UCF Could Suddenly Get A Rivalry Boost The Big 12 Needs

The potential reunion of UCF and USF in the Big 12 could strategically boost the conference's television appeal by reigniting a prominent regional rivalry.

As the Big 12 looks ahead to its next media-rights cycle, one expansion idea keeps checking every box: bring South Florida into the league and revive the War on I-4 with UCF.

That matchup has already shown it can move numbers. In the post-Texas and Oklahoma Big 12, the conference no longer has the Red River Rivalry as its giant national draw.

The league’s biggest current rivalries - BYU-Utah and Iowa State-Kansas State - generally top out in the 4.0 to 4.4 million viewer range when they land in prime network windows. The War on I-4 has been there before, and then some.

The peak came on Black Friday in 2017, when UCF’s 49-42 win over USF on ABC drew 4.6 to 4.7 million viewers, setting an all-time record for intra-conference broadcasts in the American Conference. It also delivered an 11.1 local rating in Orlando and a 10.1 local rating in Tampa, a rare example of one game hitting two major markets at once.

That’s the kind of inventory TV partners want. A revived UCF-USF series would give the Big 12 a built-in rivalry in the middle of Florida’s I-4 corridor, with Orlando and Tampa-St.

Petersburg tied together in a way the league could use every season. Tampa-St.

Petersburg is the nation’s 11th-largest media market, while Orlando ranks 15th, and pairing those two markets inside the same conference would give the Big 12 a cleaner southeastern footprint.

It would also solve a practical issue for UCF. Since the Knights left the American for the Big 12 after the 2022 season, they’ve been separated from one of their fiercest regional rivals and left with a travel setup that stretches them more than 1,000 miles away from most conference opponents. Adding USF would create an obvious travel partner and help anchor Olympic sports travel across the board.

The timing makes sense on the field, too. UCF is 5-5 under Scott Frost and has already produced one of the season’s notable Big 12 results with a double-overtime upset of BYU.

USF, meanwhile, is 6-4 in Brian Hartline’s first year after landing the top transfer portal class among Group of Six programs. The Bulls are also moving toward their new 35,000-seat on-campus stadium in 2027.

By the time the Big 12 gets to its 2031 television negotiations, USF would bring more than a rivalry. It would bring an on-campus venue, AAU credentials, and a football program on the rise. For a league trying to strengthen its TV value, that kind of addition is hard to ignore.

In Other News...

UCF Defense Has A Growing Problem Fans Cant Ignore

The frustration around UCFs defense keeps coming back to the same place: long afternoons spent chasing plays instead of dictating them. In the home loss to Arizona State, the Knights were on the field too much, and the wear showed as the Sun Devils kept finding room through the air to extend scoring drives. Even with Lewis Carter back in the lineup after a long absence, the defense never quite found the kind of disruption it needed to change the tone of the game.

Carters return was supposed to give UCF a lift, but the bigger issue was how little pressure the Knights generated overall. Arizona State was able to hit enough big passing plays to keep UCF on its heels, and the lack of backfield disruption made every series feel a little more dangerous. For a defense trying to steady itself, the concern now is not just one rough outing, but a pattern that is getting harder for fans to ignore. [Read more 🡒]

Dior Johnson Is Giving UCF A Bigger Reason To Believe

UCF kept its unbeaten start rolling with a win over Georgia Southern, and the latest reason for optimism came from Dior Johnson. The senior guard led the way with 25 points, while Oklahoma State transfer Arturo Dean chipped in 21 as the Knights continued to show they have more than one perimeter threat capable of carrying a game.

Johnson also handled the ball cleanly, adding four assists without a turnover, and Riley Kugel still found ways to help with six assists and seven rebounds despite a rough shooting night. The bigger test is coming next against Mississippi State, and if UCF is going to keep building on this early momentum, it will need the same kind of balance and poise when the competition stiffens. [Read more 🡒]