In the transfer portal era, BYU has had to fight to keep its roster together, and last January the program poured time and NIL resources into retaining every projected starter with eligibility left. Even with that kind of effort, departures still happen every year. The bigger question is what happens next.
A look at 81 transfers out of the BYU football program since 2020 gives a pretty clear answer: leaving Provo has more often led to flat or declining production than a step forward. The picture gets even sharper once you separate the transfers who landed at another FBS school from the ones who moved down or never found another roster.
Nearly half of the 81 transfers didn’t fit the comparison at all. Twenty-eight percent dropped to the FCS level to finish their careers, and 20% didn’t land on another college football roster. That leaves the 52% who transferred to another FBS program - the group that tells the real story.
Among those players, 17% would have been better off staying at BYU because their production fell off after the move. Linebacker Harrison Taggart is one example. He played a lot of snaps for BYU in 2024 before heading to Cal for the 2025 season, and both his playing time and production were cut in half there.
Crew Wakley fits in that same bucket. He would have been a backup for the Cougars, but his move to Purdue didn’t produce much return. In 2025, Wakley played only 60 snaps before leaving the team, a steep drop from the 360 snaps he logged for BYU in 2024.
The largest chunk of FBS transfers - 45% - stayed about the same after leaving. That doesn’t mean the move helped.
In a lot of cases, it looks more like development stalled. Players who stick in one program usually keep building year after year, but that wasn’t the pattern here.
Former BYU cornerback Gabe Jeudy-Lally is a good example. His production at Tennessee in 2023 was nearly identical to what he did at BYU in 2022, and his BYU season looked almost the same as his 2021 year at Vanderbilt.
Clark Barrington followed a similar path. After three years as a starter, he transferred to Baylor for his final season, and his production stayed essentially flat.
His PFF grades also dipped compared to his last two seasons at BYU.
Jake Retzlaff was the most public transfer out of the program. He wanted to remain at BYU, but a suspension pushed him into the portal and he landed at Tulane.
The change in competition didn’t move the needle much. Retzlaff averaged 226.7 passing yards per game in 2024 at BYU and 226.3 at Tulane.
Other former Cougars whose production stayed level at their new schools include Aisea Moa, Jacob Conover, Jackson Bowers, Quenton Rice, and Devin Kaufusi.
There were also players who clearly did better after leaving, though most of those gains came at the Group of Six level. In all, 20% of BYU transfers improved their production at their new schools, and the majority of those were G6 moves.
Miles Davis is a strong example. He was headed toward a third-string role at BYU, then transferred to Utah State and posted career highs in carries and yards.
Dallin Holker’s move was even more dramatic. After splitting reps with Isaac Rex when he left BYU in the middle of the 2022 season, he went to Colorado State and became an All-American.
Jake Eichorn, David Latu, and Carson Tujague also moved to the Group of Six and ended up playing important roles in the Mountain West.
Only six BYU transfers in the study improved their production after moving to another Power Four school. Those are the ones the Cougars would have liked to keep in Provo.
Keelan Marion is one of them. After leaving BYU following Spring Camp, he landed at Miami and put up a career-high 746 yards last season, compared with 346 receiving yards for BYU in 2024.
John Henry Daley is another major miss. BYU had been searching for a dominant pass rusher for years, and Daley turned into exactly that after transferring out.
He led the country in sacks last season before a season-ending injury. Logan Fano, who started opposite Daley at Utah, also began his career at BYU.
Tate Romney became a starter at Arizona State after leaving BYU, while Campbell Barrington and Joshua Singh are the other P4 transfers in the group that improved after moving on.
The broader takeaway is hard to ignore. Only 20% of BYU’s outgoing transfers improved after leaving, and most of those gains came after dropping to the G6.
Just 7% of transfers went to another Power Four school and got better. Meanwhile, half of the departures never found another FBS home, and of the players who did land somewhere else, 62% either stayed the same or got worse.
For BYU, the transfer portal has produced a few success stories. But the numbers say the grass usually isn’t greener once a Cougar leaves Provo.
In Other News...
Why Kalani Sitake Staying At BYU Suddenly Feels Even Bigger
With coaching turnover hitting the Big 12 again, Kalani Sitakes place at BYU has taken on a different kind of weight. He is now the conferences longest-tenured head coach, a reminder that stability still matters in a league where change has become the norm. Sitake has built his program around a LaVell Edwards-inspired approach that puts player development, culture, discipline and sacrifice ahead of chasing the biggest financial pitch.
That message has resonated inside the locker room, too. Sitake chose to stay at BYU when he had other options, and most of his starters are back for the upcoming season, giving the Cougars a level of continuity many programs can only hope for. In a conference constantly reshuffling its hierarchy, BYU suddenly looks like a team with both an established voice and a roster willing to follow it. [Read more 🡒]
ESPN Just Put Ty Detmer In Rare Air With College Football Legends
ESPNs latest jersey-number project sent a little more spotlight toward the states football lineage, and it was a familiar name at the center of it. Ty Detmer, the BYU quarterback whose college career still looms large in Provo, was among the players ESPN identified at the top of their numbers, joining a list that also included Utah ties like Merlin Olsen and Haloti Ngata.
For BYU fans, Detmers inclusion is the kind of national nod that never really gets old because it reinforces how long his legacy has traveled beyond campus. The broader list also surfaced a couple more Utah-connected names in the mix, with Robbie Bosco and Jordan Gross earning runner-up recognition, a reminder that the regions football history keeps showing up whenever college greats are ranked and re-ranked. [Read more 🡒]