The Big 12 is heading into a season with two problems sitting right in front of it.
First, the league still needs to punch through on the playoff stage. It has to land an at-large berth in the College Football Playoff, and it has to win a CFP game. So far, it’s the only Power Four conference that has done neither.
But the bigger issue is branding, identity, all of it. The Big 12 needs a team that can actually carry the league’s image, win the title, and give the conference a little shine. It needs someone to step forward and make the whole thing feel bigger.
Right now, Texas Tech has already embraced the other side of that equation. By the way it has operated and the way it has carried itself, the Red Raiders have become the league’s villain.
They’re widely disliked and envied for how aggressively they spend in roster building, and the combination of that approach, Cody Campbell’s attempts to steer the sport, and the school’s unforgivable, indefensible stance with former quarterback Brendan Sorsby has made them programa non grata in the Big 12. They’d be the sport’s top antagonist if not for a certain head coach in Baton Rouge.
And when the villain is that clear, somebody has to answer it.
There are candidates, but not many. Arizona and Arizona State are in the mix.
Houston could make a run at it. Kansas State, Oklahoma State or West Virginia could always show up as a sleeper, because that’s how this league works.
But there’s only one cape to go around.
Utah has done this before. Back in the Pac-12, the Utes were the kind of underdog people could rally behind while they pushed back against Oregon and USC.
This version of Utah, though, is different. Kyle Whittingham is gone, Morgan Scalley is in, and there are real unknowns on both sides of the ball.
The schedule also doesn’t give the Utes the kind of stage that turns a good season into a defining one. They’re set up to win eight or nine games and stay in the background, but that’s not the same thing as becoming the face of the league.
BYU, on the other hand, has a much cleaner path to the role.
Even with the administrative tension, with athletic director Brian Santiago marginalized by coach Kalani Sitake, the Cougars look better positioned than Utah - and maybe better positioned than anyone - to wear the cape. They might have the conference’s best quarterback-offensive line combination.
They should also have an elite defense, with proven playmakers at every level. Add in the program’s tradition, its national following, and the biggest platform available in the league, and the case gets even stronger.
That platform is the Oct. 17 home game against Notre Dame.
If BYU wins that one, it would do more than help the Cougars’ playoff case. It would give the Big 12 a marquee result it badly needs, the kind of win that lifts the whole conference and leaves a glow around the teams still chasing the playoff picture.
That matters even more because BYU doesn’t play Texas Tech in the regular season, and Texas Tech doesn’t have a major nonconference showcase of its own. The Big 12 has only seven games against SEC and Big Ten opponents total, which makes Notre Dame all the more important for the league’s overall profile.
So the setup is there. The opportunity is there. The cape is there.
If BYU doesn’t grab it, maybe Utah can. Maybe one of the Arizona schools can. Or maybe the Big 12 just spends another season with a villain, no hero, and the same playoff story it knows too well.
In Other News...
BYUs Utah Tech Opener Comes With A Price Tag Fans Will Notice
BYUs football opener against Utah Tech is set to come with more than the usual early-season intrigue. An amended contract obtained through a public records request shows Utah Tech will receive $450,000 for making the trip to play at BYUs stadium, a reminder that these nonconference games often carry as much financial significance as they do competitive value.
The agreement also spells out details beyond the payout, including officials assignments and ticket allocations, the kind of behind-the-scenes items that shape how these matchups are staged. Similar arrangements have surfaced in other in-state games, including the University of Utahs contests against Idaho and Utah State, underscoring how common these financial setups have become across the schedule. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces Three Pressure Points That Could Define 2026
One of the most interesting parts of looking ahead to BYUs 2026 football season is how much of the forecast hinges on players who are still in the middle of carving out their roles. The early buzz points to a few pressure points that could shape the Cougars trajectory, starting with special teams, where Matthias Dunn is being eyed to step in for Will Ferrin at placekicker. On offense, Bear Bachmeier is expected to keep developing at quarterback, while true freshman Legend Glasker has already made enough of an impression to be part of the conversation at wide receiver.
The defensive side carries its own intrigue, because BYU may need a breakout pass rusher to elevate the unit from solid to dangerous. Put it all together, and the bigger picture gets even more ambitious, with speculation that the Cougars could push toward their first College Football Playoff appearance. None of it is guaranteed, of course, but the range of possibilities speaks to how much is at stake for a program trying to turn promising pieces into something far bigger. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Opener Could Reveal More About This Offense Than Utah Tech
BYUs 2026 opener against Utah Tech is the kind of game that usually looks straightforward on paper, but it carries a few early-season questions for the Cougars anyway. The matchup with the FCS opponent, set for ESPN+, gives fans their first look at a new receiving corps, a chance to see how much work running back LJ Martin might handle, and an opening window into how head coach Kalani Sitake plans to sort through the depth chart before the schedule tightens up.
Utah Tech, meanwhile, arrives with some momentum under Lance Anderson, which makes this more than a pure tune-up even if BYU is expected to be the more talented team. The bigger intrigue may be less about the final score and more about which backups get meaningful snaps, how much of the playbook gets shown, and whether the Cougars can walk away with enough answers before Arizona comes next. [Read more 🡒]