Lane Kiffin’s first season at LSU may be drawing the loudest complaints, but the saddest corner of college football right now belongs to a different place entirely.
That’s the picture painted in this week’s Message Board Monday, where the mood across the sport is bleak enough that even fanbases with plenty to show for themselves are sounding worn down. The complaints are coming from everywhere.
UCLA, Wake Forest and Utah are getting mentions as teams that are at least meeting expectations, and Alabama gets a nod too, especially with the College Football Playoff committee apparently not accounting for its 16-point loss at Tennessee. Kentucky and Oklahoma State have cooled off, and Indiana is still in the mix, but even that season doesn’t feel fully satisfying.
The real focus, though, is on five fanbases that seem to have landed in a different kind of misery.
LSU gets first billing, and the frustration there is rooted in Kiffin’s record in the biggest spots. One post argued that even after his impressive final year at Ole Miss, the schedule wasn’t all that daunting, and that his history in marquee games is too long to ignore.
The message was blunt: this first year has been “an utter disaster,” and there’s no way to dress it up. The poster also said LSU is stuck with him under that contract and added, “We’ve gotta be the worst sports villians ever.
Sports villains usually win. We have a losing SEC record.”
At Michigan, the tone is less anger than numbness. One fan wrote that the yard has never looked better and the garage is clean, because the heartbreak has already done its work.
The post called for a reset, including losing players to the portal and starting over, saying that any other outcome would only drag out the disaster. For now, the consolation prize is being called a basketball school.
Clemson’s section is the one that carries the most ache. The thread centered on Dabo Swinney and the early days of falling in love with him, with one fan recalling the line about not wanting Clemson to be like Michigan, Alabama and Ohio State, but instead wanting them to want to be like Clemson.
Another said it was Swinney’s enthusiasm that stood out when the program felt stale and lifeless. One poster admitted, “Strange thread is strange.
I never cared for his personality. But I liked the winning.”
Another added, “Surely you’ve been to a funeral. I was skeptical of Dabo when hired.
But his conviction to all things is what grabbed me. Not ashamed at all of what he led Clemson football to or how he led it there.”
Nebraska’s frustration is more about the future than the present. One fan asked what the selling point is supposed to be for next year, and what would make anyone believe year 5 under Matt Rhule will be different.
The post pointed to the expected new offensive coordinator, but also questioned whether Rhule’s offenses have looked much different anywhere he’s been. The fan also noted Nebraska’s financial commitment, saying the program is top 20 nationally and sixth in the Big Ten in money invested, yet the results still aren’t there.
With a big buyout, an extended defensive coordinator and money committed to bringing back the quarterback, the question was simple: how does Nebraska sell that to fans and ask them to keep buying in?
Texas A&M’s despair comes wrapped in resignation. A thread started by a 58-year-old fan declared that he is “pretty much set in concrete” that he won’t see an Aggie football national title and added that the team probably won’t be in the new 24-team Playoff any time soon.
The replies only deepened the gloom. One said, “Pretty much?
Guarantee? A&M’s football fate has been sealed forever.”
Another told everyone to look in the mirror and accept it: “We. Will.
Never. Win.
Ever. Now, go enjoy your lives.”
A third offered a grimly funny timeline of hope fading with age, ending with: “At 86 - poop!”
Of the five, Clemson’s sadness lands hardest. Kiffin can still get more chances.
Michigan can still find the right hire whenever that day comes. Nebraska and Texas A&M sound buried in their own doubts, but not quite beyond hope.
Clemson feels different. Swinney is one of the great things to happen to the program, and the fanbase knows exactly what this looks like as it starts to slip away. It’s mid-November, the biggest games are still ahead, and Clemson fans are already flipping through the old photo album.
In Other News...
BYU Just Got The Boost It Needed After The Utah Loss
BYUs response to the Utah loss has been less about scoreboard math and more about what comes next. Coaches and players have made it clear they are not spending much time on the College Football Playoff rankings, choosing instead to keep their attention on the games ahead and the week-to-week work that will determine whether the season stays on track.
Still, the ranking recognition has given the Cougars a noticeable lift at a time when they could have let the setback linger. The committees chair, Hunter Yurachek, pointed to BYUs win over Notre Dame as a major reason the Cougars landed ahead of Wake Forest, and that nod matters even if the team insists it is not dwelling on it. After the Utah loss, any reminder that the resume still carries weight is a welcome boost. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Freshman WR Jaron Pula Is Suddenly Hard To Ignore
Jaron Pula has quietly gone from a newcomer trying to catch up to a freshman wide receiver BYU has started to notice in real time. The former four-star recruit missed most of fall camp because of injury, which slowed his early push, but he has still worked his way up the depth chart and into recent games, including a career-high 12 snaps against Baylor.
For a BYU offense looking for more answers at receiver, Pulas rise is worth tracking because it has come with steady praise behind the scenes. Offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick has pointed to both his talent and the progress he has shown in practice, and the expectation now is that his role should keep growing as the season moves along. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Heads To Kansas With Major Depth Concerns On Both Sides
BYU heads into its road game at Kansas with the kind of availability questions that can change the feel of a matchup before kickoff. The Cougars will be without linebacker Isaiah Glasker and second-string running back Sione Moa, while star back LJ Martin is still working back from an ankle injury but is expected to play. Cornerback Evan Johnson and tight end Roger Saleapaga II are doubtful, adding to the uncertainty as BYU tries to keep its rotation intact on both sides of the ball.
For a team already managing depth concerns, the timing is less than ideal. Losing pieces in the front seven and in the backfield can force more players into bigger roles, and the uncertainty at corner and tight end only adds to the challenge of preparing for a road test. BYU still appears to have its lead runner available, but the Cougars will need to navigate this one with a thinner margin for error than they would prefer. [Read more 🡒]
