Caleb Williams keeps landing in the same tricky neighborhood whenever the quarterback conversation gets serious: not quite with the untouchables, but too talented to shove into the background.
That’s the space Bryan DeArdo of CBS Sports carved out in his latest quarterback tiers, and it’s a pretty clean fit for the debate around Williams. The argument around him has been easy to see from both sides.
If you believe in his growth and upside, he looks like a future elite quarterback. If you’re focused on the low completion percentage and rough rookie numbers, the skepticism hangs around.
DeArdo didn’t go with a straight ranking. He used tiers, which makes the whole thing feel a lot more honest.
At the top are five quarterbacks he calls transcendent talents: Matthew Stafford, Lamar Jackson, Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Joe Burrow. These are the guys who can tilt a game almost by themselves.
Below that comes a much larger group of 12 quarterbacks, and this is where Williams fits the conversation. DeArdo labels them borderline stars - players who can look like stars in one game and disappear in the next. That inconsistency is the separator.
The group includes Jalen Hurts, Sam Darnold, Bo Nix, Jayden Daniels, Jared Goff, Brock Purdy, Jordan Love, Justin Herbert, Dak Prescott, Drake Maye, Trevor Lawrence, and Williams’ kind of profile. The order inside the tier can move around from week to week, matchup to matchup, and that’s the point.
There may be a few names in that group people want to argue about, but the larger idea is hard to miss: these quarterbacks have real star potential, even if they don’t show it every Sunday.
And that’s why quarterback debates get so heated this time of year. If you’ve got one of the top five, the argument is about where they sit among the best of the best. Once you fall into the next tier, the conversation gets messier fast.
Williams can be viewed as the sixth-best quarterback or the 18th-best quarterback, and in this framework, the difference isn’t nearly as dramatic as it sounds. It’s the line between near-elite and below average, and that’s exactly why this spot feels right for him.
Some weeks he looks elite. Some weeks he looks below average. That’s the reality DeArdo’s tier captures, and it’s why Williams belongs right in the middle of this debate.
In Other News...
This Hidden Bears Rookie Could Shake Up A Fragile WR Battle
The Bears receiver room still looks unsettled enough that every little skill set matters, and that is why Omari Kelly has started to draw attention. The Michigan State undrafted rookie is not the kind of name that usually jumps off a depth chart, but he brings a useful blend of punt return ability and slot work that could help him stand out in a crowded competition.
With Luther Burden III, Rome Odunze and Kalif Raymond already part of the conversation, Chicago is clearly sorting through options for the back end of the group. Kellys path is tied to versatility, since he can help on special teams and offer another layer on offense, which gives him a real chance to keep the Bears wideout battle interesting as camp unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Bears Center Battle Could Decide More Than Caleb Williams Protection
The Bears center competition has become one of the more interesting camp battles on the roster, and it reaches well beyond who lines up between the guards. Garrett Bradbury arrived with plenty of NFL experience and a built-in familiarity with Joe Thuney from their NC State days, while rookie Logan Jones brings the kind of college rsum that suggests he is ready to handle the job right away. For an offense trying to settle around Caleb Williams, the choice at center could shape more than just protection calls.
Bradbury has the benefit of a head start in chemistry, and that matters on an offensive line where communication can be as important as raw talent. Jones, though, is not just a developmental option waiting his turn. The former Iowa standout has the experience and physical readiness to push this battle deep into camp, which is exactly why the Bears may have a harder decision here than they expected when the job opened up. [Read more 🡒]
Bears Face One Risky Veteran Debate Before Camp Opens
With camp still ahead, the Bears are being linked to the kind of veteran names that can change the tone of a roster even if they are no longer the centerpiece of it. Joey Bosa, Bobby Wagner, Tyreek Hill and Von Miller all came up as possible fits in a speculative look at how Chicago could add experience, with the idea being less about splash and more about finding the right mix of leadership, role clarity and short-term impact.
Wagner is the most interesting of the group from a schematic standpoint because the conversation around him is not just about whether he can still play, but how he might be used if Chicago ever decided to bring him in. Miller, meanwhile, fits the familiar veteran pass-rusher mold teams often weigh when they want help around a young core, and the Bears are at least being mentioned in that broader discussion even though nothing is confirmed and no decisions have been announced. [Read more 🡒]