BYU’s special teams are heading into 2026 with a very different look, and that might be the biggest unknown on the roster.
For the last three seasons, that phase of the game has been a difference-maker for the Cougars. Field goals, return touchdowns and blocked kicks have all helped swing games, and Utah, Colorado and Kansas State were among the teams that felt the damage. Much of that success came under Kelly Poppinga, who did an outstanding job as special teams coordinator before being promoted in January to defensive coordinator to replace Michigan-bound Jay Hill.
Now Justin Ena is in charge, and he’s taking over a group that has to replace a lot at once. BYU is moving on from kicker Will Ferrin, punter Sam Vander Haar and punt returner Parker Kingston. Last year’s holder was Vander Haar, and the long snapper, Garrison Grimes, was waived Aug. 1 by the New York Jets, so Ena also has to sort out those spots.
Ena said Tuesday that the specialists “are on the right track” after a solid showing in last Saturday’s scrimmage and Tuesday’s practice. Presumed starting kicker Matthias Dunn drilled a 54-yard field goal, while recently returned missionary Brody Laga added a shorter make.
The kicking battle is one of the more interesting parts of the transition. Dunn has been in the program for five years after serving a church mission to Argentina and Michigan, and Ena said the wait has prepared him for this moment.
“I feel good about our kicker situation right now. Matthias and Brody are both doing a really good job,” Ena said.
“They’re a good one-two combo. I know they’re gonna push each other throughout the year.
… Matthias has great character, and it is cool to see the wisdom being passed down to the freshman.”
Laga, a freshman from Herriman’s Mountain Ridge High, returned from his church mission in May and arrives with a big reputation. Ena said the left-footed kicker may even be able to split duties with Dunn, using one on placekicks and the other on kickoffs.
“Brody has a super strong leg. He has a whip that goes forever and ever and ever,” Ena said.
“You watch him on kickoffs and he’s getting hang times at 4.3, 4.4 (seconds) and they go into the back of the end zone, which is almost unheard of. So he’s got a monster leg, and now it’s just about being exact and getting everything honed in.”
Ena added that Dunn can handle kickoffs, too.
“So you can totally do it that way,” he said. “But make no mistake, Matthias Dunn has a great leg for kickoffs, too.”
Punting is another spot where BYU has been spoiled in recent years. Ryan Rehkow and then Vander Haar kept the Cougars steady there starting in 2020, but that run has ended. Rehkow is now in the NFL, and Vander Haar’s bid for another year of eligibility was denied.
That leaves redshirt junior Fuller Shurtz, a Katy, Texas, native who also started at cornerback for his high school team. Shurtz has played in one game for BYU and blasted a 41-yard punt against TCU last year.
“Right now, Fuller is locked in for the punting situation,” Ena said.
Freshman Cole Shulman of Nashville, Tennessee, is the backup. He got a chance to work in front of the team during last Tuesday’s media viewing portion of practice, but the result wasn’t clean.
“That’s why we practice,” Ena said. “That’s why it is such a blessing that Kalani allows us to do that in front of the whole team, truly do it when you have everybody watching.”
At punt returner, BYU is also filling a major void. Kingston gave the Cougars plenty of excitement over three seasons and remains the only player in program history with a passing touchdown, a rushing touchdown, a receiving touchdown and a punt return touchdown.
His time at BYU ended after he was charged with felony rape in St. George and was kicked out of the school last February.
The case was dismissed without prejudice in June, but his effort to return has not worked out.
Sophomore Cannon DeVries appears to be the front-runner to replace him. The Weber High product returned a few punts last year and is leading the race for 2026. Ena also mentioned Tiger Bachmeier and freshman Legend Glasker as options.
“I am excited to see what Legend can do for us,” he said.
Those three are also in the mix on kickoff returns, along with freshman running back Devaughn Eka.
In Other News...
BYUs Jaxon Kohler Move Comes With One Massive Question
Jaxon Kohlers path to BYU became one of the most notable roster developments of the offseason, giving the Cougars an experienced frontcourt piece with real production behind him. The Michigan State big man has committed to BYU and, thanks to a temporary injunction tied to a California lawsuit involving fifth-year graduated players, is eligible to suit up this coming season. For a program looking to strengthen its interior presence, the move brings immediate credibility and a player who has already logged heavy minutes on a major stage.
Kohler spent four seasons at Michigan State, starting 69 games over his last two years and finishing his senior season at 12.5 points and 8.9 rebounds per game. Those numbers are part of why his arrival is expected to have a significant impact on BYUs roster, but the larger question still hangs over everything: how long that eligibility window remains open and what it means for the Cougars if the legal landscape changes again. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Just Landed A Frontcourt Boost Fans Did Not See Coming
A familiar name from the Utah prep scene is headed back closer to home, and BYUs frontcourt suddenly looks a lot more settled for the long term. The American Fork product spent four seasons at Michigan State before committing to the Cougars for an extra season under the NCAAs new five-in-five eligibility rule, a policy that is still facing legal challenges but would allow him to spread five seasons across five years.
For BYU, the appeal is obvious: an experienced center who should step into the lineup and give the Cougars a proven presence in the middle. The timing matters too, because if the rule survives, he would be available for the 2026-27 season, giving BYU another layer of size and skill at a position that can change the shape of a roster fast. [Read more 🡒]
BYU May Have Finally Solved Its Biggest Roster Problem
BYUs search for a proven center has taken a significant step forward with the commitment of Jaxon Kohler, the former Michigan State big man who will suit up for a fifth college basketball season after receiving an additional year of NCAA eligibility. Kohler spent four seasons in East Lansing and capped that run by earning All-Big Ten Honorable Mention honors last season, giving the Cougars a veteran interior presence at a spot that had loomed as one of the rosters biggest needs.
His arrival gives BYU a much clearer answer in the middle and should help balance a frontcourt that needs both size and spacing. Kohlers game also fits the Cougars desire to improve perimeter shooting from the inside out, but the bigger question now is how quickly he can settle in and how much he changes the ceiling of a roster that was still searching for its starting center. [Read more 🡒]