Morgan Scalley didn’t need much time to revise his opinion of BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier.
The first-year Utah coach admitted that when he first watched the Cougar quarterback, he didn’t see a polished passer. That changed fast once Bachmeier started producing in 2025.
“I’m going to be honest. When I first started watching Bear, I’m like, ‘This guy cannot throw. He’s a running back playing quarterback,’” Scalley said.
Then came the correction.
“I was wrong, dead wrong. I mean, (BYU offensive coordinator) Aaron Roderick has done such a great job developing him and you can tell his work ethic also, you have to compliment him on that,” Scalley said.
Bachmeier, a Stanford transfer, took over last year after starter Jake Retzlaff was suspended for an honor code violation and later withdrew from BYU in July. Retzlaff eventually landed at Tulane. Since then, Bachmeier has become the engine of the Cougars’ offense.
He helped BYU reach the Big 12 championship game and win the Pop-Tarts Bowl, throwing for 3,033 yards with 15 touchdowns and seven interceptions while completing 64.9% of his passes. He also ran for 527 yards and 11 touchdowns, often delivering in the biggest moments.
That included last year’s 24-21 win over Utah, when Bachmeier passed for 166 yards and a touchdown and added 64 rushing yards plus the decisive score: a 22-yard touchdown run on third-and-11, dragging multiple Utes into the end zone. He also turned in one of the Cougars’ signature plays in the rivalry, a hurdle that Scalley hasn’t forgotten.
“He can hurdle you. That’s one thing we learned,” Scalley said.
This year, Bachmeier has had to carry even more of the load with star running back LJ Martin sidelined for the past four games. BYU hasn’t gotten much from its backup backs, so the offense has leaned harder on Bachmeier’s arm.
Over that stretch, he has averaged 261.5 passing yards per game. That includes a 224-yard outing in a win over then-No.
2 Notre Dame. He has thrown three interceptions in four games, but the Cougars have still leaned on him to keep the offense moving without much help from the run game.
That’s why Utah knows the assignment this week is simple: slow him down.
If BYU, a 5.5-point underdog, is going to beat undefeated Utah and stretch its rivalry winning streak to four, Bachmeier likely has to deliver another big performance. That becomes even more important if Martin can’t go Saturday morning or is limited in his first game back from injury.
Utah is preparing as if Martin will play.
“Obviously Bear, it all runs through him. We expect LJ probably to be back, but don’t know, but we’re planning for it,” Scalley said.
The Utes have already shown they can make life hard on top quarterbacks. Conner Weigman, the best quarterback Utah has faced so far, finished with 282 yards in Houston’s loss, but the Cougars managed only one touchdown and Weigman’s 54.3% completion rate was his season low. Jackson Bennee’s strip-sack helped swing that game.
Utah also ramped up pressure against Cincinnati’s JC French IV, blitzing on nearly 49% of his dropbacks. That led to a season-low 53.3% completion percentage, a pick-six and three sacks.
Now Colton Swan’s defense has to figure out how to do that to Bachmeier, even though BYU has protected him well. The Cougars have allowed the fourth-fewest sacks in the country and have kept Bachmeier clean on 80% of his dropbacks.
The challenge isn’t just in the pocket. Bachmeier can hurt teams as a runner, too.
Utah has used a “cage rush” against dual-threat quarterbacks this season, limiting the run game but sometimes sacrificing pressure. Swan mixed his calls well in the wins over Houston and Cincinnati, bringing heat at the right moments.
Bachmeier’s skill set is exactly why Scalley is so wary of him now.
“He is an efficient thrower. He has zip on his ball,” Scalley said.
“He makes great decisions. Add to that, the fact that when he runs, it’s like, OK, bring your lunch every time.
“He is thick, he’s tough to bring down, really good balance,” he continued. “So the dual threat is always going to be something that if a team’s got that, then you really have to have answers and take your shots every once in a while, but can’t say enough good things about him.”
Utah’s defense has been one of the strengths of its 8-0 start, allowing 101.4 rushing yards per game, which ranks 22nd nationally, and 15.9 points per game, good for 15th in the country. But the Utes have also given up chunk plays in each of their last four games, with some of those breakdowns tied to miscommunication and coverage issues.
That has pushed Utah to 229 passing yards allowed per game, which ranks No. 96 in FBS.
The Utes have survived those mistakes because of strong red-zone defense, but they know that won’t be enough if Bachmeier starts hitting explosives and Legend Glasker gets room to work. If Utah can force a turnover or two the way it has against high-level competition in the last two games, it will go a long way toward deciding Saturday’s matchup.
In Other News...
BYU Has One Real Opening In This Rivalry Upset Bid
BYU heads into the Utah game with the kind of rivalry backdrop that always sharpens the edges of a matchup, and this one comes with plenty of familiar tension. The Cougars are being sized up against a Utes team that has owned the series for stretches, while the broader college football slate around them only underscores how much these November games hinge on health, form and who can handle the moment best.
For BYU, the appeal of an upset bid is tied to finding the one opening that really matters in a game like this. The preview around the matchup points to the usual rivalry variables, from injuries to matchup quirks to the way recent history can shape expectations, and it places the Cougars in the same conversation as other high-stakes games like Missouri-Texas, LSU-Alabama and Tennessee-Kentucky. The question is whether BYU can turn that opening into something bigger before the rivalry pressure closes it back up. [Read more 🡒]
BYUs CFP Position Just Made The Utah Game Even Bigger
BYUs first College Football Playoff ranking came in a little lower than many around the program expected, with the Cougars landing at No. 9 despite the marquee win over Notre Dame. The committees first look made clear that the Irish victory still matters, but not nearly as much as it might have if Notre Dame had held a stronger place in the rankings, and the overall message was that the committee is weighing quality wins heavily.
For BYU, that puts even more pressure on what comes next, starting with the Utah game. The Cougars also have a Notre Dame-Miami matchup to watch closely, since movement there could affect how the Irish win ages in the committees eyes, but the bigger point is simple: BYU cannot afford to let the resume sit still, especially with the UCF loss still hanging over the evaluation. [Read more 🡒]
Texas Draws Fresh Respect In Joel Klatt Ranking Debate
Joel Klatts latest top 10 after Week 9 gave Texas a fresh boost in the national conversation, with the FOX analyst slotting the Longhorns at No. 7 behind Miami, Oregon, Georgia, Ohio State, Indiana and Penn State. The ranking also came with a reminder of how crowded the upper tier has become, as Klatt pointed to BYU, Ole Miss, LSU, USC and Wake Forest as bubble teams just outside his list.
For BYU, the takeaway is less about the exact pecking order and more about the company it is keeping as the season tightens. Klatt also weighed in on how Miami and Utah are handling their own paths ahead, which only adds to the sense that the playoff picture is still very much in motion and that a strong finish could reshape where the Cougars stand in the next round of debates. [Read more 🡒]