Utah’s coaching tree is set to cast a wide shadow over the 2026 college football season.
That’s the big takeaway from Sports Illustrated’s Pat Forde, who stacked his list of the 25 most intriguing head coaches for 2026 with four figures tied to the state: BYU’s Kalani Sitake, Utah’s Morgan Scalley, former Utes coach Kyle Whittingham and ex-BYU quarterback Steve Sarkisian.
The highest-ranked of the bunch is Whittingham, who lands at No. 3 behind Indiana’s Curt Cignetti and LSU’s Lane Kiffin. After 21 seasons in Salt Lake City, he moved on to Michigan this offseason, stepping into a program that was rocked by the ouster of Sherrone Moore. Forde suggested the change could work out well for the Wolverines, praising Whittingham’s track record and experience.
“There is an adult in charge now in Whittingham, who became available when Utah squeezed him out to facilitate its longstanding succession plan to elevate assistant Morgan Scalley. A guy with 177 career victories and eight 10-win seasons in the relative obscurity of the Mountain time zone falls into Michigan’s lap, anxious to prove himself at age 66 at a blueblood program,” Forde wrote.
Whittingham won’t be walking into a bare cupboard either. Forde noted that he inherits quarterback Bryce Underwood, whom many project as a future first-round NFL pick, and that he brought several important players and staff members with him from Salt Lake City. Michigan’s schedule, though, is no soft landing, with four 2025 playoff opponents on the slate.
Scalley, meanwhile, checks in at No. 19 as he takes over the Utes after serving as the head-coach-in-waiting. He had already begun to shoulder more responsibility in recent years, and got his first chance to run the show in Utah’s bowl game last season, when the Utes beat Nebraska 44-22 in the Las Vegas Bowl.
Forde pointed to the unusual circumstances around the transition, including Whittingham’s exit and sudden arrival in Ann Arbor.
“Replacing 21-year head coach hero Whittingham was never going to be easy, but the circumstances have ratcheted up the stakes. Whittingham was shown the door to make room for his successor-in-waiting, then landed the deluxe Michigan job pretty much out of nowhere. Now the comparison game will have real-time results,” Forde wrote.
Still, Scalley has pieces to build around. Forde highlighted quarterback Devon Dampier, who has more than 8,000 yards total offense in three years, and running back Wayshawn Parker, who has more than 1,700 rushing yards in two years.
He also noted that Utah’s schedule is manageable, with no Texas Tech matchup, and that the season should build toward the Holy War against BYU on Nov. 7.
Sarkisian comes in at No. 20 after another strong year in Austin. Texas finished 2025 at 10-3 and ended up in the top 15, though the Longhorns still missed the College Football Playoff after back-to-back appearances and a run to the semifinals in 2024.
Forde framed the season ahead as the next step in Texas’ rise under Sarkisian.
“Sark has returned the Longhorns to permanent contender status, with three straight seasons of double-digit wins for the first time since 2007-09. Like Mack Brown before him, he now has to take the next steps - win a conference championship and ultimately a national championship,” Forde wrote.
The pressure and the upside both rise in tandem for Texas, especially with Arch Manning back and a transfer portal class that has boosted expectations around the program. Forde described the Longhorns as perhaps the biggest winners in the portal and said Manning is central to what comes next.
“Texas may well be the single biggest winner in the transfer portal, adding major playmakers on both sides of the ball in addition to retaining standouts on defense and the offensive line,” Forde wrote. “Sark has hitched his wagon to Arch Manning, which every coach wanted to do when he was coming out of high school. Manning’s first year as a starter was rough early and better late; if his improvement continues this season it may vault the program to championship status.”
Sitake, who remains firmly in Provo after turning down Penn State, lands at No. 22. BYU has gone 23-4 over the last two seasons and finished in the top 15 both years, and the Cougars bring back an experienced roster loaded with returning starters and playmakers.
Forde made clear that the Penn State flirtation faded quickly, and that Sitake remains a strong fit where he is.
“Perhaps the strangest blip on the hire-and-fire radar last year was Sitake’s appearance as a candidate for the Penn State job. That subsided fairly quickly, and (Sitake) remains in his happy place at BYU. The personable former Cougar player has been a great fit as head coach, winning 10 or more games four times in Provo,” Forde wrote.
He also pointed to BYU’s run to the 2025 Big 12 title game, which came despite freshman QB Bear Bachmeier having to step in as the unexpected starter over the summer. Forde believes this group can push for even more.
“That includes the last two years, and it includes getting BYU into the 2025 Big 12 title game despite having to make freshman QB Bear Bachmeier the unexpected starter during the summer. This season Sitake has one of the nation’s most experienced teams and should directly challenge Texas Tech for Big 12 supremacy and a playoff berth.”
Two other Big 12 coaches cracked the list as well. Texas Tech’s Joey McGuire is No. 9 after guiding the Red Raiders to a Big 12 title and a College Football Playoff berth, with Texas Tech favored again to win the league. Colorado’s Deion Sanders is No. 25 after the Buffaloes dropped from 9-4 in 2024 to 3-9 last season, leaving him with a pivotal year ahead in Folsom.
In Other News...
BYU Camp Puts These Returning Starters Under Real Pressure
BYU opened Fall Camp with a familiar kind of optimism, the kind that comes from bringing back several starters and expecting them to take another step in 2026. Among the names drawing the most attention are defensive end Bodie Schoonover, quarterback Bear Bachmeier and wide receiver Jojo Phillips, all of whom have already shown enough to matter and now have something more specific to prove. Schoonover is looking to sharpen his pass rushing and tackling, while Bachmeier enters camp with the kind of year-over-year pressure that comes with being the player the offense runs through.
Phillips adds another layer to that mix, because his challenge is less about physical ability than getting back to the level of trust that makes a receiver dependable in big moments. After returning from injury, he has been working to regain confidence and re-establish himself as a reliable target, which matters just as much as the technical fixes Bachmeier is chasing. For BYU, the early days of camp are not just about getting reps in, but about finding out which returning starters are ready to turn last seasons promise into something more stable this fall. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Fall Camp Has Cougars Fans Eyeing A Bigger Season
Fall camp has opened with BYU blending familiarity and change, a combination that has Cougars fans paying close attention to what this group might become. The offense still has some proven pieces in place, from quarterback Bear Bachmeier to center Bruce Mitchell, while running back LJ Martin is working his way back after shoulder surgery. Add in several new coaches in key roles and there is a sense that this team is trying to build on what it already knows instead of starting over.
For Kalani Sitake, the early tone around camp has been one of continuity and confidence, with players talking about the benefit of returning experience and a cleaner path into the season. The challenge now is turning that optimism into production once the pads stay on and the depth chart starts to settle. With new faces joining established starters, BYU has the look of a team trying to make this fall more than just a step forward. [Read more 🡒]