BYU walked out of LaVell Edwards Stadium with a 27-20 win over Arizona State, but the performance came with plenty of uneven edges. Brandon Gurney’s position-by-position grades paint a picture of a team that got enough big moments to win, while still leaving room for concern on both sides of the ball.
Bear Bachmeier’s day was a little of everything. The sophomore quarterback flashed the arm talent to squeeze throws into tight windows, including a touchdown pass to Kyler Kasper.
But he also forced a costly interception late in the first half, one that shaped how the second half played out. His legs never really became a factor, though Arizona State’s double-spy approach had a lot to do with that, especially with BYU’s running backs offering little threat.
That lack of balance showed up clearly in the backfield grades. With LJ Martin unavailable and Preston Rex also out injured, BYU never found much rhythm on the ground.
Journee Tonga didn’t make an impact, and while Sione Moa scored twice, his eight carries produced only 20 yards. The Cougars simply didn’t do enough to make Arizona State respect the run.
The receiving group had its moments, but not without mistakes. Kyler Kasper’s fumble and some drops slowed BYU down, even as freshman standout Legend Glasker delivered the game’s biggest offensive play with a 53-yard catch from Bachmeier. Walker Lyons added five catches for 49 yards, while Roger Saleapaga showed early promise before fading from the action, possibly because of an injury.
Up front, the offensive line wasn’t the culprit behind BYU’s struggles. The group held up fairly well in pass protection, even after losing another key piece in Trevin Ostler to injury. Kyle Sfarcioc’s return helped, and the line was solid overall, but it didn’t create the kind of running lanes that could have helped a thin backfield take pressure off Bachmeier.
Defensively, BYU got strong edge pressure, but the interior gave up too much ground. Arizona State freshman Cardae Mack ran for 123 yards on 26 carries, and the Cougars didn’t control the middle the way they needed to. Keanu Tanuvasa had several standout snaps and made his presence felt in key spots, but the unit as a whole wasn’t at its sharpest.
The linebackers also left plays on the field. The fits weren’t clean enough, and too many tackles were missed.
Middle linebacker Cade Uluave had one particularly costly miss when he completely whiffed on Jake Fette, allowing a first down at a critical moment. It was the kind of tackling issue that made Kalani Sitake’s emphasis on technique feel necessary heading into next week’s prep for Utah.
In the secondary, BYU found its best defensive answers. The Cougars leaned on a three-safety look with Faletau Satuala, Raider Damuni and Tommy Prassas, with Cannon DeVries rotating in late for Prassas.
Satuala was especially active with nine tackles, while Damuni also made his presence felt. Together, that group helped hold Reed Harris and Omarion Miller to five catches for 41 yards.
The cornerbacks were even better. Therrian Alexander and Jayven Williams were the standout duo on the field, and they handled the matchup work extremely well.
Williams locked down Miller and added six solo tackles, while Alexander limited Harris to one catch for four yards. With Evan Johnson out injured, the pressure on both corners was obvious, and they answered it.
Special teams delivered a steady day, highlighted by Matthias Dunn’s 45-yard field goal late in the game. Dunn has now gone without a miss since his unsuccessful 47-yard attempt against Utah Tech in the season’s first week.
The kicking and punt coverage were both solid, and BYU also handled an onsides kick attempt late. The one lingering issue was punt fielding.
Coaching grades landed in the middle as well. The defensive plan was sound, but the tackling problems that showed up again this week can’t be ignored. On offense, Bachmeier’s frustration with conservative play-calling from Aaron Roderick was part of the story, and the unit never found enough creativity or punch, especially in the third quarter, to keep Arizona State on its heels for long.
In Other News...
BYU Heads Into Utah Week With One Awkward Tie And Injury Drama
Utah week always carries extra weight for BYU, but Keanu Tanuvasa adds a personal layer to the rivalry. The defensive lineman spent time in Salt Lake City before transferring across the aisle, and he still has enduring connections there, including with Utah head coach Morgan Scalley. Even with that history, Tanuvasa sounded eager for the chance to line up at Rice-Eccles Stadium, where the emotion of the matchup will be matched by a very different kind of family milestone as his wife is expecting their first child soon.
On the injury front, BYU is still sorting out two important names before kickoff. Coach Kalani Sitake said running back LJ Martin and cornerback Evan Johnson will continue to be evaluated over the next few days as the Cougars try to determine whether either can go against Utah. For a game that already has plenty of edge, the availability of both players could shape how BYU approaches one of its biggest tests of the season. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces A Huge Holy War Test After Its Uneven Stretch
BYU left Tempe with a 27-20 win over Arizona State, but the bigger picture now shifts quickly to the road and to the kind of game that can define a season. Kalani Sitake has made it clear the Cougars still need to sharpen up after an uneven stretch, and the timing could hardly be more demanding with No. 3 Utah waiting on Saturday morning in Salt Lake City.
The Holy War has a way of stripping everything down to urgency, and BYU enters this one trying to keep its momentum while also proving it can play cleaner football against a top-tier opponent. The Cougars will get their shot on November 7, with kickoff set for 10 a.m. MST, and the stakes are obvious: a chance to extend their winning streak against Utah and show that the recent bumps have not knocked them off course. [Read more 🡒]
Tyler Betseys Quiet Start Puts BYU Fans In Wait-And-See Mode
Tyler Betseys first few days in a BYU uniform have given Cougar fans a little bit of everything except the scoring burst they were hoping to see. The Syracuse transfer has started both exhibition games, but he has made just 1 of 6 shots, a quiet beginning for a player expected to help on the wing as the season takes shape.
Kevin Young has not sounded concerned, pointing to Betseys defensive work and saying the shooting will come around. The Cougars will get a better read soon enough, with Ohio State up next in a non-conference game at the Delta Center in Salt Lake City, where the stakes and the pace should offer a clearer picture of how Betsey fits. [Read more 🡒]