BYU got the win it needed Saturday, but not the kind that settles anything.
The Cougars beat Arizona State 27-20 and moved one step closer to next Saturday’s showdown with undefeated Utah, yet the bigger picture coming out of the game is still cloudy. BYU flashed enough to survive, but the same problems kept showing up: a run game that never got rolling, tackling issues on defense and stretches where the offense simply stalled out.
The day opened with a jolt. On just the third play from scrimmage, blitzing edge defender Nusi Taumoepeau knocked the ball loose from Sun Devil freshman quarterback Jake Fette, and Isaiah Glasker pounced on it. A few plays later, Sione Moa finished the short field with a touchdown run, and BYU was up 7-0 in the first five minutes.
After that, the Cougars spent much of the afternoon fighting uphill.
The ground game never found traction. Moa finished with 20 yards on eight carries, and BYU as a team managed only 47 rushing yards on 1.6 yards per carry. With LJ Martin’s status still in question and Preston Rex unavailable because of injury, the offense had little balance to lean on.
“We just didn’t have a lot of plays. And Arizona State did a good job at loading the box,” said BYU coach Kalani Sitake.
“We just were not able to establish the run game, and that makes it hard for us. We’d like to be more balanced, and keep them on their heels.
They did a good job at taking that away from us.”
That left Bear Bachmeier carrying more of the load than BYU wanted, and Arizona State was able to key on him. Bachmeier ran 16 times for just 15 yards.
Even with the offensive issues, BYU still put itself in position to take control before halftime. The Cougars led 17-3 and were driving with a chance to make it 24-7 at the break, but Bachmeier was intercepted with 51 seconds left when he failed to clear Arizona’s underneath coverage. It was another late-first-half turnover that changed the shape of the game.
“The one today was a great play. The defender got up and high-pointed the ball,” Sitake said.
“It might have been under thrown a little bit, but it was a great defensive play. Let’s not do that anymore.”
The third quarter was even rougher. BYU opened the half with back-to-back 3-and-outs, and the Cougars ran only six plays for nine yards in the period.
“That third quarter was tough,” Sitake stated. “A lot of plays for our defense… Third down was not good for our offense, and we could not run the ball for some reason. There’s things we need to improve on.”
Arizona State took advantage of the lull. Fette settled in and helped the Sun Devils tie the game 17-17 early in the fourth quarter on a short touchdown pass to tight end Anthony Miller.
That set up the final push from BYU, and the Cougars answered when it mattered most. Facing fourth-and-short at their own 14 with 5:45 left and clinging to a 20-17 lead, BYU went for it and converted.
Bachmeier powered through the line, and one play later he hit a streaking freshman receiver for a 53-yard gain. That sequence helped set up Moa’s touchdown run with 2:02 remaining, stretching the lead to 27-17 and putting the game away.
“I think a lot of people were nervous about the fourth-and-one, but the team was all for it. That was a good moment for us,” Sitake said.
“There was no hesitation from anyone - offense, defense, special teams and even the sideline. They were all for it, and I can be convinced pretty easily.
I’m just glad it worked out … We just felt like they were gaining momentum. They had possession of the clock and kind of wore our defense down a little bit.
We felt like we had to keep the ball for a little bit and
give our guys a break and make some adjustments. It just seemed like the right thing to do … Feeling the game and the momentum and trying to get it back. I
felt like it was worth the risk.”
Defensively, BYU did create pressure. The Cougars sacked Fette six times and forced the early turnover that helped them grab control. But Arizona State freshman Cardae Mack still found room, rushing for 123 yards on 23 carries, and Sitake didn’t hide his concern about the missed tackles.
“We had turnovers and (tackles-for-loss), but they were kind of gashing us on some of the run plays,” Sitake observed. “Their running back is a really good player.
He got his yardage. We just had a hard time tackling.
We missed a lot of tackles this week. That was concerning … So we’ve got to get things fixed and figured out … We’ll go back to work and try to figure out a way to get these guys more tackles.
We had a lot of missed opportunities and sacks.”
Now the focus shifts quickly to Utah, which beat Cincinnati on the road on Saturday and comes in undefeated. Sitake knows the margin for error is shrinking.
“That game is different every time. No matter what you think is going to happen, it’s a different week,” Sitake said of next Saturday’s matchup.
“I’m more focused on trying to get our team to make improvements week-to-week. They’re a great team and undefeated for a reason.
It’s not going to be an easy task, but I’m looking forward to the matchup, and it’s going to be a lot of fun.”
In Other News...
BYU Win Over Arizona State Just Sparked A Big 12 Debate
The Big 12s acknowledgment of an officiating error in BYUs 27-20 win over Arizona State has added a fresh layer to a game that already carried plenty of weight in the conference race. The issue centered on a fumble recovery that was incorrectly ruled a touchdown, a call that immediately shifted the tone of the matchup and left one side feeling as if the moment had been decided on the spot.
For BYU, the result still stands, but the debate around how the play should have been handled is impossible to ignore because the awarded points matched the final margin. The correct ruling would have given the Cougars possession where the fumble was recovered, not a touchdown, and that distinction has turned a hard-fought win into one of the more talked-about officiating controversies in the Big 12 this season. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Win Draws Fresh Scrutiny After Another Big 12 Admission
The Big 12s latest officiating admission has put BYU back in an uncomfortable spotlight, this time over a touchdown in the win against Arizona State that the league says should never have counted. The conference said running back Sione Moas score was the result of an error, and the proper ruling should have left BYU with possession at the two-yard line instead.
For a program already dealing with the lingering frustration from a timing mistake in the Notre Dame game two weeks earlier, the back-to-back acknowledgments only deepen the sense that the Cougars have been on the wrong end of some major calls. BYU still has the victory in hand, but the latest statement adds another layer to a season in which the conversation around the team has too often drifted from the field to the replay booth. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Win Reignites Frustration Over Another Big 12 Officiating Error
BYUs win over Arizona State came with another officiating wrinkle that quickly became part of the conversation afterward. On the field, a touchdown was initially awarded after running back Sione Moa came up with a fumble recovery, but the Big 12 later acknowledged the score should not have counted and that BYU should have been facing third-and-goal from the two-yard line instead.
For a program that is still getting used to life in the Big 12, the correction only added to the frustration around how these games are being handled. It also came on the heels of another officiating adjustment in a recent BYU game against Notre Dame, leaving the Cougars with a familiar feeling that a clean result on the scoreboard has not always meant a clean finish in the review process. [Read more 🡒]