For Carolina Hurricanes fans, Brooks Orpik has long been the easy answer.
Ask around, and there’s usually no debate, no pause, no search for a second name. Orpik sits at the top of the list of most hated players in franchise history, and the feeling has lasted for more than 20 years. That kind of staying power says everything.
Orpik built his NHL career around being hard to play against. Over 16 seasons with Pittsburgh and Washington, he posted 194 points in 1,035 games, piled up nearly 1,000 penalty minutes and likely landed close to 3,000 hits, even if hits haven’t always been tracked. His job was clear: punish opponents physically, and he did it well.
For Carolina, the grudge traces back to March 4, 2006, in Pittsburgh. The Hurricanes came in with the NHL’s best record, while the Penguins had the league’s worst record by a small margin. The game itself turned into a wild one, but one play made it unforgettable in Carolina lore.
The Canes jumped out to a 5-0 lead after the first period, getting two power-play goals and a short-handed goal from Erik Cole. Pittsburgh clawed back with two goals in the second, then Cole answered with his second goal of the night and his 30th of the season. The Penguins added another in the second and then scored early in the third, cutting the deficit to 6-4 with under 18 minutes left.
Then came the hit that changed everything. With 14:42 remaining, and Cole’s back turned to the play, Orpik drove him headfirst into the boards. Orpik was assessed 17 minutes in penalties, Bret Hedican stepped in to defend Cole and took a roughing penalty, and Cole suffered a broken neck that kept him out for more than three months before he returned during the Stanley Cup Final.
From that night on, Orpik was never going to get a friendly reception in Raleigh. Hurricanes fans made sure of it every time he came back.
And Cole never forgot, either. Nearly two years later, he dropped the gloves with Orpik in a spirited fight that helped close that chapter, even if the resentment around it never really disappeared.
The bad blood lingered through more meetings. In the 2009 Eastern Conference Finals, Orpik didn’t record a point, but Pittsburgh swept the series and he averaged more than four hits per game. For Carolina, it was another reminder that Orpik often seemed to have the upper hand.
There was another flashpoint in 2012, when Jeff Skinner, who had missed more than a month after suffering a concussion, took an open-ice hit from Orpik on January 17. The play drew an interference penalty and, once again, brought the old feelings right back to the surface.
Orpik’s move from Pittsburgh to Washington in 2014 didn’t end the story. It only gave it a new setting.
In the 2019 postseason, he scored the overtime winner in Game 2 to put the Capitals up 2-0 in the series. But the Hurricanes got the final word.
That same playoff run ended Orpik’s NHL career in the most fitting way possible for Carolina fans: Game 7 of the first round in 2019, when Brock McGinn scored in double overtime to eliminate Washington and close the book on Orpik’s season and career.
The comparison to Scott Stevens is part of the conversation, but the source of that anger was different. Stevens’ hate from 2001 and 2002 was tied mostly to those playoff series.
Orpik’s reputation has lasted far longer. He hasn’t played in more than seven years, and he still stands as one of the most despised opponents in Hurricanes history.
For a lot of Carolina fans, that 2006 hit is never going away.
In Other News...
Jordan Staal Finally Put A Blunt Label On Rantanen's Hurricanes Stint
Jordan Staal didnt dress up the Mikko Rantanen episode in Carolina as anything other than strange. The Hurricanes captain said the brief stint felt awkward and unusual, a rare stretch in which a major addition never quite settled into the room or the on-ice structure the way the team expected. Rantanen arrived in a blockbuster trade from Colorado with big-name expectations, but the fit never clicked, and the uncertainty around his role hung over the group until the deadline.
What made the whole thing even more notable from Carolinas side is how quickly the focus shifted after Rantanen was moved on to Dallas. The Hurricanes turned the situation into a different kind of asset, bringing in Logan Stankoven and draft capital, and Stankoven soon became part of the next chapter in a way that mattered far more than anyone could have predicted at the time. Staals blunt read on the Rantanen stretch is a reminder that not every headline move lands cleanly, even when the long-term outcome ends up working out. [Read more 🡒]