Drake Maye’s opening-week stumble gave Caleb Williams’ case another boost.
The New England Patriots quarterback was tagged with three interceptions in the fourth quarter of the season opener against the Seattle Seahawks, and that kind of finish is the sort of thing that can flip the conversation in a hurry. One rough game, one ugly stretch, and suddenly all the noise around the 2024 quarterback class is back on full blast.
That noise has been building for a while. A lot of people were ready to hand the crown to Drake Maye after just two years, but Bears fans have never been eager to go along with that. From their view, this is still a long game, and Williams is the one who keeps separating himself when the moment gets heavy.
Maye’s stat line from last season was huge - nearly 4,400 yards and 31 touchdowns - and he was an MVP finalist. But the source of the skepticism is right there too: the idea that he may have benefited from one of the softest schedules in the league. The Patriots only faced three 2025 playoff teams in the regular season - Pittsburgh, Carolina, and Buffalo - and they lost to the Steelers while splitting with the Bills.
That backdrop matters because the debate among Maye, Jayden Daniels and Williams has been driven so much by what just happened most recently. Daniels made his jump as a rookie by getting to the NFC Championship Game, and that pushed plenty of people to put him first. Then Maye put together an MVP-caliber season and reached a Super Bowl, and that was enough for others to move him to the top.
But the argument for Williams is different. It’s less about one hot stretch and more about what he’s already shown when everything is on the line. He tied an NFL record with six game-winning drives and fourth quarter comebacks in his most recent season, and that’s the kind of trait that changes how a quarterback is judged.
That’s why the completion-percentage crowd doesn’t really land here. Maye completed 70 percent of his passes in the opener, and it still turned into a mess. The number looked fine until the fourth quarter arrived and the interceptions started piling up.
Three fourth-quarter interceptions. That’s the part that sticks.
Williams, meanwhile, has already shown he can handle those pressure snaps. The source makes the point plainly: he’s the quarterback you want in the fourth quarter with the game on the line.
Maye is a good quarterback. The question is whether he’s great, and whether he can be trusted when the matchup tightens and the stakes rise. After Week 1, that answer looks a lot less certain than the early hype suggested.
In Other News...
Caleb Williams Fans Just Got New Fuel In The QB Debate
Drake Mayes Week 1 debut did not exactly quiet the quarterback debate from the 2024 class. In a loss to the Seahawks, he threw three interceptions, including the one that ended the game, and was outplayed by backup Drew Lock after Sam Darnold left early with an injury. For Bears fans keeping tabs on the rookie class, it was the kind of opener that immediately sharpened the contrast with Caleb Williams.
Williams enters a far less demanding start to his season, and that alone has kept the comparison alive. Some fans already see him as the superior quarterback from the 2024 group, and Mayes rough first impression only gave that argument more oxygen. The season is just beginning, of course, but the early returns have added a little more weight to every Caleb Williams conversation in Chicago. [Read more 🡒]
Bears Defensive Depth Chart Is Getting Mocked For One Big Reason
The Bears Week 1 defensive depth chart has a few familiar anchors, with Montez Sweat and Grady Jarrett expected to set the tone up front and Jaylon Johnson and Tyrique Stevenson positioned to help stabilize the secondary. Devin Bush also stands out as an upgrade at linebacker over Tremaine Edmunds, giving Chicago a different look in the middle of the defense as the season opens.
What has drawn the most attention, though, is how the chart handles Jordan van den Berg. Even without a prominent listing, he is expected to have a meaningful role, which has led to plenty of second-guessing about how the Bears are arranging their front. For a group trying to project confidence before Week 1, the reactions are a reminder that the official order on paper does not always match how the snaps are likely to be distributed. [Read more 🡒]
Bears Open With A Caleb Williams Question Fans Were Hoping To Avoid
Braxton Jones will open the season where the Bears need stability most, with the veteran tackle named the starter at left tackle for Week 1 against the Carolina Panthers. It is a notable development for an offensive line still trying to settle in around Caleb Williams, because protecting the quarterbacks blind side has been one of the biggest early-season questions hanging over the offense.
Ben Johnson said injured tackle Ozzy Trapilo is making positive progress, but his return does not appear imminent, which leaves Jones in position to handle the job for now. For Chicago, the bigger issue is not just who starts Sunday, but how long the Bears can keep that spot from turning into another weekly conversation at one of the most important positions on the field. [Read more 🡒]