The Hurricanes and Islanders were back in familiar territory in 2024, meeting in the first round for the second straight season and giving the matchup another jolt of playoff energy. Carolina had already handled New York in six games the year before, then followed that run with a conference finals appearance. This time, the Canes came in with 111 points and the second spot in the division, while the Islanders finished third in the Metro and trailed Carolina by 17 points.
On paper, New York was a step behind. The Islanders won just 39 games, the fewest of the eight Eastern playoff teams, and they leaned on 16 overtime and shootout losses, which tied for the most in the league.
They also weren’t the same team defensively that they had been in previous seasons, finishing tied for 18th in goals against after usually living in the Top 10. Ilya Sorokin handled most of the workload during the season, but Patrick Roy turned to Semyon Varlamov after he finished strong.
Game 1 gave Carolina the start it wanted. Evgeny Kuznetsov opened the scoring on the power play, snapping a shot over Varlamov’s shoulder from a tough angle with the help of a moving screen.
New York answered with its fourth line, as Kyle MacLean finished off a sequence after Frederik Andersen misplayed a redirection. The goaltenders settled in after that, and the game stayed tied until the third.
Stefan Noesen broke through first. Kuznetsov fired from the point, Brady Skjei got a touch on it, and Noesen buried the loose puck on the backhand. Martin Necas added the empty-net goal to seal a 3-1 win, and Necas, Kuznetsov and Skjei each finished with two points.
Game 2 flipped the script early. The Islanders raced out to a 3-0 lead, with Kyle Palmieri and Bo Horvat scoring late in the first period before Anders Lee added a power-play goal in the second. Teuvo Teravainen got Carolina on the board with a power-play goal of his own, and Seth Jarvis later cut the deficit to one with a shot that beat Varlamov off the iron.
Still, New York held the edge until the final minutes. Andersen went to the bench, Andrei Svechnikov missed the net, and Sebastian Aho was waiting at the back door to tie the game with 2:15 left.
Carolina wasn’t done. Jordan Martinook won a battle behind the net and shoved the puck in just nine seconds later, giving the Hurricanes the two quickest goals in franchise history.
Jake Guentzel added an empty-net goal after that, and the Canes escaped with a 5-3 win.
Back on Long Island, the Islanders made a change in net and went with Sorokin in Game 3, hoping for a spark. Brent Burns beat him with a shot from the point, and Dmitry Orlov followed with a wrister to the blocker side.
Pierre Engvall answered for New York in the second period, but Aho scored from between the dots to send Sorokin out of the game. Brock Nelson pulled one back late in the second, yet Carolina still finished with a 3-0 series lead.
Game 4 was the Islanders’ best chance to breathe life into the series. Jarvis scored on the power play eight minutes in, but New York answered with the next two.
Mathew Barzal, quiet for three games, got his first goal of the series in the second period, and Jean-Gabriel Pageau tied it on the power play early in the third. Carolina’s power play came through late, though, and Noesen redirected Teravainen’s pass to force overtime.
The first extra period solved nothing, and the game spilled into a fifth period before Barzal tipped in the winner 84 seconds into double overtime. It was New York’s first win of the series.
The next night brought another burst of chaos. Carolina and New York combined for three goals in less than four minutes to start Game 5.
Teravainen scored first in under 90 seconds, Svechnikov added a power-play goal less than two minutes later, and future Hurricane Mike Reilly responded 41 seconds after that. Kuznetsov then turned a penalty shot into a 3-1 lead late in the period, moving in slowly and outwaiting Varlamov.
The Islanders pushed back in the second. Nelson scored early, and Casey Cizikas tied the game in the final minute of the period.
That set up another tense third, and Jack Drury delivered his first postseason goal early in the frame when a bouncing puck landed on his stick. Eight seconds later, Noesen struck again, giving Carolina breathing room with another quick answer.
Jarvis closed it out with the empty-net goal, and the Hurricanes finished off New York in the first round for the second straight year.
Jarvis led Carolina with seven points, while Noesen matched him with a team-high three goals. All but two skaters picked up a point for the Hurricanes in a series that ended 4-1 but played much tighter than that result suggests.
Andersen finished with a .912 save percentage and a 2.25 GAA, while Varlamov posted a .914 save percentage. Sorokin’s Game 3 appearance stood out as the exception, and it leaves one wondering how that night might have played out if Roy had not changed course.
Game 2 stands out as one of the best postseason games of the Rod Brind’Amour era, and the series as a whole had plenty of drama. The final tally made it look cleaner than it really was, but this was the strongest of Carolina’s three playoff meetings with the Islanders.
In Other News...
Hurricanes Fans Will Notice A Big Lenovo Center Change This Season
Lenovo Center is in the middle of a sweeping $300-million renovation that began last year and is set to keep rolling through 2028, with the building closed until Sept. 15 to finish the current phase. For Hurricanes fans, the changes will be hard to miss once hockey returns, with new seating, upgraded technology and additional concession areas all part of the ongoing effort to modernize the home rink.
The timing matters because the arena makeover comes as the Hurricanes have already sold out season tickets and are preparing to control more of their own presentation starting in the 2026-27 season with local TV broadcasts. Between the long-term building project and the teams growing reach off the ice, this feels like more than a cosmetic upgrade - it is another sign that the franchise is pushing to match its on-ice ambitions with a bigger fan experience around it. [Read more 🡒]
Hurricanes Just Got A Dynasty-Level Stanley Cup Case
The Hurricanes have spent years building one of the NHLs most stable contender models, and that reputation only grows when you look at the pieces they already have in place. A deep roster, smart organizational planning and a track record of staying in the mix have made Carolina an easy team to place near the top of any long-view Cup conversation, especially when compared with clubs still searching for the right blend of coaching, core talent and playoff consistency.
What separates Carolina from so many other hopefuls is how many of its best ingredients are already locked in. The core around the lineup has kept the Hurricanes positioned as a threat well into the future, and the sense around the league is that they are not just chasing one good run but trying to sustain something bigger. The remaining question is how high that ceiling can climb, and how quickly the rest of the NHL will have to start treating them like the standard rather than the challenger. [Read more 🡒]