Oklahoma State has gone from a team nobody expected much from to the league’s biggest midseason surprise in a hurry.
That was the verdict from Associated Press writers who cover the Big 12, who voted the 18th-ranked Cowboys the conference’s most surprising team at the halfway point of the season. It fits the arc of a program that had gone two seasons without a Big 12 win before Eric Morris arrived, stumbled with a loss to Tulsa in his debut, then flipped the script with a run that has included a statement upset and two conference victories.
The headline result came on Sept. 12, when Oklahoma State knocked off then-No. 6 Oregon 39-31 in Morris’ home opener.
That was the same Oregon team that had beaten the Cowboys 69-3 last season. The win snapped a 21-game losing streak against FBS opponents.
Two weeks later, Oklahoma State won at West Virginia and ended a 19-game Big 12 skid that dated back to a loss to Texas in the 2023 conference championship game.
Morris’ turnaround work earned him another AP honor, too. He was selected as the conference’s top coach, finishing ahead of Morgan Scalley, who is in his first season as the head coach at No.
11 Utah (5-0). Scalley had spent 10 seasons as Utah’s defensive coordinator and had been on Kyle Whittingham’s staff since 2007 after playing for the Utes from 2001-04.
The AP’s midseason awards also put a spotlight on the players driving the conference’s biggest storylines.
Arizona quarterback Noah Fifita was named the top offensive player after climbing to 10,939 career passing yards and 89 touchdowns, breaking the school records previously held by Super Bowl-winning quarterback Nick Foles. The senior is second in the Big 12 with 292.7 passing yards per game and has completed 140 of 191 passes for a 73.3% rate, while also leading the league with 17 touchdown passes to help the Wildcats to a 5-1 start, their best since 2014.
On defense, the nod went to Oklahoma State linebacker Ethan Wesloski. The senior, who spent the previous four seasons at North Texas, leads the Big 12 and all Power Four players with 53 tackles, an average of 10.6 per game. He has 17 tackles in each of the Cowboys’ first two Big 12 games.
The top first-year freshman honor went to BYU receiver Legend Glasker, who has piled up 19 catches for 378 yards and three touchdowns, while also adding 11 rushing attempts for 83 yards and two more scores for the No. 8 Cougars (5-0).
The top first-year transfer award went to Drew Mestemaker, another North Texas-to-Oklahoma State arrival and one of 21 players who followed Morris north. There were 88 newcomers overall for the Cowboys.
Mestemaker, who was the national passing leader as a freshman last season at North Texas after never being a varsity starting quarterback in high school, leads the Big 12 with 315 passing yards per game. He has completed 114 of 169 throws for 1,756 yards and 13 touchdowns.
Iowa State running back Aiden Flora was voted the most surprising player after going from walk-on to scholarship sophomore sensation. He is already just the third Big 12 player to score touchdowns by passing, rushing and on a punt return in the same season. Flora ranks second nationally with 785 all-purpose yards, third with 8.14 yards per carry, seventh with 118.8 rushing yards per game and ninth with a 17.9-yard punt return average.
TCU took the label of most disappointing team. The Horned Frogs are 2-3 after entering the season off back-to-back 9-4 campaigns, but have scored only 33 points combined in losses to Power Four opponents. Their 0-2 Big 12 start is their first since 2013.
That rough stretch helped put coach Sonny Dykes in a tie for the hottest seat, with Colorado’s Deion Sanders splitting the votes. TCU opened Dykes’ debut in 2022 with a 12-0 regular season and a trip to the national championship game, but it has not reached the Big 12 title game since and is now struggling badly on offense after quarterback Josh Hoover’s transfer to Indiana.
Colorado is 2-3, has lost seven straight Big 12 games and now faces Utah and Oklahoma State in its next two. The Buffaloes are 5-12 since two-way standout Travis Hunter’s 2024 Heisman Trophy season.
Baylor coach Dave Aranda, meanwhile, saw the temperature drop a bit after a shaky start to his seventh season. He was 36-38 after a loss to Auburn to open the year, but the Bears have since won four in a row and are home Saturday against TCU.
The AP’s biggest injury concern involved BYU running back LJ Martin, last season’s Big 12 offensive player of the year and the league’s leading rusher with 1,305 yards. He was off to another strong start at 109.3 rushing yards per game before getting hurt against TCU on Oct.
- He was expected to miss 4 to 6 weeks, putting his return on hold until maybe mid-November.
In Other News...
BYU Faces A Program Defining Test In A Brutal Top 10 Showdown
Brigham Young steps into one of its biggest regular-season stages in years Saturday night, hosting Notre Dame in a clash between two unbeaten teams at LaVell Edwards Stadium. The setting alone gives it weight, but the matchup adds even more intrigue: the Irish arrive with the nations top total defense, while BYU is trying to keep rolling in front of a national audience on ABC.
The Cougars will have to navigate the game without their top running back because of injury, a challenge that makes the offensive approach even more important against a defense like Notre Dames. For BYU, this is the kind of top-10 measuring stick that can shape how the season is viewed long after Saturday night ends. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Fans Should Hate Where This Playoff Debate Is Headed
Nick Sabans latest College Football Playoff idea is the kind of proposal that gets plenty of attention because of who is saying it, not necessarily because of where the sport seems headed. He has floated a 16-team field instead of 24, and for BYU fans, the debate matters because the size of the playoff will help determine whether programs outside the traditional Power Four can realistically keep breaking through or whether the safest path stays mostly inside the same familiar lanes.
The bigger issue is that playoff expansion is no longer just about competitive balance, it is about money and leverage, and those forces usually push the conversation beyond the tidy version of the sport that coaches prefer. A 24-team format would create more openings for teams like BYU and would reshape the value of conference championship games across the country, but the push and pull around the final number says plenty about how college football is choosing to organize its future. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces A Tougher Notre Dame Test If Two Defenders Return
Notre Dame may look a little closer to whole when it meets BYU, and that matters for a Cougars offense that has to navigate a defense still built around speed and depth even after injuries. Head coach Marcus Freeman said cornerback Leonard Moore and defensive lineman Jason Onye have taken practice reps and are trending toward playing, which puts both players in position to be available after missing significant time.
Moore sat out the previous game with a concussion, while Onye has been sidelined since the season opener with an ankle injury. If both are back on the field, it gives Notre Dame a welcome boost on the back end and up front, and it raises the degree of difficulty for BYU in a game that already figures to demand clean execution. [Read more 🡒]