A few of the biggest voices in football had plenty to say after NC State hired Philip Rivers as its next head coach, and the range of reactions says a lot about how unusual this move really is.
Pat McAfee was all in on Rivers’ presence and the way he carries himself. He pointed to the former quarterback’s leadership, his reputation and the way he can command a room without needing to force it.
“Yeah. I think everyone respects his leadership.
Everyone appreciates how he goes about his business. And his resume is legit.
“So, when you talk about a guy that can come in and win people over quickly with authenticity, it’s Phil Rivers, and I can’t wait for these young bucks to hear him chirp them without swearing.
“Because he’s going to be a chirper, and he doesn’t swear. I don’t know if this age can fully understand that.”
NFL insider Ian Rapoport, also appearing on The Pat McAfee Show, took the conversation in a different direction. He wondered whether Rivers might actually have been a more natural fit for the NFL coaching path, given how long he played there, and he even floated the idea that this could be a steppingstone to a future pro job.
Ian Rapoport:
“It’s funny you say that. I’ve kind of wondered if it would be not easier, because the NFL is as high as it gets, but I wondered if the acclimation process would be a little less for him if he became an NFL coach.
“He interviewed last year for the Bills. I thought that might happen.
“This opportunity, though, hopefully he has a really good GM to get him through this.
“He’s got a really good quarterback prospect, who I know they’ve been recruiting, and they like, who is also his son.
“The opportunity to possibly coach his son is unbelievable. So, I think it makes sense to do this for a while.
“At the end of four years, if he ends up in the NFL as a head coach, I wouldn’t be surprised at all.”
Nick Saban’s reaction centered on the bigger job description that comes with running a college program. He gave Rivers credit for what he already knows about football, but made clear that college coaching is about much more than drawing up plays or teaching technique.
Nick Saban:
“First of all, I think Philip Rivers, probably from a technical standpoint, from a football standpoint, being an NFL quarterback for so many years, being a smart guy…he probably will be able to coach the players, and that part of it.
“But being a college coach to me is all about being a program builder.
“Recruiting is a really big thing. Developing relationships with people, having the kind of staff that can develop those kind of relationships and develop the leadership for these guys…a little different in terms of how you’ve got to motivate college players versus being an NFL player.
“He was in high school. Probably a lot of similarities with that.
“But I think the program part, whether it’s academics, whether it’s the discipline in the program, how you’re going to practice and be most efficient, how you spend the time, which is a limited amount of time in college because of academics…all those types of things to me are going to be the key in terms of how you evaluate the players you have on the team, how you evaluate players you want to pay, how you evaluate the guys you want to recruit.
“All these things take an expertise that maybe isn’t something he’s experienced, that he’s probably capable of.
“If he can set up the right protocol for those things, I think he has a great chance to be successful.”
That’s the real question hanging over this hire: not whether Rivers understands football, but whether he can build the structure around himself to handle everything that comes with a major college program.
Jim Rome, for his part, wasn’t sold on the idea working out. Still, he made it clear he understood why NC State went this route if it was going to make a change from Dave Doeren.
Jim Rome:
“Bottom line is this. I am skeptical.
It doesn’t work. It never works.
It hasn’t worked. And you know what…it may never work.
“BUT…if there is one guy who might be able to make it work…it’s Philip.
“Either way, I’m here for it, and I don’t blame them for shooting their shot.
“NC State has got to do something. They have to do something to shake it up.
“I’m here for it.
“If you’re going to run a guy like Dave Doeren, who was a really good coach for a long time there, then you better do something pretty dramatic, and this, of all the dramatic things, this is pretty dramatic.
“Shoot…let’s see what happens. Am I right…daggumit? Shoot your shot, gunslinger!”
In Other News...
Saints Complaints Just Added More Heat To Panthers Rematch
The Panthers left New Orleans with a walk-off win thanks to Ryan Fitzgeralds field goal, a finish set up by defensive pass interference on Kool-Aid McKinstry. It was the kind of ending that always invites debate, and the Saints wasted little time voicing their frustration afterward, but the call fit the rulebook and came after Carolina had already been flagged for a similar infraction earlier in the game.
What makes the aftermath a little richer for Carolina is that the Saints also benefited from several calls that went their way along the way, including penalties that helped them score and later get back even. So while the final play will be the one replayed most often, the broader officiating picture was more complicated than the postgame complaints suggested, and it only adds a little more edge to the next meeting between these two teams. [Read more 🡒]
Steve Smith Sr. Just Reminded Panthers Fans What This Offense Lacks
The Panthers are coming off a win over the Saints and sitting at 4-5, with Dave Canales choosing to stand pat at the 2026 NFL trade deadline, but the conversation around the roster still has a familiar edge. During a Monday Night Football broadcast on Nov. 16, Steve Smith Sr. leaned into the kind of hard-nosed, old-school football that made him a franchise icon, talking through the injury battles and toughness that defined his own career.
For Carolina fans, it was a reminder of the standard this offense still has to chase. Smiths presence on the broadcast brought back the memory of a receiver who could tilt a game with physicality and urgency, traits the current group has been trying to rediscover as the season settles in. The Panthers have shown enough to stay in the mix, but the gap between where they are and the kind of edge Smith represented was hard to miss. [Read more 🡒]
Panthers Are Suddenly Testing Young Defenders In Bigger Roles
A couple of young Panthers defenders got a bigger look in the recent game against the Saints, and interim defensive coordinator Todd Wash made it clear the expanded roles were intentional. Rookie defensive tackle Lee Hunter saw 15 defensive snaps and finished with three tackles, including a key stop on a fourth-and-inches play, while rookie safety Zakee Wheatley was thrust into the starting lineup and handled 63 snaps with three tackles of his own.
For a defense trying to sort out who can be trusted in more meaningful spots, those reps matter. Wash has stressed the value of letting younger players contribute more on that side of the ball, and the Panthers now have a better sense of how Hunter and Wheatley respond when the workload gets heavier and the margin for error gets thinner. [Read more 🡒]
