into a $75 million contract that made him the leagues highest-paid defenseman. On paper, it was the kind of bold move a team trying to accelerate its rebuild can sell to itself, especially with a young blue line still looking for a true anchor.
But the trade also invites a harder question: whether Chicago paid for certainty in a market that may have offered more paths to the same fix. Free-agent veterans such as John Klingberg, Jacob Trouba and John Carlson were out there as possible alternatives, and there were other avenues the Blackhawks could have explored if they wanted to avoid surrendering so much future capital. Buffalo, meanwhile, turned the pick it received from Chicago into defenseman Daxon Rudolph, a reminder that the cost of landing Byram was about more than just the contract. [Read more 🡒]