The Indianapolis Colts may be aiming high if they move Jonathan Taylor, and the benchmark they’re reportedly using is one Panthers fans know all too well.
With the NFL trade deadline just over a week away, Carolina is staring at needs on both sides of the line of scrimmage, especially at the boundary cornerback spots, where the depth chart has thinned to the third and fifth options. Running back, though, is not a problem area for the Panthers. That matters because the top back available is expected to come with a massive price tag.
According to Adam Schefter at ESPN, the Colts want a Christian McCaffrey-type return for Taylor. That means any deal would need to match at least the package the San Francisco 49ers sent to Carolina in 2022: second-, third-, fourth- and fifth-round picks.
For the Panthers, that haul looked like a windfall at the time. In practice, it became a mixed bag at best.
The second-round pick, 61st overall in 2023, was flipped to the Chicago Bears as part of the deal that brought Carolina the first overall pick in 2023. The third-rounder, 93rd overall, and the fourth-rounder, 132nd overall, were both sent to the Pittsburgh Steelers in the trade that netted the 80th pick in 2023. The fifth-round pick in 2024, 166th overall, went to the New York Giants in a deal that brought back the 39th and 141st picks in 2024.
That second-rounder eventually helped the Panthers move up for quarterback Bryce Young. The third and fourth picks helped them land outside linebacker DJ Johnson, while the fifth was used, in part, to select running back Jonathon Brooks in 2024.
If Young turns things around after this two-game slide, Carolina can at least point to that part of the deal as worthwhile. The rest of the return hasn’t aged nearly as well. Brooks has appeared in only five regular-season games since being drafted, and Johnson is out of the league.
So if the Colts do land a sizable package for Taylor, the real question won’t be how many picks they get. It’ll be what they do with them.
In Other News...
Panthers Fans Suddenly Have A Real Quenton Nelson Debate
Taylor Motons season-ending injury has only sharpened the focus on Carolinas offensive line, and it has also opened the door to an uncomfortable what-if for Panthers fans. With the unit already under pressure, the recent deal that sent Quenton Nelson to Seattle for a 2027 third-round pick and a 2028 fifth-round pick is the kind of move that naturally makes a team like Carolina wonder whether it should have been in the conversation.
There is no indication the Panthers were actually involved in any trade talks, but the price Seattle paid is low enough to fuel the debate anyway. For a team trying to stabilize the front in the middle of a difficult stretch, Nelsons availability is the sort of opportunity that can linger in the background, especially when the alternative is trying to patch together protection after losing one of the groups most important pieces. [Read more 🡒]
Panthers Cornerback Crisis Could Force A Trade Deadline Decision
The Panthers cornerback room has been hit so hard by injuries that the depth chart has become a weekly survival exercise. With only two healthy cornerbacks left on the active roster as of Week 9, Carolina is trying to patch together a secondary that has been gutted by injuries, while the firing of defensive coordinator Ejiro Evero only adds to the sense that the defense is entering a critical stretch.
That shortage has pushed the trade deadline into sharper focus, and CBS Sports writer Josh Edwards has already floated the idea that Carolina may need outside help. He went a step further by naming five possible cornerback trade targets, a sign that the Panthers may have to decide whether to ride out the injuries or make a move before the market closes. [Read more 🡒]
Panthers Season Pressure Is Now Squarely On Dan Morgan
Injuries have already forced the Panthers into a difficult spot, and the cornerback group has become one of the clearest pressure points on the roster. With the defense taking hits and the teams recent play sliding, the conversation around Carolina has shifted from simply surviving the week to finding a real answer before the season slips further away.
Greg Auman has floated a trade idea that would send the Panthers toward Philadelphia cornerback Riq Woolen as a way to shore up the secondary, a sign of how urgent the need has become. For Dan Morgan, the challenge is no longer just managing the roster he has, but deciding whether this is the moment to make a move that could stabilize a battered defense. [Read more 🡒]