Kirk Herbstreit is still looking at the Big 12 as a league with multiple teams in the College Football Playoff conversation, even after a rough weekend for a couple of its contenders.
On Monday’s “Nonstop” podcast with former Ohio State receiver Joey Galloway, the ESPN analyst singled out Utah, Texas Tech and BYU as playoff-caliber teams. He also included Arizona as the conference’s fourth “really good” team and said, “I think Oklahoma State and Houston have fallen off.”
Utah remains the headliner. The Utes are the Big 12’s only unbeaten team at 10-0 overall and 7-0 in conference play, and the committee had them at No. 2 in last week’s rankings. It’s Utah’s best start since the 13-0 season in 2008, and it’s happening in Morgan Scalley’s first year as head coach.
The Utes had to survive a wild one Saturday in Tucson. Arizona grabbed a 39-33 lead with a little more than three minutes left, but quarterback Devon Dampier answered with a 70-yard touchdown strike to Creed Whittemore with 2:35 remaining, lifting Utah to a 40-39 win. Dampier finished with four touchdowns, and Daniel Bray piled up 197 rushing yards.
Former Auburn head coach Hugh Freeze, who was also on the episode, said he’s “very intrigued by Utah.” The way the Utes ran for nearly 200 yards in a hostile road game only added to that impression.
Texas Tech made its own statement in a big way. The Red Raiders rolled past No.
25 Oklahoma State, 52-27, to improve to 9-1. Thomas Castellanos threw for 263 yards and four touchdowns, and Malcolm Simmons set the tone immediately with a 97-yard kickoff-return touchdown.
That win mattered because Texas Tech had been the first team out of the projected field in the previous rankings. Greg McElroy had already pointed to the Red Raiders as a team with playoff danger heading into the trip to Stillwater, and Castellanos backed up the hype with a strong response.
BYU also got back on track after losing to Utah, beating Baylor 28-7 to move to 8-2. Bear Bachmeier ran for three touchdowns and added another through the air, though the passing game remains a question.
When asked why Bachmeier wasn’t throwing downfield more, BYU coach Kalani Sitake said, “You are asking the same questions I ask.” The Cougars still have a win over Notre Dame, and that gives them more in the at-large discussion than Houston can claim.
Arizona, meanwhile, earned respect even in defeat. The Wildcats fell just short against Utah, and Noah Fifita threw for 356 yards and three touchdowns in the effort.
Herbstreit pushed back against any idea that Arizona should slide too far, saying, “Arizona is a good football team. They played against an exceptional football team at home.”
Galloway agreed, though his playoff math was centered on three teams.
Freeze also praised Arizona coach Brent Brennan, calling him “one of the most underrated coaches in the nation.”
Houston’s loss was the most jarring of the weekend. The No. 14 Cougars dropped 42-32 at Colorado after surrendering 28 straight points, falling to 7-3.
Oklahoma State, on the other hand, slid to 6-4 after the loss to Texas Tech, even with Drew Mestemaker in the lineup after Danny Kanell called him the best quarterback in college football last week.
The committee’s next rankings come out Tuesday at 9 p.m. ET.
In Other News...
BYU Faces A New Test With Its Loaded 2027 Class
With BYU sitting in the top 10 and chasing its first College Football Playoff berth, the program is already balancing present-day expectations with the next wave of talent. True freshmen have been part of that push, giving the staff a clear reminder that the roster is not just built for now but for what comes next. Even with the season still unfolding, the Cougars have started turning attention to the 2027 recruiting class, and the early returns suggest this group could be a major one.
The class is still small in terms of commitments, but the quality stands out, with multiple prospects drawing interest from major programs. BYU has already begun extending official scholarship offers, and the early shape of the class points to particularly strong groups along the defensive line and at cornerback. For a program trying to sustain its current rise, the next recruiting cycle may end up being just as important as the one already on campus. [Read more 🡒]
Bear Bachmeier Just Gave BYU The Reset It Needed
Bear Bachmeier gave BYU exactly the kind of stabilizing performance it needed in a 28-7 win over Baylor, keeping the Cougars on schedule and out of trouble in his first extended look. He didnt force the issue through the air, finishing 14 of 24 for 104 yards, but he protected the ball, added 54 rushing yards and found the end zone three times on the ground while BYU controlled possession for 37 minutes.
The bigger question now is how quickly that showing changes the conversation around the offense. The defense did its part, too, with multiple sacks and an interception while holding Baylor in check, but Bachmeiers composure and dual-threat presence gave the Cougars a cleaner version of themselves than they had shown earlier. Whether this becomes a one-game spark or something more lasting is the next thing BYU has to sort out. [Read more 🡒]
BYUs Big 12 And Playoff Hopes Now Come Down To This
BYUs path through the Big 12 still looks very much alive, but the margin for error is thin as the regular season winds down. ESPNs FPI likes the Cougars to handle Kansas and gives them a solid edge in the finale against Cincinnati, which puts them in position to finish 10-2 and keep the conference race in view.
The bigger picture is where things get interesting. BYU and Texas Tech are rated similarly, but the Red Raiders sit ahead in the Big 12 standings and have the better conference title odds, while BYUs stronger win over Notre Dame gives the Cougars a boost in the College Football Playoff conversation. Both teams are chasing the same small cluster of spots, and the final stretch may decide which resume gets the last word. [Read more 🡒]
