BYU’s special teams picture is still coming into focus, and the biggest opening right now is at returner.
After Saturday’s first scrimmage of Fall Camp, Kalani Sitake said he feels good about the special teams groups overall, but he also made clear that the Cougars are sorting through several candidates to handle punts. BYU has to replace every starter at the specialist spots in 2026, which makes this one of the more important competitions on the roster.
At punt return, Sitake named five players in the mix: Cannon Devries, Tiger Bachmeier, Preston Rex, Legend Glasker, and Evan Johnson. Of that group, Devries and Bachmeier “have an edge,” based on their prior experience.
Bachmeier brings the kind of résumé that makes him an obvious candidate. Before transferring to BYU, he handled punt returns at Stanford and even took one 90 yards for a touchdown against Cal Poly.
The upside is obvious. The issue showed up early in 2025, when Parker Kingston muffed a few punts and Bachmeier briefly took over the job.
He didn’t lock it down. Bachmeier struggled, and the role went back to Kingston.
He also fielded multiple punts inside his own five-yard line, a sign that his decision-making needs to tighten up if he’s going to win the job.
Devries, meanwhile, looks like the steadier projection. He was a dynamic return man in high school, served as BYU’s backup punt returner last season, and even got a chance to return a punt against Portland State in the opener. If the Cougars were forced to pick a starter today, Devries would be the best bet.
Glasker is another intriguing option. The true freshman wide receiver is expected to have a role on offense, and he already showed return ability as a senior at Lehi last season.
He has the kind of speed that can flip a field in a hurry. The question is whether BYU wants to expose him to the added injury risk, especially with offensive responsibilities waiting for him.
Rex is a different kind of candidate. He was a wide receiver in high school and also returned kicks, and Sitake specifically mentioned him as someone who stood out on Saturday. Rex doesn’t have the same top-end speed as some of the others in the race, but he is a reliable catcher with sound decision-making.
Johnson may be the most explosive name on the list. Sitake called him the fastest player on BYU’s roster, and his background as a high school wide receiver means he’s comfortable securing the ball. But he’s also one of the most important players on BYU’s defense, which makes the injury risk hard to ignore even if the return upside is obvious.
There’s also a separate battle shaping up on kickoffs. Devaughn Eka is not in the punt return mix, but he is competing to handle kickoff returns.
The true freshman flashed his speed in Saturday’s scrimmage, breaking a tackle and outrunning the defense for a long touchdown. Sitake singled out Eka and the other running backs after the scrimmage.
For now, BYU has options. The challenge is finding the right blend of explosiveness, security, and availability before the season gets rolling.
In Other News...
BYUs Offense Looks Real Again As One Defensive Concern Lingers
BYU wrapped the first two weeks of fall camp with a scrimmage that tilted toward the offense, a welcome sign for a program trying to build real momentum on that side of the ball again. Quarterback Bear Bachmeier has reportedly taken a notable step forward from last season, and he is working with a deep, talented collection of weapons that gives the Cougars more options than they had a year ago.
The defense still has plenty going for it, especially speed, but one lingering issue remains hard to ignore. BYU has not yet identified a clear star pass rusher, and that leaves a little uncertainty about where the consistent pressure is going to come from when the games start to matter. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Fans Just Got A Revealing Look At Utahs Football Divide
A new Deseret News/Hinckley Institute of Politics poll offers a useful snapshot of where Utah college football loyalties stand, and it is a reminder that the rivalry landscape in the state is broader than one game. Among Utah fans surveyed, 36% said they most closely follow the University of Utah, while 29% said BYU and 13% said Utah State, giving a clearer picture of how the fan base is divided across the state.
The more revealing part for BYU followers is how those allegiances shift by age, religion and politics. Younger and older fans leaned more toward BYU, while middle-aged fans were more likely to side with Utah, and the survey also found differences tied to religious background and political affiliation. For BYU, that kind of split matters because its fan base has always been about more than win-loss records, and this poll suggests the schools reach still cuts in different directions depending on who is looking. [Read more 🡒]
BYUs Frontcourt Plan Hinges On One Crucial Eligibility Fight
BYU still has two open roster spots to sort through, and the frontcourt remains the biggest piece of the puzzle. The Cougars are in the mix for a Michigan State big man who would fit a clear need, and they are watching a California court injunction that could determine whether he is even allowed to enter the transfer portal. If the ruling goes the players way, BYU is viewed as one of the leading candidates to land him.
There is also another name in the frame, but the financial side of the equation is already shaping the rest of the search. With limited room to maneuver, the Cougars appear to be working through a choice rather than building out a full wish list, which leaves the frontcourt plan tied to a legal decision as much as a basketball one. For now, the roster picture is still waiting on that next turn. [Read more 🡒]