There’s never really been a moment like this for BYU football.
Not with this kind of national spotlight. Not with this much praise rolling in from every direction. And not with the Cougars sitting at No. 2 in the AP Top 25 after their win over Notre Dame on Saturday night.
The reaction to BYU’s latest statement has been loud and widespread. In the days since the game, the Cougars have been the subject of a wave of commentary from across college football - writers, broadcasters, analysts, coaches, former coaches and former players all weighing in. The tone has been overwhelmingly positive, and in a lot of those conversations, BYU has even been pushed into the No. 1 discussion.
That argument has been built on two things: the losses taken by other highly ranked teams, and the résumé and performance of top-ranked Miami, which many observers have said doesn’t measure up to what BYU has done so far.
And it hasn’t just been the ranking that changed. The praise has spread everywhere.
Kalani Sitake has been lauded. Offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick has been lauded.
Bear Bachmeier has been lauded. The offensive line has been lauded.
The receivers and tight ends have been lauded. The defense has been lauded.
The culture has been lauded. The setting and scenery and crowd and atmosphere at LaVell Edwards Stadium have been lauded.
Cosmo and Cougartails and Cougarettes have been lauded.
The only people not getting love? The Big 12 refs and the clock operator at LES.
Plenty of viewers and commentators said the officiating crew missed pass interference on Notre Dame’s final offensive snap. Others - including the Big 12 - said there should have been one second left after the incomplete pass. Some also argued that the final play, which started with four seconds left, took longer than four seconds from snap to the ball hitting the ground, and that the clock operator started the clock late.
Even so, most of the reaction hasn’t been aimed at taking anything away from BYU. Outside of a small group of angry Notre Dame fans, the consensus from people who watched the game in the stadium or on television is that the Cougars outplayed the Irish in just about every way and deserved the win.
That’s what makes this moment stand out. BYU has had achievements before - a national championship in 1984, a Heisman winner, Outland Trophy, Doak Walker and Davey O’Brien winners, plus All-Americans. But the respect surrounding this team feels different.
When the Cougars finished No. 1 in the polls in 1984, they kept the trophy. But the wider football world didn’t embrace it.
A lot of people believed BYU hadn’t faced enough of a challenge that season, that the schedule was too soft, and some of those same people made sure the title carried a cloud for years afterward. In some circles, the Cougars were even mocked for it, with the feeling that future postseason formats were designed to keep a team like BYU from getting that kind of reward again.
Now, in a sport still shaped by power, money and access battles among the Power 4 conferences, BYU has landed in a different place. As of Saturday night, it may not be universally adored, but it is unquestionably being viewed with far more reverence than before.
There’s a bit of irony in the Big 12 and its supporters using BYU as proof of the league’s strength, especially after so many years when the Cougars were on the outside trying to get in. But that’s where things stand now. The conference can point to BYU as part of its case, and BYU is willing to help its league-mates in every way except one: by losing to them.
That said, the Cougars still have to handle what comes next. They’ll need to guard against the kind of emotional or executional letdown that can follow a huge win and a flood of praise. And looming ahead is a matchup with a highly talented Utah team in early November.
Even if BYU drops that game - and maybe more than one Big 12 team makes the playoff - the broader picture could still hold. Right now, before the first CFP rankings are released, BYU, Texas Tech and Utah are all in the AP poll’s top 10.
What happens from here isn’t locked in. What is clear, though, is that BYU football has more respect on its name right now than it ever has before. Keeping it there will be on the Cougars.
In Other News...
Jaxon Kohler Just Got A Huge Boost In BYU Eligibility Fight
Jaxon Kohlers eligibility case just got a major lift in Santa Clara, where a court granted an injunction in the Glancey vs. NCAA case that helps keep the former class of 2022 players on the field. For BYU, the ruling matters because it gives Kohler a stronger path to a fifth season of eligibility under NCAA bylaws, rather than leaving his status in limbo while the legal process drags on.
The injunction is prohibitory, which means it preserves the current status quo instead of serving as a short-term stopgap, and that distinction gives Kohler more breathing room as the case moves forward. The NCAA can still appeal, and a trial date remains pending, but this ruling is a meaningful step for BYU because it sharply improves Kohlers odds of being available for the full season. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Has The Edge Over UCF Until One Variable Changes Everything
BYU heads into its matchup with UCF with the kind of profile that usually travels well: a clear statistical edge and a defense that has helped separate the Cougars from a Knights team that has stayed competitive but is still dealing with the ripple effects of a quarterback injury. The betting line reflects that gap, with BYU favored by about a touchdown, and on paper the Cougars appear positioned to control the game if they play to form.
Keyone Jenkins is set to start for UCF in place of the injured regular quarterback, which already adds one layer of uncertainty for a Knights offense trying to keep pace. The bigger twist, though, may come from the sky. Rain could muddy the passing game and shift the whole feel of the afternoon, giving UCF a path to hang around longer than the numbers suggest and making BYU's edge a little less comfortable than it looks on paper. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Is Winning Over Voters But One Debate Isnt Going Away
BYUs unbeaten start and statement win over then-No. 2 Notre Dame have clearly resonated with human voters, pushing the Cougars up to No. 2 in the AP Top 25 and No. 3 in the US LBM Coaches Poll. It is the kind of rise that reflects both the record and the quality of the rsum, and it has put BYU squarely in the national conversation in a way few expected this early.
The numbers, though, are still not fully aligned with that view. Computer rankings remain far more cautious, with ESPNs Football Power Index placing BYU at No. 14, and other systems slotting the Cougars anywhere from No. 4 to No. 14. For a team trying to turn a fast start into something lasting, the split between human confidence and algorithmic skepticism is becoming one of the more interesting threads around the program. [Read more 🡒]