The ACC has rewritten the script on how it settles football ties, and the timing makes perfect sense. After last season’s messy finish sent an eight-win Duke team into the title game and left Miami on the outside, the league announced a new tiebreaker system Wednesday at its media days.
That 2025 finish was the kind of outcome that forces a conference to take a hard look in the mirror. Duke, despite five losses, got past Miami on the fifth tiebreaker and then beat Virginia for the ACC championship.
Miami had the league’s best overall record, sat 12th in the College Football Playoff rankings, and still missed out. The optics were rough, and the ACC clearly decided it could not live with a repeat.
There were three big reasons behind the overhaul.
First, the league wanted its two best teams in the championship game. Last year, that did not happen. A five-loss team playing for the conference crown, while a much stronger Miami team watched from home, was exactly the kind of result the ACC wanted to avoid.
Second, the schedule itself is getting trickier. The ACC is moving to a nine-game conference slate this season to line up with the other Power 4 leagues, but it is doing so as a 17-team conference after the arrivals of Stanford, Cal and SMU.
That means not everyone will play the same number of league games. In 2026, 12 teams will play nine conference games and five will play eight.
Starting in 2027, 16 teams will play nine and one team will play eight on a rotating basis each year.
That uneven setup is a big reason the league wanted a cleaner system.
“Head-to-head results need to matter and then we wanted to make sure we were treating everybody fairly from whoever is playing eight games versus who is playing nine games based on the luck of the draw,” ACC SVP of Football Michael Strickland said. “There was some discussion [of using CFP rankings], but it came back to the guiding principles.
That would be dismissing the conference schedule. It’s a conference championship game and your conference results should matter more than non-conference to determine who plays in your game.”
The third factor is the playoff picture. The ACC knows the conference title game now carries direct College Football Playoff weight.
Last year, the five highest ranked conference champions got automatic bids. This year, the four Power 4 champions will receive automatic bids, along with the highest-rated champion from the Group of 6.
The league did not formally adopt CFP rankings as a tiebreaker, but it did build in a heavier reliance on a metric used by the selection committee.
The new process starts by defining what a tie actually is. Teams no longer need identical records to be considered tied. Instead, teams with the same number of conference wins or conference losses will be treated as tied, which keeps a 7-2 team from being treated differently than a 7-1 team simply because one played more league games.
From there, head-to-head results come first.
If one tied team beat the other tied team in conference play, that team advances.
If three or more teams are tied and all are common opponents, the team with the best head-to-head record advances. If that does not settle it, the process continues with the remaining teams. If needed, the commissioner determines the outcome by draw, and the tiebreaker restarts if necessary.
If three or more teams are tied and they are not common opponents, the team that beat each of the other tied teams advances, while the team that lost to each of the others is removed. If that still does not resolve the situation, the commissioner’s draw comes into play again.
In plain terms, the ACC has made head-to-head results the centerpiece. If that does not solve it, the Team Success Ranking steps in.
That metric, which is also used by the College Football Playoff selection committee, rewards the stronger overall résumé. If that still leaves things unresolved, the commissioner or the commissioner’s designee gets the final say.
The league had already used Team Success Ranking in its old tiebreaker format for more than a decade, but it was buried near the bottom of the list. In last year’s five-way tie, it sat at No. 6, behind the combined winning percentage of conference opponents - the very step that ended up sending Duke to the title game and knocking out Miami.
Under the new setup, that would not happen. The Team Success Ranking would arrive much earlier in the process, and Miami would have advanced to face Virginia based on its overall résumé.
The ACC’s new system is simpler, more playoff-aware, and built for a conference schedule that no longer looks uniform from top to bottom. It is also designed to make sure the league’s title game is decided by the teams that actually belong there.
In Other News...
Tosh Lupoi Sends Cal Fans A Promising Warning About This Reset
Tosh Lupoi has spent the months since taking over at Cal trying to turn a reset into something sturdier, and by his own account the early returns are encouraging. The first-year head coach said he likes the progress the program has made since his hiring last December, pointing to recruiting momentum and the work of a new staff that has been trying to build a more competitive culture before the season even starts.
Still, Lupoi has made it clear the job is nowhere near finished, which is part of what gives this stretch its edge for the Bears. Keeping sophomore quarterback Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele in the fold was a major piece of that early push, and with UCLA looming in the opener, Cal is trying to show that the reset is more than a feel-good offseason story. [Read more 🡒]
Cal's Young QB Is Facing A Very Different Kind Of Pressure
Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele spent last summer trying to win a job. This summer, the Cal sophomore is trying to grow into one. After beating out Ohio State transfer Devin Brown for the starting role a year ago, Sagapolutele enters 2026 as the established quarterback, and the expectations around him have changed along with the Bears' offense under new coordinator Jordan Somerville.
Somerville is installing a more pro-style system, and Sagapolutele said the details matter because the quarterback now has more to process and more to command. Cal is also looking for a better run game behind portal additions and returning pieces, which should help take some pressure off the passing attack, but the bigger shift is on Sagapolutele himself: he is no longer just competing for snaps, he is being asked to lead the entire operation. [Read more 🡒]
Max Homa Kept Cal Alive At The Open In Dramatic Fashion
Max Homa gave Cal a weekend presence at The 154th Open Championship with a late surge that changed the feel of his second round in a hurry. A birdie at the 15th and an eagle at the 17th helped him finish with a 1-under 69, leaving him tied for 49th at even par and still in the mix heading into the final two rounds.
Collin Morikawa also kept the Bears represented near the top half of the board, finishing at 2 under and tied for 23rd after a turbulent close to his round. Michael Kim, meanwhile, was unable to join them for the weekend after missing the cut at 5 over, leaving Homa and Morikawa as the Cal names to watch from here. [Read more 🡒]