The Carolina Panthers’ final roster came with a few choices that stood out immediately, and not all of them were easy to defend.
Last week, Carolina had to settle on its final 53, and the result included some surprises on both sides of the ledger. The Panthers did a strong job through preseason of identifying who belonged and who didn’t, but the cut list still raised eyebrows - especially with Isaiah Simmons, Ja’Seem Reed, and Trevin Wallace among the names shown the door.
That trio is where the biggest criticism lands. Simmons looks like a special teams weapon who could also handle linebacker snaps in a pinch.
Reed, meanwhile, might have been a better answer than John Metchie III. And with the linebacker group already thin, losing that kind of depth felt like a mistake.
Even so, Carolina didn’t lose all of them for long. The Panthers were able to keep two of the three through waivers and practice squad maneuvering, while Wallace was claimed by the New York Jets. For now, the organization at least kept the situation from becoming a total loss.
There were also a few players who made the roster despite making the decision harder than it needed to be: Bobby Okereke, Haynes King, AJ Dillon, and Darren Waller. Dillon made the strongest case of the bunch.
He was steady all preseason and, in the view here, looked like the best running back on the team. Still, carrying a fourth back - or third, with Trevor Etienne hurt - is a tough fit.
The rest of that group had different issues. King missed the rest of the preseason after the Hall of Fame Game.
Waller practiced but never got into a game. Okereke didn’t show up until just before cuts.
Even so, Carolina found ways to keep all three around, and that matters.
The bigger problem is what the roster looks like beyond the cutdown window. On pure personnel management, the Panthers handled the available players well. But the overall construction still has obvious holes.
Wide receiver remains thin behind Tetairoa McMillan and Jalen Coker. Running back is still a question until somebody proves otherwise. Tight end is clearly unsettled, too.
And the quarterback room, with Bryce Young, Kenny Pickett, and King, doesn’t exactly inspire fear. Defensively, the team is leaning heavily on a free agent in Okereke who sat on the market for months. Nick Scott is still probably a starter, and that’s not a great sign either.
So while the Panthers earned credit for how they navigated the final roster process, the bigger picture still points to a modest grade. Overall, this roster looks like a C-, with plenty of work still ahead for the coaching staff and the players.
In Other News...
Panthers Backfield Plan Leaves Jonathon Brooks Facing A Familiar Problem
The Panthers are heading into the season with a backfield setup that should feel familiar to anyone who watched them last year. According to ESPNs Dan Graziano and offensive coordinator Ben Canales, Carolina plans to split carries between Chuba Hubbard and Jonathon Brooks, with Hubbard positioned to handle most of the work as long as he stays healthy. Brooks, meanwhile, is expected to mix in on third downs and in other situational spots, giving the room a layered but clearly defined hierarchy.
For Brooks, the arrangement leaves him in a role that looks a lot like what the Panthers already tried when Hubbard shared the load with Rico Dowdle. That split produced mixed results, and now Carolina is essentially betting it can get more out of the same kind of approach with a different cast of backs. The real question is whether Brooks can carve out a meaningful weekly role without the kind of steady volume that usually helps a young runner settle in. [Read more 🡒]
Chuba Hubbards New Panthers Role Says A Lot About 2026
Chuba Hubbards place in the Panthers offense is changing again, and this time it comes with more than touches and responsibilities. Named a team captain for the 2026 season, Hubbard enters the year as one of the clearest veteran voices on a roster trying to build on its 2025 playoff appearance, a sign that Carolina values him as much for his presence as for what he does with the ball.
With Rico Dowdle gone, Hubbard is expected to have a larger role in the offense, which makes the captaincy feel even more meaningful. He has already been a key contributor in previous seasons, and now the Panthers are asking him to help steady a group that wants to take the next step while leaning on familiar leadership in the backfield. [Read more 🡒]
Panthers Face A Bryce Young Decision That Could Define 2027
The Panthers have spent plenty of energy trying to build around Bryce Young, but the offense still feels like the part of the roster most likely to drag the team backward if things go wrong. Any slide could put Carolina in position to chase a top-10 pick in 2027, and that sort of outcome would force another hard look at how much progress has really been made since Young arrived and how much more help he still needs.
FOX Sports insider Rob Rang pushed that conversation into the draft lane with a mock projection that sends wide receiver Cam Coleman to Carolina as a possible way to keep Young supported. It is the kind of suggestion that reflects both hope and uncertainty around the quarterback spot, because the Panthers may soon have to decide whether another year of patience is the right answer or whether the clock on the Young era is already starting to get louder. [Read more 🡒]