KANSAS CITY - Randy Bennett spent more than a decade making life miserable for BYU in the West Coast Conference. Now he’s back in the same neighborhood, only this time the Cougars are waiting for him in the Big 12.
For 12 seasons as conference foes, Bennett and Saint Mary’s were constant problems for BYU. The Gaels were a regular obstacle in the Cougars’ push for at-large NCAA Tournament bids, and the matchups carried the kind of edge that made each meeting feel bigger than the standings.
When BYU left the WCC in 2023, Bennett said he “celebrated.” He figured that chapter was closed for good.
Instead, Bennett ended up at Arizona State after leaving Saint Mary’s following 25 seasons, and the Sun Devils’ first conference game of the year is set for Jan. 2 against BYU.
“I thought I was done with Provo!” a laughing Bennett told the Deseret News at Big 12 basketball media days in Kansas City.
That doesn’t mean he forgot what those games were like. Bennett has faced BYU 30 times in his career and owns a 19-11 record against the Cougars, including 3-1 in the WCC tournament. He spoke with obvious respect about a program he spent years battling.
“BYU is a great football, basketball and athletic program. Honestly, I really enjoyed playing BYU and playing at BYU,” Bennett said.
“I know it’s a really tough venue to play at, they have great fans, but that’s why it’s great, you want those challenges. It’s one of those few places that you just stare at 20,000 fans.
They’re all pulling for BYU, which is the way it should be.
“(Facing BYU) was like going to play Gonzaga. When you’re in the moment, you’re like, ‘It’s going to be tough,’ but you look forward to those games. That’s what gets you in the gym in the summertime, that’s what gets you doing those extra workouts and that extra set of weights, it’s for those type of games.”
The rivalry produced plenty of the kind of games people remember years later. Jeff Call once described it as a series of “physical, intense games and fantastic finishes,” and that fits. The last 11 meetings between BYU and Saint Mary’s were all decided by 10 points or fewer, and seven were settled by a single possession.
Bennett’s favorite BYU memories are the ones that ended in heartbreak for the Cougars in Provo - Matthew Dellavedova’s half-court winner in 2013 and Aidan Mahaney’s last-second shot in 2023. But BYU got its share of payback, too. TJ Haws hit late heroics in 2020, the Cougars beat Saint Mary’s in the 2018 WCC semifinals in a result that effectively kept the Gaels out of the NCAA Tournament, and BYU also won in 2022 despite making just one 3-pointer.
“We had some great games there, and I remember some of the tough ones too, when (BYU) had really good teams and beat us in our place,” Bennett said. “So it was a very spirited, good rivalry.”
Bennett’s move to Arizona State was rooted in geography and timing. A native of nearby Mesa, he said the Sun Devils were always the only school he had “circled” if he ever left Saint Mary’s. When Arizona State parted ways with Bobby Hurley in March, Bennett became the clear choice in Tempe, bringing 589 career wins with him.
His departure from Saint Mary’s came after a run that included 11 combined conference titles and seven league Coach of the Year awards. He raised his kids in Moraga and said he’ll especially miss the coaches and athletic directors he got to know over 25 seasons.
Still, he felt ready for the change.
“(Arizona State) was the only place where if they ever came calling, I’d be very interested in doing it,” Bennett said.
“And it was good timing, too, because we’d done a lot at Saint Mary’s. With Gonzaga leaving that league (for the Pac-12), I don’t know how much more we could have done. It’s going to be harder now to get at-large bids out of that league, so it was a good time to change.”
BYU, meanwhile, has transformed since those WCC battles. The Cougars finished below .500 in their final season in the league, but since joining the Big 12 they are 33-23 against conference competition, have made three NCAA Tournaments, reached the Sweet 16 in 2025 and boosted recruiting in a way the program hadn’t before.
Bennett has not yet coached against Kevin Young, though he said he “got to know him a little bit” when Young was an assistant with the Phoenix Suns. “Really nice guy,” Bennett said.
He also credited BYU for keeping up in a tougher league.
“(BYU) had to step it up because they came to Big 12, and they did, they’ve done great,” Bennett said. “You’ve got to adapt and adjust to this NIL time, or you’re probably going to fall behind. I think they adapted to the situation, they’ve gotten good players and good coaches, although they’ve always had good coaches.”
In Other News...
BYU Could Get A Big Backfield Boost Against UCF
BYUs backfield could get an important lift this week with running back Sione Moa no longer on the injury report for the matchup against UCF. Moa is medically cleared to play, giving the Cougars a potential boost in a spot where depth always matters, even if his actual workload will still come down to how confident and ready he feels once game day arrives.
The rest of BYUs report is relatively light, with right guard Kyle Sfarcioc and safety Tommy Prassas still listed, while UCF is dealing with a much busier set of availability questions. The Knights have starting quarterback Alonza Barnett III marked questionable and five players already ruled out, including offensive lineman Owen Spell and linebacker Lewis Carter, setting up a game where both teams will be watching the injury situation closely right up to kickoff. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Suddenly Has A Backfield Question That Could Shape Everything
Bear Bachmeiers national recognition and Cade Uluaves Big 12 honor gave BYU plenty to celebrate after the win over Notre Dame, but the Cougars also left that game with a reminder that depth across the roster is still going to matter. With LJ Martin and Sione Moa sidelined by injuries, backup backs Preston Rex and Journee Tonga were thrown into meaningful work and helped stabilize an offense that needed them to hold up their end of the bargain.
That leaves the backfield in a familiar but delicate spot for Kalani Sitakes staff. Sitake praised the way the running backs have developed and contributed, but BYU is still evaluating Moas readiness to return after an injury history that has complicated his availability. How that shakes out could shape the balance of an offense coming off one of its biggest wins of the season. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Just Added A New Threat To Its Big 12 Push
With the Big 12 at its midpoint and three teams still unbeaten in league and overall play, BYU has already done enough to make the conference race feel crowded. The Cougars win over Notre Dame, pulled off despite injuries, has only sharpened the sense that this team belongs in the conversation with the leagues best, especially with several ranked teams still sorting out their own issues and identities.
What makes BYUs position even more interesting is how much turbulence sits around it. Houston has gotten a big lift from Conner Weigmans passing, Texas Tech has found more rhythm on offense, and other contenders have run into problems, from Oklahoma States defensive struggles to Baylors offensive issues and Arizona States in-game quarterback change. For BYU, the next stretch will say plenty about whether its fast start is a real Big 12 platform or just the opening chapter of a tougher climb. [Read more 🡒]