CFB Insider Gives Utah Surprising Nod Over Alabama

Despite Alabama's quarterback room brimming with top-tier talent and potential Heisman candidates, its exclusion from key rankings has sparked controversy.

Alabama’s quarterback room is loaded enough to make any preseason ranking look shaky, and yet CBS Sports somehow left it out of Blake Brockermeyer’s Top 10 this week.

That omission feels especially odd because the Crimson Tide don’t just have one promising option for 2026 - they have a full room that stacks up with anyone in the country. Redshirt freshman Keelon Russell has picked up the most buzz and is widely viewed as the favorite to win the job, but redshirt junior Austin Mack is still very much in the mix. The two are set to battle through fall camp for the starting role.

And even beyond that competition, the depth is the kind most programs can only dream about. Russell already has dark-horse Heisman Trophy chatter attached to his name, while Mack brings real pedigree of his own as a 4-star recruit and Top 100 overall player. Then there’s 5-star true freshman Jett Thomalla, who gives Kalen DeBoer another blue-chip arm waiting in the wings.

Brockermeyer’s list ran through Oregon, Texas, Utah, Ole Miss, Ohio State, LSU, USC, Miami, Houston and Notre Dame - with Alabama nowhere on it. No explanation was offered for the Tide’s absence, but the ranking clearly leaned toward rooms built around a more established starter.

That’s where the disconnect shows up. Ranking quarterbacks and ranking quarterback rooms are not the same thing.

If the argument is that Utah’s Devon Dampier is more proven than Mack or Russell, that’s fair. But saying Utah has a better overall room than Alabama top to bottom is a much harder sell.

The bigger point is simple: Alabama’s 2026 quarterback situation is a strength, not a concern. One of Mack or Russell should emerge as an elite option for DeBoer, and whoever comes out on top will leave the other as one of the best backups in the country. With Thomalla behind them, the Tide’s depth chart is built on talent few programs can match.

In Other News...

BYU Just Lost A Key Coach Fans Did Not Expect

Will Voigts time on the BYU basketball staff was short, but it left a real imprint. The former associate head coach arrived in 2024 and quickly became one of the more recognizable voices behind the Cougars operation, with a reputation for the peel switch scheme and for helping organize the offense. For a program that has leaned on continuity and detail, losing a staffer with that kind of niche value is not nothing.

Voigt is now heading back to a familiar place, taking on the associate head coach role at Boise State after spending more than a decade there previously. His return comes as the Broncos settle into the Pac-12, a move that officially took effect this week alongside other incoming programs including Utah State. For BYU, it is another reminder that the coaching carousel does not just reshape rosters, it can quietly alter the backbone of a teams identity. [Read more 🡒]

BYU Draft Momentum Just Showed Up In Another Big 12 Projection

Early draft boards are already giving the Big 12 a familiar look, with Sam Vecenies latest 2027 mock projecting the league to keep piling up first-round talent. Kansas Tyran Stokes headlines the group, Arizona shows up multiple times, and Baylor and West Virginia are in the mix as well, a reminder that the conferences talent pipeline is still as deep as any in the country.

For BYU, the interesting part is less about the mock itself than what it hints at for the programs momentum. Bruce Branch is in the first-round conversation, and if that kind of projection holds, it would keep the Cougars on a track they have been trying to build around: turning high-end recruiting and development into NBA-level recognition before the real draft board is ever set. [Read more 🡒]

BYU Just Won A Utah Recruiting Fight Fans Know Matters

Utah recruiting has become a lot more crowded, and BYU has been feeling the pressure from some familiar and unfamiliar places. Oklahoma coach Brent Venables has already landed the states top two high school players at the top of the board, while Utah has also kept a strong grip on its own class with commitments from the No. 6 and No. 8 prospects. Add in Michigans growing presence through Utah-connected coaches, and the race for local talent has turned into something much bigger than a regional battle.

Even with all of that noise, BYU still found a way to make a statement by securing one of the states most coveted edge rushers. The Cougars had to battle Oklahoma for the player, and the timing matters because Venables also brought a former BYU defensive lineman onto his recruiting staff, a move that only underscores how hard the fight for Utah talent has become. For BYU, this was more than just another commitment. It was a reminder that in a year when outsiders are circling, the Cougars can still win a recruiting fight that fans in Provo know matters. [Read more 🡒]