The Chicago Blackhawks were supposed to be moving forward by now. Nobody in the preseason predictions poll had them in the playoffs, but there was still an expectation that they’d take a step. Instead, they’ve gone backward, sitting 31st in the overall league standings despite a prospect pool that’s been described as comically loaded and a strong group of young NHL talent.
That leaves GM Kyle Davidson with a problem that can’t be dressed up. On Wednesday, he told reporters he was “looking to improve the playing roster,” which suggests he’s not trying to turn this into a futures-only sell-off.
So how do you fix it? The Roundtable had a few different answers.
Matt Larkin sees the Bowen Byram trade as a move that already looks ugly, but he says the thinking behind it made some sense. With so many prospects in the system, there’s only so much room to fit them all into the lineup, and the Blackhawks needed help that could matter right away.
He’d keep the 2027 first-round pick tightly in hand, with hopes it could land Landon DuPont, but he’d be open to moving other picks - including one of the eight selections they have in Rounds 1-2 this year - or other prospects to bring in a prime-age forward who can help speed up the timeline. He also pointed to the team’s huge amount of 2027-28 cap space as another way to strengthen the roster next offseason.
Paul Pidutti’s answer is less dramatic: patience. He notes that the Blackhawks’ prospects are developing slower than hoped, but says rebuilds usually take time.
In his view, it’s typically about eight-and-a-half years to go from missing the playoffs twice to making the playoffs twice. He also points out that Stan Bowman spent a half-decade chasing the postseason after the 2015 Stanley Cup, while Davidson’s teardown is still less than five years old.
Because this rebuild has been taken all the way to the ground, he says the timeline is naturally longer than most. Still, he thinks the front office could try to ease the pressure by moving a shiny prospect or two whose ceilings are questioned internally, either to get short-term help or to bring back other “change of scenery” prospects.
But the bigger point remains the same: this kind of rebuild needs four or five prospects to become high-impact NHL players to support Connor Bedard, and that kind of growth takes time.
Anthony Trudeau takes a sharper view of the roster-building approach. He says Davidson’s attempt to shield the young players has meant surrounding them with veterans other teams were eager to move on from, and he argues that strategy has not worked.
In his eyes, whoever replaces Davidson - and he says he really ought to be replaced - should focus on bringing in NHL players who aren’t already fading out of the league or pushing 37. He says tossing prospects into the lineup before they’re ready has hurt Kevin Korchinski, Artyom Leshunov, and even Connor Bedard.
Trudeau believes adding players such as Noah Cates and Jonathan Aspirot could help steady things and give Bedard, Anton Frondell, and the rest of the young core more room to work. He also notes that the Blackhawks have more promising young players than roster spots, so they aren’t short on trade assets, even if it’s fair to question how a team this hopeless is spending nearly to the salary cap.
In Other News...
Blackhawks Have Another Tyler Bertuzzi Question After A Brutal Loss
The Blackhawks are dealing with another injury concern after Tyler Bertuzzi left a recent game with an undisclosed issue, adding a fresh layer of uncertainty to a roster that has already had to manage plenty of turbulence this season. For a team trying to steady itself after a brutal loss, any question about Bertuzzi matters, because his presence changes the look of Chicagos forward group and the way the club can attack on the wing.
Around the league, the injury picture is getting crowded in a hurry, with the Utah Mammoth set to be without several key players against the San Jose Sharks and the Dallas Stars also missing important pieces on the blue line and up front. Chicagos situation is different, but no less relevant to its immediate outlook, since the Blackhawks now have to wait and see how serious Bertuzzis issue is before knowing how much more lineup shuffling may be ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Blackhawks Face A Big Lineup Decision Against Red-Hot Winnipeg
The Blackhawks head into Saturdays meeting with Winnipeg still sorting through their own lineup after an overtime win against Buffalo, a result that gave them a lift but also left the club managing player availability. Bowen Byram is day-to-day, and with the United Center matchup arriving against one of the leagues hottest teams, Chicagos pregame decisions carry a little more weight than usual.
Winnipeg comes in on a five-game winning streak and has already altered its roster picture with the trade of Connor Hellebuyck to the New Jersey Devils, adding another layer to a game that already asks plenty of Chicago. For the Blackhawks, the challenge is less about the standings and more about whether they can keep their footing against a team rolling at full speed while still navigating a lineup that is not quite settled. [Read more 🡒]
Blackhawks Let A Dream Start Turn Into Another Brutal Collapse
For a while at the United Center, it looked like the Blackhawks had finally found a night to breathe. They built a four-goal lead and had the kind of start that can settle a team, energize a crowd and put a road-weary opponent on the ropes.
Instead, Winnipeg kept chipping away until the game turned into a familiar kind of pain for Chicago, with Mark Scheifele and Kyle Connor driving the push back into it and Gabriel Vilardi forcing overtime late in regulation. The Jets finished the job in the shootout, where Nico Daws made the decisive save and left the Blackhawks staring at another collapse they could not afford. [Read more 🡒]
