Huberdeau Now Carries The Biggest Question In Calgarys Longest Debate

As Jonathan Huberdeau returns to the ice after major hip surgery, the Calgary Flames face an anxious wait to see if their star player can recover his former glory and justify his hefty contract.

Jonathan Huberdeau’s hip surgery is the kind of development that can change the conversation around a player fast.

After arriving in Calgary in July 2022 as part of the blockbuster deal that sent Matthew Tkachuk to Florida, Huberdeau signed an eight-year extension worth $84 million, with a $10.5 million average annual value. The expectation in Calgary was obvious: a top-end scorer who had just put together a record-setting season would keep driving offense.

That hasn’t happened in the way anyone hoped, but there’s now a clearer reason to at least factor in the body itself. In March 2026, after battling increasing hip pain since the previous summer, Huberdeau had hip resurfacing surgery performed by surgical specialist Dr.

Edwin Su. Flames rehab sports physiotherapist Scott Cyr addressed the recovery in mid-March as Huberdeau started his rehabilitation, saying, “So it’s our job now to try to wake those up and get them strong again, and get his hip and his body used to moving into areas that he hasn’t been able to for a number of years now.”

The scoring numbers in Calgary tell the story of a player who never matched the production he brought over from Florida. In four seasons with the Flames, Huberdeau put up 15 goals and 55 points in 79 games in 2022-23, 12 goals and 52 points in 81 games in 2023-24, 28 goals and 62 points in 81 games in 2024-25, and 10 goals and 25 points in 50 games in 2025-26.

He arrived in Alberta after three straight seasons with the Panthers at better than a point per game, and Calgary paid accordingly. The drop-off since then has made his contract a frequent target on “worst contract in the NHL” lists, even though Huberdeau changed his game heading into the 2024-25 season and took a notable step forward offensively and overall by focusing more on two-way fundamentals.

The injury piece matters because hip resurfacing surgery is no small thing. As described by Ed Jovanovski, who had the procedure, “They dislocate your joint,” Jovanovski said to Custance.

“Pull it out of your leg. Then shave the femoral head down to a certain size and cap it with titanium.

Then do the same for your socket, shaving out the socket and hammering in a new socket where everything kind of joins together.”

Other players who have gone through it include Nicklas Backstrom, Ed Jovanovski, Ryan Kesler, Mike Sillinger, and Andy Murray. Former Flames forward Sean Monahan had two hip labrum surgeries, which are generally considered less invasive than hip resurfacing.

The post-surgery track record is all over the map. Backstrom played 47 games across three seasons for Washington after his surgery before shutting himself down early in 2023-24 and later returning to Sweden.

Jovanovski played 37 games after his operation, was bought out, and retired. Kesler and Sillinger had the surgery near the end of their careers for quality-of-life reasons.

Murray returned six months after surgery and played at a high level for five more years, though not at the same elite level he had before.

For Huberdeau, the hope is straightforward: better mobility, less pain, and a chance to get back to using the vision and passing that have always been his calling card. What’s far less certain is whether a healthier hip leads to a true offensive rebound in 2026-27. The question now is less about whether he can play, and more about what he looks like when he does.

In Other News...

Flames Face A Risky Morgan Frost Decision They Can't Dodge

Morgan Frosts arrival in Calgary has already made him one of the most important decisions on the Flames books. After a career-best 22-goal season, the pending unrestricted free agent has put himself in position to be the clubs No. 1 centreman as soon as 2026-27, which is exactly why the front office cannot treat his future like a routine contract call. Calgary needs center help, and it needs it soon, which makes Frost more than just a productive forward - he is a possible pivot point for how the next few seasons are built.

The Flames have to choose between keeping Frost in place and betting on internal growth, or moving him now and forcing the organization to lean harder on prospects to fill the void. Either path carries risk, especially for a team whose center depth is already limited, and the stakes only rise because this is the kind of decision that can shape the roster well beyond next season. For management, the uncomfortable part is that there does not seem to be a painless way to handle it. [Read more 🡒]

Simon Nemec Is Already Eyeing A Bigger Flames Role

Simon Nemec arrives in Calgary with a fresh start and a clear sense of purpose after the Flames brought him in from New Jersey and locked him up on a five-year deal. The young defender already has one eye on how he fits into the lineup, and it sounds like he views this move as more than just a change of scenery. It is a chance to play a larger offensive role for a team that paid real assets to get him.

Nemec spent last season with the Devils putting up 11 goals and 26 points in 68 games, production he now hopes to build on with more opportunity in Calgary. The intriguing part is how quickly he believes he can climb into a meaningful spot on the power play and make himself part of the Flames' scoring plans, which gives this trade a different kind of upside if the opportunity matches the confidence. [Read more 🡒]

Simon Nemec Is Giving Devils Fans A Reason To Revisit That Trade

Simon Nemec is settling into a fresh start in Calgary after the June trade that sent the young defenseman from New Jersey to the Flames and quickly put him on a new path. He signed a five-year contract with Calgary and has made it clear he sees this move as a chance to expand his game in a place that will give him more responsibility.

The intrigue here is less about the transaction itself than the fit on the ice. Nemec has talked about wanting a larger role after limited opportunity with the Devils, and power-play usage is a big part of that conversation. If Calgary can give him the kind of man-advantage work he has been chasing, this trade could end up looking very different for everyone involved. [Read more 🡒]