Caleb Williams is already back in the crosshairs of the league’s loudest skeptics, and this time the label comes with a strange kind of insult: he’s been slotted as the NFL’s second-most overrated player.
That’s a hard place to land for a quarterback who entered the league carrying the kind of hype usually reserved for saviors. The Chicago Bears were never going to let the same mistake happen twice after being linked to Patrick Mahomes as a missed opportunity, and Williams arrived with the expectation that he would be the answer.
His rookie year, though, didn’t give him much of a fair shot. Matt Eberflus wasn’t the right coach to develop him, and behind a shaky offensive line, Williams took the most sacks of any quarterback in the league.
Last season, the story changed. Williams led the Bears to the NFC North title and all the way to the Divisional Round, but that still wasn’t enough to quiet everyone.
FanSided experts ranked him No. 2 on their list of the league’s most overrated players, behind only Denver Broncos quarterback Bo Nix. Williams received 16 total points and four first-place votes.
Jason Kandel explained the reasoning this way: "The expectations surrounding Williams as he entered the NFL are definitely playing into his overrated moniker. A bona fide first-overall pick in 2024, Williams was touted as a franchise-a ltering quarterback who would change the culture of whatever team landed him right away," Jason Kandel wrote.
"Ironically enough, Williams is a victim of his own success both in college and in the pros. Unless he turns in an MVP-caliber season and a deep playoff run, he will almost certainly still be considered overrated.
"
That framing says as much about the hype around Williams as it does about his play. Scouts, fans and analysts threw around the word “generational” too casually, and the burden that came with it has followed him ever since. His completion percentage was a talking point last season, but that stat alone doesn’t capture the whole picture of a young quarterback who was dealing with tough conditions from the jump.
Williams has already shown he can make every throw in the book, including the kind of outrageous passes most quarterbacks never even attempt. He’s also delivered in pressure moments, producing comebacks and late-game drives when the Bears needed them most. His decision-making still has room to grow, and the routine throws have to become routine, but the talent is obvious.
For all the noise, Williams has already helped a team that was stuck at the bottom start looking like a real contender. Ben Johnson deserves credit for that rise, but the quarterback has done enough to show he’s not just along for the ride. And with the Bears hearing plenty of talk about regression heading into 2026, this latest ranking gives them one more thing to pin up and remember.
Williams has been through the chatter before. Questions about his personality, doubts about whether he could handle the next level - none of it has seemed to rattle him. Now he has another chance to answer the critics the same way he always has: on the field.
In Other News...
Bears Just Turned Two Last Roster Battles Into Tough Decisions
The Bears have started trimming the edges of their roster picture with a pair of moves that say plenty about how the final week of decisions is shaping up. Chicago added edge rusher Marcus Davenport and defensive back Denatre Prince, while moving on from running back Coleman Bennett and tight end Nikola Kalinic, a set of transactions that helps sharpen the competition in a couple of crowded spots.
Coleman Bennett had been part of a four-man battle for the third running back job, so his departure narrows that race and puts more pressure on the remaining contenders to separate themselves before the roster is set. Kalinics release with an injury designation brings another layer of uncertainty to the tight end group, and with those two situations now clarified, the Bears can move deeper into the final phase of roster choices. [Read more 🡒]
Malik Muhammad Just Crashed A Bears Battle That Suddenly Matters
The Bears got an early look at a couple of training camp names in the preseason opener, and Malik Muhammad was right in the middle of it. Defensive coordinator Dennis Allen used the game to see how standouts like Jordan van den Berg and Muhammad would hold up when the speed and spacing changed, which is usually where camp buzz either hardens into a role or fades back into the depth chart.
Muhammads appeal is obvious for Chicago, because the cornerback picture is still unsettled by injuries and uneven play. He took on multiple responsibilities in that first test and showed enough promise to stay in the conversation, even with the kind of rough edges that come with a young defender trying to prove he can be trusted when the games start to count. [Read more 🡒]
Bears Suddenly Have A Backup Quarterback Question Behind Caleb Williams
The Bears quarterback depth chart already has an added layer of uncertainty after Tyson Bagent was slowed by a hamstring injury in Saturdays preseason game against the Browns. The backup quarterback did not practice afterward, leaving Chicago to monitor a spot that matters more than it might in a typical August week, especially with Caleb Williams firmly installed as the starter and the team trying to sort out its insurance policy behind him.
Chicago has not offered an official update on Bagents condition, and the absence only sharpens the question heading into the Bengals game. With the preseason schedule moving quickly, the Bears may need to lean on the next man up sooner than expected if Bagent cannot get back on the field in time. [Read more 🡒]