BYU’s roster picture still has one big unresolved piece, and it all comes back to Jaxon Kohler.
The 6-foot-10 Michigan State big man is the player BYU wants most as it tries to finish building out its 2024-25 roster. If he becomes eligible to move, he could be the kind of addition that changes the entire feel of the team - a frontcourt piece who scores on the block, shoots it well for a big, rebounds at a high level and, in this view, instantly lifts BYU into contender territory in the Big 12.
Kohler’s appeal is easy to see. He’d be one of the top big men in the league, and the belief here is that no other frontcourt target BYU chased this offseason would raise the ceiling more.
The projection is that he’d lead BYU in rebounding and sit right behind Rob Wright in scoring, while also ranking among the best offensive bigs in the conference. In this assessment, only Arizona’s Mo Krivas and Houston’s Jo Tugler belong in the same conversation with him among the league’s best bigs.
The hold-up is legal, not basketball-related. Right now, Kohler can play a fifth year but only at Michigan State because of a California injunction.
He is one of several players tied to that case, and if the injunction is granted, it would allow him to enter the transfer portal. Other state-level injunctions in Ohio and Tennessee have already gone in the players’ favor, letting them play a fifth year and transfer.
The expectation is that the courts will side with the players again, and there should be a federal ruling early next week from the tenth circuit in the Colorado case that was recently decided. If that ruling also goes against the NCAA, it could finally push the organization to give in.
If Kohler does become available, BYU appears to be in the best spot. Kentucky, Kansas, Louisville and others have pushed hard, but BYU has stayed out front in this race.
Kevin Young has reportedly made a strong impression on Kohler, and there’s also a real pull for him to remain close to home for his final college season. BYU has also improved its NIL offer in recent weeks, which had been the biggest obstacle.
The Cougars still may not be the top bidder, but the gap is no longer seen as overwhelming. Louisville, though, is viewed as the strongest competition after making a strong NIL offer of its own.
The sense is that once Kohler’s eligibility situation is resolved, a decision could follow quickly - possibly as soon as this week.
That also makes the Keba Keita question fairly straightforward. Keita is part of the same California injunction case, but Kohler is the preferred option for BYU. There is not enough money left to land both, and unless Keita were willing to play essentially for free, the idea of BYU signing both players is described as virtually impossible.
So if BYU does land Kohler, one roster spot would still remain open. And even then, that last spot would not be reserved for an impact addition. At this stage of the offseason, there simply isn’t enough money or playing opportunity left to bring in a major piece.
That’s why leaving the spot open is very much on the table. BYU could also use it later in the year, much like it did with Abdullah Ahmed last season, giving the staff flexibility for a winter addition if injuries hit or if the team gets on campus and decides a specific need has to be addressed.
In Other News...
BYUs Offense Looks Real Again As One Defensive Concern Lingers
BYU wrapped the first two weeks of fall camp with a scrimmage that tilted toward the offense, a welcome sign for a program trying to build real momentum on that side of the ball again. Quarterback Bear Bachmeier has reportedly taken a notable step forward from last season, and he is working with a deep, talented collection of weapons that gives the Cougars more options than they had a year ago.
The defense still has plenty going for it, especially speed, but one lingering issue remains hard to ignore. BYU has not yet identified a clear star pass rusher, and that leaves a little uncertainty about where the consistent pressure is going to come from when the games start to matter. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Fans Just Got A Revealing Look At Utahs Football Divide
A new Deseret News/Hinckley Institute of Politics poll offers a useful snapshot of where Utah college football loyalties stand, and it is a reminder that the rivalry landscape in the state is broader than one game. Among Utah fans surveyed, 36% said they most closely follow the University of Utah, while 29% said BYU and 13% said Utah State, giving a clearer picture of how the fan base is divided across the state.
The more revealing part for BYU followers is how those allegiances shift by age, religion and politics. Younger and older fans leaned more toward BYU, while middle-aged fans were more likely to side with Utah, and the survey also found differences tied to religious background and political affiliation. For BYU, that kind of split matters because its fan base has always been about more than win-loss records, and this poll suggests the schools reach still cuts in different directions depending on who is looking. [Read more 🡒]