The NFC South looks like it could come down to the same messy margin it always seems to, but one thing has already sparked debate: the Carolina Panthers are getting pushed aside too quickly in favor of the New Orleans Saints.
Bleacher Report’s Brad Gagnon recently made a bold prediction for each division, and in the NFC South he picked a change at the top, with the Saints overtaking the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. That part is easy enough to understand. The jump from Tampa Bay to New Orleans is not some wild leap, especially with the Buccaneers having finished 2-7 and carrying a roster full of declining players behind a bad coaching staff.
But the leap from Carolina to New Orleans is where the logic starts to wobble.
There’s a real resemblance between what the Saints are trying to do and what the Panthers already pulled off last season. Both teams are built around young offensive head coaches, quarterbacks who flashed late enough to create hope, and favorable schedules that open the door for a division run.
Carolina had the Bryce Young-Dave Canales pairing, got enough momentum out of it to inspire optimism, and rode a third-place schedule to the division crown in 2025. New Orleans now has the Kellen Moore-Tyler Shough combination, and plenty of people are projecting that tandem to be good enough to take advantage of a fourth-place schedule.
That’s the part of Gagnon’s argument that makes sense.
What doesn’t hold up is treating the Saints as the obvious answer over a Panthers team that already proved it could get there. Gagnon pointed to Young’s uncertainty, but the same standard doesn’t seem to be applied to Shough. Young isn’t being framed as a finished product or a sure thing, but neither is Shough.
“2025 second-round pick Tyler Shough posted a 103.8 passer rating in his final four games and frequently showed signs that he could be the long-term option under center in New Orleans as the Saints went 4-1 to wrap up the 2025 campaign,” Gagnon said.
He also added, “With quarterback situations still murky in Atlanta and Carolina, and significant issues remaining elsewhere on both rosters, expect New Orleans to climb back to the top of the division.”
That’s a lot of confidence built on a short stretch when the games mostly didn’t matter. Young, meanwhile, has a longer body of work and has already shown more than a few flashes of what he can become. He’s also about two years younger than Shough, which matters when the conversation is about upside.
And if there’s a quarterback in this comparison who still has another level to reach, it’s Young.
The sophomore slump is real, especially once NFL defenses get a full stack of tape. Shough showed enough to raise eyebrows, sure, but he still comes with the same kind of questions that follow Young. That’s why it feels premature to hand the division crown to New Orleans and act like Carolina’s grip is already slipping.
In Other News...
Panthers Face A Risky Haynes King Decision They Could Regret
As the Panthers move through their roster cuts, Haynes King has become one of those preseason names that can linger because of what he might eventually offer rather than what he has already shown. He has only appeared in the Hall of Fame Game so far, and his injury recovery has kept him from building much of a rsum in camp, but the appeal is obvious enough: a quarterback with enough versatility to be used in different offensive looks and enough short-yardage value to matter in a tight game.
That makes his spot a tricky one to judge, because the Panthers are weighing immediate roster math against the risk of letting a useful player get away before he has a chance to prove it. If they move on now, it would be easy to see how the decision could be revisited later if his development continues and another team is willing to bet on the same upside Carolina is trying to measure. [Read more 🡒]
Panthers Face A Risky QB Debate Behind Bryce Young
The Panthers continue to operate as if Bryce Young is the quarterback to build around, and that certainty shapes everything else in the room behind him. With the team still sorting out how to support Young, the temptation to chase another name has surfaced in the usual offseason way, with Carolina linked to possible quarterback trade chatter involving Mac Jones and J.J. McCarthy.
But the case against making a move is pretty straightforward: the Panthers already have bodies behind Young, including Haynes King and Kenny Pickett, and there is enough uncertainty around the starters long-term setup without adding another layer to it. For now, the smarter play looks like patience, keeping the current quarterback group intact until Carolina has a clearer reason to change course. [Read more 🡒]
Panthers Suddenly Have One More Pass Rush Situation To Watch
The Panthers spent the offseason trying to give their pass rush a clearer shape, signing Jaelan Phillips to a four-year contract with the idea of pairing him with Nic Scourton. Instead, Scourtons torn ACL changed the picture before the regular season even arrived, leaving Carolina with another question mark in a spot that already needed reinforcement.
Josh Sweats name has entered the conversation as the kind of player who could fit what Carolina is looking for, especially with the Cardinals sitting on a veteran edge option. But Arizona general manager Monti Ossenfort has already said there is no interest in moving him, which leaves the Panthers monitoring a situation that could matter to their defense without offering any easy answers yet. [Read more 🡒]