BYU’s first official practices have already started to answer some of the biggest questions around the program, and the biggest one still hangs over Jaxon Kohler.
The Cougars have 15 players on the roster, with Kohler and Petar Ostojic both enrolled and working out with the team. Kohler’s status is the one everyone is watching, though, because he is eligible right now but still has hurdles to clear if he wants to stay on the floor for the season.
That next checkpoint comes Sept. 29, when the case he is involved in gets a preliminary injunction hearing in California State Court in Santa Clara at 3:00 PT. Several other states have already held similar hearings, and Ryan Downton, the managing partner leading most of these cases, recently handled one in Indiana against the NCAA. Downton and his group won the preliminary injunction there in what the source described as the NCAA’s backyard.
The latest argument from plaintiffs is that the NCAA’s own five-for-five rules do not exclude the class of 2022, a claim courts have reportedly been receptive to. Players and coaches tied to the California case are heading to Santa Clara for the hearing, and one source said Kohler and BYU assistant Chris Burgess will be there, with Kevin Young potentially attending as well.
A ruling on the injunction won’t end the fight, but it matters. If the injunction is granted, the NCAA will almost certainly try to appeal and stay it. If it is denied, Kohler and the other plaintiffs would have to wait for trial to learn whether they are eligible.
The sense from those around the case, at least from the reporting here, is that the players are gaining ground.
And for BYU, Kohler is the swing piece. The source called him the most impactful fifth-year player in college basketball who could suit up this season, and the reason is obvious: with him, BYU looks like a top-15 team.
He gives the Cougars elite spacing, one of the best shooting bigs in the sport, and a skilled scorer on the block. He’s also a strong rebounder and was one of the best in the Big Ten last season.
Even with questions about BYU’s defense, Kohler’s years under Tom Izzo are viewed as a big reason he would compete hard on that end.
Without him, the frontcourt picture gets messy fast. BYU would be looking at Khadim Mboup, Petar Ostojic and Jake Wahlin at the five, a group the source described as far from ideal. That version of the team would still have shooting and some high-end moments, but it would also carry a major center concern and would be vulnerable when the shots stop dropping.
On the recruiting side, BYU is chasing another huge class under Kevin Young. The Cougars have landed a five-star in each of Young’s first three offseasons - Egor Demin, AJ Dybantsa and Bruce Branch - and they are trying to keep that streak going in 2027.
The name at the top of the board right now is AJ Williams, a 6-foot-7 wing who was the No. 1 prospect in the 2028 class before reclassifying to 2027, where 247 Sports now has him at No. 5.
He’s a scorer, and the fit at BYU is easy to picture based on how Young would use him. Williams has already taken official visits to Auburn and Mississippi State, with North Carolina, Kentucky, Duke, Arkansas and others among the schools still in the mix.
Georgia is a school to watch, and industry sources have BYU near the top of his list as he works through official visits.
BYU is in the process of setting up an official visit, and one possible weekend is Oct. 17, when Williams could be in Provo for the exhibition against Nebraska and the football game against Notre Dame.
The Cougars are also involved with five-star big man Lewis Uvwo and four-star big man Cherif Millogo. BYU was the first to offer Uvwo and has been on him the longest, but the source notes that big men are expensive right now and that landing Williams plus a top freshman big may not be realistic financially. BYU is recruiting both, but if Williams commits, the belief is that the bigs would likely go elsewhere.
Another name to know is DeMarcus Henry, a five-star wing who is LDS and the nephew of former BYU running back Fui Vakapuna. BYU has been in contact with him for months, but sources say the Cougars are not currently viewed as one of his top options. Still, with his family ties, the door may not be closed for long.
The bottom line from this notebook is simple: BYU appears likely to land only one five-star freshman in this cycle, which would have sounded wild before Kevin Young arrived. Right now, Williams is the priority.
There is also a closed scrimmage on the calendar. BYU will face Long Beach State on Saturday, Oct. 10 in Provo, but the event will not be open to the public and won’t be broadcast.
The expectation is that no stats will be released, though that has not been confirmed. The Cougars are allowed three exhibition games, and they’ve chosen to keep one of them behind closed doors.
The other two are against Nebraska and at UNLV.
As for how BYU may line up, the group getting the most run in practice has been Jaxon Kohler, Tyler Betsey, Bruce Branch, Collin Chandler and Rob Wright. That five-man group would bring a ton of spacing and, on paper, could be the best shooting lineup in the country.
Betsey has also drawn strong buzz this offseason. The 6-foot-8 forward was productive at Syracuse last year, averaging 6.7 points while shooting 41% from three, and multiple people have told the source that he has been BYU’s best shooter in practice. The expectation is that he could take another step as a junior.
In Other News...
BYU Just Added Another Twist Before A Huge Trip To TCU
BYU is keeping its weekly uniform reveal rolling, and the Cougars will bring another new look into a major Big 12 road game at TCU. The team announced it will wear all white with royal trim and royal helmets, continuing a season-long pattern of changing things up every week. It is the fourth different combination BYU has used in as many games, another small wrinkle as the Cougars head into one of the more important trips on the schedule.
The setting at TCU adds to the intrigue, with weather expected to factor into the matchup and both teams carrying recent results that give the game a little extra weight. BYU has already shown it is willing to mix style with substance, but the real test will be whether the new uniform comes with the same edge on the field. For a team still settling into the rhythm of conference play, every detail matters, including what the Cougars are wearing when they walk into Fort Worth. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Made An Early Move That Could Shake Up Safety Competition
During BYUs bye week, safeties coach Demario Warren made an early move in the recruiting market by extending a scholarship offer to JUCO safety Jadyn Hudson of the College of San Mateo. Hudson brings some real intrigue to the position room as a former UCLA freshman and four-star recruit, and he has already drawn an offer from Western Michigan as well.
For BYU, the timing matters because the Cougars are still sorting out depth and competition at safety, and Hudson fits the profile of a player who could help immediately while still offering room to develop. He has three years of eligibility remaining and comes with a reputation for strong ball skills and tackling, two traits that tend to travel well if the Cougars can get him on campus. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Heads To TCU With A Major Offensive Line Concern
BYU heads into its trip to TCU with a key question on the offensive line, as starting right tackle Andrew Gentry is listed as questionable because of injury. The Cougars have had to manage their front five carefully all season, and this latest uncertainty comes at a time when continuity up front matters even more against a conference opponent on the road.
If Gentry cannot go, freshmen Bott Mulitalo and Siosiua Latu-Finau are in line to battle for the spot at right tackle. There is some good news on the injury front, though, with coach Kalani Sitake saying offensive lineman Kyle Sfarcioc, tight end Roger Saleapaga and receiver Tiger Bachmeier are expected back after missing the previous game, giving BYU at least a few more options as it tries to sort out its lineup. [Read more 🡒]