It’s finally here.
Rivalry week has arrived, and the stage is set for a heavyweight matchup in Salt Lake City. No.
6 Utah and No. 8 BYU are headed to Rice-Eccles Stadium on Saturday morning, with both teams coming off wins and both carrying plenty of momentum into one of the biggest games on the schedule.
The rankings may shift again when the Associated Press releases its latest poll Sunday, but the bigger picture is already clear. Big 12 positioning, tie-breakers and pride are all wrapped into this one.
Utah kept rolling with a road win at Cincinnati, and it wasn’t close for long. The Utes jumped out to a 41-6 halftime lead before finishing off the Bearcats 49-25. That was the latest example of an 8-0 team that has mostly made its living by blowing games open with explosive plays and a punishing ground attack.
BYU, meanwhile, survived another one of those strange, stressful, hard-to-explain games that seem to follow the Cougars around. At home against Arizona State, they led 17-3 before hanging on for a 27-20 win over a Sun Devils team fighting for bowl eligibility, with true freshman quarterback Jake Fette making his first career start.
BYU coach Kalani Sitake summed up the vibe afterward on KSL radio: “We’re getting oddities out of the way,” BYU coach Kalani Sitake told KSL radio afterwards.
The Cougars are 7-1 and own the Big 12’s most notable win so far, the victory over Notre Dame. But they still haven’t put together a truly clean game.
Saturday was another reminder. BYU turned it over twice, including an interception and a peanut-hit fumble on a third-and-7 conversion catch by Kyler Kasper.
That has been the story with this team: enough talent to win, enough chaos to make it interesting every time.
Utah brings a different kind of pressure into the rivalry. Against Cincinnati, Wayshawn Parker carried seven times for 82 yards and a touchdown, Daniel Bray added eight carries for 75 yards, and quarterback Devon Dampier ran nine times for 45 yards. The Utes piled up 268 rushing yards against one of the Big 12’s weakest defenses.
BYU has not had that kind of balance since star running back LJ Martin went down four games ago. Against Arizona State, a backfield committee featuring Bear Bachmeier, Sione Moa and receiver Legend Glasker managed just 47 rushing yards. The Cougars also lost 43 yards on tackles for loss, including 23 on the final possession when Bachmeier was running around in the backfield trying to drain the clock.
That kind of mess has become familiar. For the third straight BYU game, the action felt like it had wandered into the “Twilight Zone.”
The Cougars try to take control, then don’t. Strange plays keep opponents alive.
Officials get dragged into long reviews and drawn-out rulings. The clock seems to freeze for a beat while everyone scrambles around with the ball.
One sequence against ASU captured it all. Bachmeier appeared to get into the end zone on a quarterback sneak, but the play was not reviewed.
On the next snap, he fumbled, Moa recovered it, advanced after securing the ball and standing up, and after a 12- to 15-minute review and discussion, Moa was awarded advancement and a touchdown. The call has already become a national talking point.
Or maybe not.
Then came another odd finish. As Bachmeier was kneeling to run out the clock, a defender launched with his helmet and hit him while he was going down, but no personal foul or targeting flag came out.
Even with all that, BYU has found ways to win. The Cougars have lost the turnover margin in four straight games and still won three of them.
The Arizona State game also offered a couple of big positives. With starting cornerback Evan Johnson out with an ankle injury, BYU had to line up against one of the country’s better receivers in senior Reed Harris.
The result: Harris finished with one catch for 4 yards. Jayvon Williams, filling in for Johnson, had three pass breakups and seven tackles.
And when it mattered most, BYU delivered its best drive of the season. Trailing 20-17 late in the fourth quarter, the Cougars put together an 11-play, 95-yard march, their longest scoring drive of the year. It featured a fourth-and-1 conversion at the BYU 15-yard line on a Bachmeier dive, a 53-yard strike to Glasker and a 1-yard touchdown run by Moa, his second score of the day.
Bachmeier finished 19 of 30 for 236 yards, a touchdown and an interception. His touchdown pass went to Kyler Kasper. He completed 63% of his throws and posted a 133.7 efficiency rating.
Dampier was sharp for Utah, too, completing 22 of 29 passes for 260 yards, two touchdowns and one interception. He finished with a 167 rating and a 75% completion percentage.
The matchup now shifts to the rivalry stage, where close games and late swings have long been the norm. BYU has to hope this one comes down to a handful of plays at the end, because this is not a team built to win by pulling away. Utah, on the other hand, has looked like exactly that kind of team, and ESPN’s metrics have had the Utes favored in this game since summer.
Stay tuned.
In Other News...
BYU Win Over Arizona State Just Sparked A Big 12 Debate
The Big 12s acknowledgment of an officiating error in BYUs 27-20 win over Arizona State has added a fresh layer to a game that already carried plenty of weight in the conference race. The issue centered on a fumble recovery that was incorrectly ruled a touchdown, a call that immediately shifted the tone of the matchup and left one side feeling as if the moment had been decided on the spot.
For BYU, the result still stands, but the debate around how the play should have been handled is impossible to ignore because the awarded points matched the final margin. The correct ruling would have given the Cougars possession where the fumble was recovered, not a touchdown, and that distinction has turned a hard-fought win into one of the more talked-about officiating controversies in the Big 12 this season. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Win Draws Fresh Scrutiny After Another Big 12 Admission
The Big 12s latest officiating admission has put BYU back in an uncomfortable spotlight, this time over a touchdown in the win against Arizona State that the league says should never have counted. The conference said running back Sione Moas score was the result of an error, and the proper ruling should have left BYU with possession at the two-yard line instead.
For a program already dealing with the lingering frustration from a timing mistake in the Notre Dame game two weeks earlier, the back-to-back acknowledgments only deepen the sense that the Cougars have been on the wrong end of some major calls. BYU still has the victory in hand, but the latest statement adds another layer to a season in which the conversation around the team has too often drifted from the field to the replay booth. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Beat Arizona State But Utah Concerns Just Got Harder To Ignore
BYU got the result it needed against Arizona State, but the way it got there did little to quiet the questions around this team. The Cougars won 27-20 in a game that featured an early turnover, a quick touchdown off that takeaway and enough timely fourth-quarter plays to finish the job, yet the offense never looked fully comfortable for long stretches. The run game was especially sluggish, and the third quarter offered little relief as BYU spent much of the afternoon fighting for rhythm.
For a team still trying to sort out how sturdy it really is, the win came with some familiar warning signs attached. BYUs defense created an early edge, but it also had to absorb enough pressure to keep the game tight, and the offensive inconsistency left the Cougars leaning on situational execution instead of control. The victory counts, of course, but it also leaves the bigger concern hanging around as the schedule keeps moving. [Read more 🡒]