Time has taken some of the edge off one of the Carolina Hurricanes’ most memorable rivalries from the 2000s, and the reason is pretty simple: the games haven’t lined up the same way, and neither has the success.
The Hurricanes were not a postseason machine from 1998 to 2009. They reached the playoffs only five times in that stretch, and four of those trips brought them face-to-face with the New Jersey Devils.
Those meetings came in the conference quarterfinals in 2001, 2002 and 2009, plus the conference semifinals in 2006. Carolina won three of the four series, but that record doesn’t tell the whole story.
Several of those matchups were packed with drama and sit near the top of the franchise’s playoff moments.
The first one, in 2001, set the tone immediately. Scott Stevens knocked Shane Willis and Ron Francis out of the series in back-to-back games, helping New Jersey build a 3-0 lead. Carolina pushed back with two wins, but the Devils closed it out in Game 6.
A year later, Kevin Weekes flipped the script. He stole Game 5 from the Devils, and the Hurricanes went on to win their first series in six games.
By 2006, the tone was different. Carolina opened by chasing Martin Brodeur in Game 1, and Game 2 turned into one of those playoff nights people remember for years.
Eric Staal tied it late, and Niclas Wallin scored the overtime winner. The Hurricanes took the series in five.
Then came 2009, another back-and-forth fight that ended with “The Shock at the Rock” in Game 7, when Carolina stunned New Jersey.
Back then, the two teams weren’t even division rivals. The Hurricanes were in the Southeast, while the Devils played in the Atlantic. Even so, the repeated playoff collisions built plenty of bad blood.
Since the realignment put both clubs in the Metropolitan Division, though, the rivalry has lost some of that bite. That’s in part because the teams haven’t been on the same track.
In the first four seasons after realignment, both spent time near the bottom of the division, with each team finishing in the bottom three all four years. New Jersey got back to the playoffs as a Wild Card team in 2018, while Carolina’s drought lasted one more year.
After that, the paths split. Since 2019, the Devils have finished in the bottom two of the division more times (4) than they’ve made the playoffs (2). The Hurricanes, meanwhile, haven’t missed the postseason and have won the Metro three times in the last five years.
That gap shows up in the head-to-head results, too. Since the pandemic-shortened 2021 season, when the teams didn’t meet because they were in different divisions, Carolina has won 22 of the last 29 regular-season and postseason games against New Jersey. Last season was the second time in three years that the Hurricanes swept the season series, winning all four games by at least two goals.
Even the recent playoff meetings haven’t had the same spark as those 2000s battles. In 2023, the first four games were lopsided, with three going Carolina’s way.
Game 5 was tighter, and the Hurricanes finished the series in overtime. The 2025 series had a little more drama, with two games going to double overtime, but Carolina still closed out the opening-round matchup in five games.
There has been some edge. In Game 3 of the 2023 series, Sebastian Aho and Jack Hughes got into a wrestling match, and Stefan Noesen dropped the gloves with Caniac-favorite Erik Haula. But that kind of heat has been rare compared with what these teams brought to each other in the 2000s.
Maybe that’s the whole story. Maybe the rivalry just burned brightest when the Hurricanes and Devils were meeting in the playoffs over and over again, with real tension and real moments attached to every series. Whatever the reason, it doesn’t quite feel the same in 2026.
In Other News...
Hurricanes May Be Weighing A Stunning Gamble With Their Blue Line
Alexander Nikishins first full NHL season gave the Hurricanes exactly what they hoped for from a young defenseman, with the rookie showing he could handle a regular role and chip in at both ends. For a team that has spent years trying to stay in the contender lane, that kind of emergence should have made him part of the long-term core, especially with general manager Eric Tulsky already showing a willingness to think big when the right opportunity appears.
Instead, Carolina appears to be weighing whether Nikishin can become part of a larger move that would give the roster more flexibility or help land a proven difference-maker now. The wrinkle is that the blue line is one of the clubs strengths, which is exactly why this kind of decision carries so much weight: keep the young defenseman and build around him, or use a valuable asset to chase immediate help and accept the risk that comes with it. [Read more 🡒]
Hurricanes Prospect Charlie Cerrato Just Reached A Bigger Stage
Charlie Cerrato is getting a notable next step in his young career, as the Carolina prospect will represent the defending Stanley Cup champions at the 16th annual NHLPA Rookie Showcase in Chicago from July 28 to July 30. The event, hosted by the NHLPA and Upper Deck, has become a familiar summer checkpoint for some of hockeys top young names, and Cerratos invitation adds another sign that his path is moving from college standout to pro hopeful.
Cerratos rise has been built on a strong Penn State background, where he produced immediately as a freshman and followed with another productive season before an injury interrupted the year in January. He has already gotten a taste of the pro game, too, after signing a tryout with the Chicago Wolves and appearing in one Calder Cup Playoff game, and he is now entering the second season of his three-year entry-level deal with Carolina. [Read more 🡒]