In June, the Chicago Blackhawks made a move that sent their fourth overall pick in the 2026 NHL Entry Draft, their 2026 second-round pick and Louis Crevier to the Buffalo Sabres in exchange for Bowen Byram and Jordan Greenway. Not long after, the Blackhawks locked Byram into a $75 million contract, which made him the highest-paid defender in the league.
That kind of price tag naturally invites the same question: what would Chicago have done if it had kept the pick instead of chasing Byram? The answer starts with the obvious hole the Blackhawks still would have needed to fill.
Without Byram, they would have been searching for a true first-line defender, and the pressure would have landed on Alex Vlasic or Louis Crevier - who is now with the Buffalo Sabres - to take a major step forward. Another option would have been to find someone else capable of handling that role, but the market wasn’t exactly overflowing with choices.
If Chicago had decided to hang onto the fourth pick, free agency could have been the next stop. John Klingberg was one possible target, though he is much older than Byram. The Blackhawks could also have looked at Trouba or John Carlson, but neither fits as a long-term answer.
The most intriguing alternative would have been an offer sheet for Jamie Drysdale. Daniel Briere would have had to be willing to play along, and the timing mattered too - Chicago would have needed to get that done before Drysdale elected to go to arbitration. Drysdale is currently on the second pairing for the Philadelphia Flyers, but on a thinner blue line he could have been pushed into that top role.
A different trade was another path, at least in theory. Morgan Rielly’s name has been floating around in rumors tied to the Toronto Maple Leafs, but he controls his future, and a move to a team that doesn’t look like a Cup contender in the next few years probably wouldn’t fit his plans.
The draft itself gives the clearest glimpse of what Chicago gave up. Buffalo used the pick to select defenseman Daxon Rudolph, a player who fits the offensive-defenseman mold the Blackhawks would have wanted. Another comparable name, Chase Reid, went seventh overall to the Seattle Kraken.
Of course, draft picks come with a built-in delay. You never know how long it will take for a player to settle in and become what you hoped.
Byram offers something different: help now, while Bedard and Nazr are in their prime. That might be the real value in the deal.
And if you want to take the thought experiment one step further, there’s an even bigger “what if” sitting underneath all of this: what if the Blackhawks had drafted Bowen Byram back in the 2019 Entry Draft? That’s a question for another day.
In Other News...
The Yzerplan Just Hit A Stunning Turning Point In Detroit
The ripple effects of the NHL offseason keep reaching Chicago, where the Blackhawks are still watching a league-wide reset unfold around them. Detroits long-running Yzerplan has reached a major turning point, while several other clubs have been busy locking up young talent and filling out their staffs, a reminder that the leagues next wave of moves is already taking shape.
For the Blackhawks, the more immediate focus is their own schedule and the challenge that comes with it. Chicago has learned its first four home and road opponents, and the season will open with three straight road games against playoff teams, all without Connor Bedard, a difficult early test for a team trying to build momentum while the rest of the conference keeps shifting. [Read more 🡒]
Blackhawks Fans Still Have One Big Connor Murphy Debate
Connor Murphys run with the Blackhawks was never going to be the flashiest part of the rebuild, but it still left a mark. In 60 games in Chicago, the veteran defenseman settled into a third-pairing role, chipped in 13 points and did plenty of the quiet work that tends to matter more when a team is trying to stabilize its blue line than when it is chasing headlines.
The debate for Blackhawks fans is whether that kind of dependable presence was worth moving on from when the front office had a chance to cash in. Chicago did land a 2028 second-round pick in the deal, which gives the trade some long-term appeal, but Murphys value was always tied to the kind of minutes and matchup work that are hard to replace cleanly. For a team still sorting out its defensive identity, the question lingers over whether the return matched the role he filled. [Read more 🡒]