The Big 12 admitted Sunday that replay got it wrong in one of the most consequential moments of BYU’s 27-20 win over Arizona State.
The error came early in the first quarter, when BYU had second-and-goal near the Sun Devils’ goal line. Quarterback Bear Bachmeier tried to push the ball into the end zone, but he lost control before the play was over. Sione Moa scooped up the fumble near the goal line and was then given a touchdown after a replay review.
That ruling, the conference said, should not have stood.
In its postgame statement, the Big 12 explained that once Bachmeier lost possession before the forward progress spot, BYU should have kept the ball where Moa recovered it. NCAA replay rules did not allow the recovering player to advance the fumble.
“Replay was incorrect in awarding a score,” the Big 12 said in its statement.
Instead of a touchdown, BYU should have faced third-and-goal from the Arizona State two-yard line.
The call loomed large because the final score ended up matching the value of the mistake. BYU won by seven, and the replay ruling had handed the Cougars seven points.
That doesn’t automatically mean Arizona State would have changed the outcome. BYU still would have had a short-yardage snap from the two-yard line and could have scored anyway. But it remains a major miss, especially with replay officials stopping the game to take a second look and still landing on the wrong answer.
Arizona State did fight back after falling behind 17-3 at halftime. The Sun Devils tied it at 17 in the third quarter before BYU answered with 10 straight points in the fourth.
The win pushed BYU to 7-1 overall and 4-1 in Big 12 play, leaving the Cougars one game behind undefeated Utah in the conference standings.
In Other News...
BYUs UCF Win Looks Different After The Knights Ugly Reality Check
BYUs win over UCF suddenly carries a different kind of weight after the Knights followed that double-overtime thriller with a sobering 41-9 loss to Baylor. What looked at the time like a tough road result against a dangerous opponent now sits in a sharper light, especially with UCFs offense sputtering to a season-low output and failing to find the end zone at all.
Baylor also exposed just how much ground UCF still has to cover in the trenches, piling up 501 yards and seven sacks against the Knights offensive line. The blowout got worse when Keyone Jenkins left with an ankle injury, leaving UCF with more questions than answers heading into the next stretch and giving BYU a little more perspective on what that earlier matchup really meant. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Escaped A Scare And Now Everything Points To Utah
BYU got what it needed at LaVell Edwards Stadium, but not without a few tense moments along the way. The Cougars held off Arizona State 27-20 behind Bear Bachmeiers 236 passing yards and a touchdown, while Sione Moa powered the ground game with two rushing scores, a combination that helped BYU move to 7-1 overall and 4-1 in Big 12 play.
Now the focus shifts to a rivalry game that has a way of revealing exactly how far a team has come. BYU has banked another league win and kept its place near the top of the conference race, but the margin for error is shrinking as the calendar turns toward Utah and all the noise that comes with it. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Could Finally Benefit From A Playoff Change Fans Will Debate
A proposed move to a 24-team College Football Playoff would stir plenty of debate, especially among fans who worry that a bigger bracket could water down the sports most meaningful stretch. But for programs like BYU, the conversation cuts the other way. A larger field would offer a clearer path into the postseason and reduce the kind of subjective selection drama that has so often left teams on the outside looking in.
The bigger picture is not just about more bids, but about making the postseason feel more inclusive without stripping away the urgency of the regular season. College football has long lived with the tension between access and exclusivity, and the expanded format is being framed as a way to ease scheduling headaches while keeping the stakes high. For BYU, that kind of change could finally turn a familiar frustration into a real opportunity. [Read more 🡒]