Cal May Already Be Facing The Tosh Lupoi Decision

Despite high hopes and considerable investment, Tosh Lupoi's tenure as head coach at Cal appears to be a cautionary tale of unmet expectations and the limits of financial backing.

Tosh Lupoi was always a gamble for Cal. Ten games in, that gamble looks a lot less like a bold swing and a lot more like a mistake the program can’t afford to keep making.

The idea behind the hire was easy enough to understand. Cal would back him with real money, give him a stronger financial footing than the program had under Justin Wilcox, and let that investment do some of the heavy lifting.

That part, at least, has held up. The problem is that money can only take you so far.

A college football program still needs a baseline level of coaching competence, and the evidence so far says Lupoi hasn’t provided it.

That’s why this is no longer a debate about upside. It’s about survival. Based on what Cal has shown through 10 games, Lupoi’s team has been historically bad, and the athletic department is staring at a crisis.

The simplest way to see it is through SP+, the analytical ranking system that gets cited for a reason. Cal is last among Power 4 teams.

Behind San Jose State. If Cal traveled to Texas to play Rice, the game would be a coin flip.

Cal is also a home underdog to Stanford, the same Stanford program that previously shared the consensus label for the worst Power 4 team with Rutgers.

You could spend a long time sorting through why Cal has landed in this spot. But at a certain point, the explanation stops mattering as much as the result.

The result is that Cal is roughly 120th in the country and the worst power conference team in the country. That is not a small problem.

That is a real crisis for the athletic department.

What makes this even more troubling is how much harder it is to shrug off a disastrous first year in the current college football landscape. Bill Radjewski, a college football data analyst and Michigan fan, has been running numbers on how predictive Year 1 is for the rest of a coach’s tenure. The answer is: pretty darn predictive.

That doesn’t mean every bad start becomes a permanent disaster. But the pattern is clear enough. Coaches who begin badly usually stay bad.

Cal’s situation offers little reason to expect a turnaround. The data Radjewski is looking at mostly comes from the pre-portal, pre-NIL era, when a coach had far less control over the roster he inherited.

That distinction matters. Sonny Dykes, for example, got a mulligan for 2013 because he inherited a broken roster from Jeff Tedford and didn’t have the time to reshape it.

Lupoi doesn’t have that excuse. He was given the resources to shape the roster, and his defense is almost entirely made up of players he and his staff identified.

He was also given a significant cash investment to find offensive talent that could maximize Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele’s abilities. In other words, he had more support than Justin Wilcox ever got, and the results have been much worse.

That’s the core of the problem. Every objective marker says this season has been uniquely bad, and there’s little reason to think Lupoi’s tenure will look different if it continues. From the standpoint of simply trying to field a winning football team, Cal needs to move on as soon as it can.

The hard part is the money. Cal did raise 82 million in donations last year, but that does not automatically answer the question of whether there’s enough left to fire Lupoi and turn over the staff.

Maybe there’s another 20 million available. Maybe there isn’t.

And even if the cash exists, there’s still the issue of whether the wider campus will tolerate that kind of spending, or whether Rich Lyons has the desire, the money, and the political capital to make a move that has little precedent in college football, much less in Berkeley.

Those are questions I can’t answer. But whoever is making the decision needs to understand what this already is: a sunk cost.

That phrase matters here. The sunk cost fallacy is what happens when people keep pouring time, money, and effort into a failed project because they don’t want to admit the project has failed.

That’s human nature. Nobody likes to say the money was wasted, so they keep spending.

Cal can’t let that logic drive the decision. If the school truly can’t afford to fire Lupoi and rebuild the staff, then it needs to face the reality that 2027 under Tosh Lupoi is very likely to resemble what 2026 has already looked like.

Cal’s donors have already stepped up repeatedly since the Pac-12 dissolved in an effort to keep Cal football afloat. They may have to do it again.

In Other News...

Cal QBs Just Delivered A Historic NFL Sunday

A rare Cal quarterback moment unfolded across the NFL on Sunday, when three former Golden Bears started games for the first time in nearly 46 years. Jared Goff was in command for Detroit in Munich, Germany, while Aaron Rodgers was back under center for Pittsburgh and Fernando Mendoza got the call for Las Vegas, giving Cal fans an unusual coast-to-coast snapshot of the programs quarterback lineage on one day.

The results were mixed, as Goff helped the Lions roll past New England, Rodgers and the Steelers were handled by Cincinnati, and Mendozas debut start came in a loss to Seattle. Even so, the bigger takeaway for Cal is the historical weight of the afternoon, with three ex-Bears starting on the same NFL Sunday for the first time in generations and one of them stepping into a new role at the pro level. [Read more 🡒]

Cal Gets One Last Chance Against A Pitt Team In Trouble

Cals season finale now has a time and a TV home, with the ACC announcing that the Bears will face Pittsburgh at 4:30 p.m. Pacific time on Saturday, Nov. 28, on The CW. It gives Cal one last chance to close the year on a national broadcast after its loss to Virginia, and it also sets up a late-afternoon matchup that should draw attention beyond the usual conference footprint.

Pittsburgh comes in with its own issues after losing its starting quarterback, leaving the Panthers in a far less stable place than they were earlier in the season. Cal will still have to handle whatever version of Pitt shows up, but the uncertainty around the Panthers adds another layer to a finale that already carries plenty of weight for a Bears team trying to finish with something better than a sour ending. [Read more 🡒]

Cal Showed Something Fans Will Be Debating After This Ugly Win

Utah Tech spent much of the night making Cal work for everything at Haas Pavilion, and for long stretches it looked like the Trailblazers might leave Berkeley with a memorable upset. Christian Gibson and Ethan Potter helped keep Utah Tech in front for much of the game, while the Bears labored through a rough shooting night from beyond the arc and never found a comfortable rhythm until the closing minutes.

Still, Cal found a way to survive 79-73, and the way it happened is likely to fuel some debate among fans who watched an ugly win turn into a late escape. The Bears leaned on a comeback when it mattered most, with TT Carr and others helping steady the group down the stretch, and now the focus shifts quickly to Texas A&M Commerce as Cal tries to turn a shaky performance into something more convincing. [Read more 🡒]