A rough night against Tampa Bay left the Buffalo Sabres staring at an uncomfortable truth: the version of this team that surged late last season is not just waiting around to reappear.
After the blowout loss on home ice Wednesday, captain Rasmus Dahlin didn’t sugarcoat it.
"We have to look ourselves in the mirror after this one," Sabres captain Rasmus Dahlin told reporters.
Alternate captain Tage Thompson echoed that message.
"Just look in the mirror and try to find ways that we can be better, and do it every single shift."
That’s the challenge now for Buffalo, because the easy answer - the one that carried the Sabres through the end of the 2025-26 season - is not coming back on command. Buffalo closed that year by winning 39 of its final 53 games, an absurd run that ended the NHL’s longest playoff drought. But that stretch was a perfect storm, the kind of heater a team doesn’t get to summon twice.
This group is dealing with a different reality. The goaltending hasn’t been steady enough.
The special teams have been a mess at times. And the finishing touch that used to be a strength has gone missing.
If Buffalo wants to get back to the postseason for a second straight year, it can’t afford to wait until mid-December to sort itself out again. HockeyStats.com has the Sabres at just 39% odds to make it after Wednesday’s loss, and the Eastern Conference isn’t offering much breathing room.
What made the defeat to Tampa Bay sting even more was the way it unfolded. The Sabres looked disorganized, with defensive breakdowns piling up as players started trying to force plays outside the structure. That opened the door for the Lightning to keep generating dangerous chances and keep stretching the score.
Last season, Buffalo could usually find its footing again even after a bad bounce or a multi-goal hole. The team had a rhythm to it, a system that could still create transition looks and build pressure through the offensive zone.
Right now, that flow is missing. The Sabres are having trouble producing offense consistently, and once they fail to cash in on early chances, the game tends to tilt against them fast.
There are still 66 games left, so this isn’t panic time. But after 18 games, the warning signs are loud enough to notice. Maybe the panic button stays in the drawer for now, but it’s getting close to being pulled out.
Tage Thompson was one of the few bright spots in the loss and earned Buffalo Player of the Game honors. His early third-period goal cut Tampa Bay’s lead to 4-3 and briefly brought the building to life.
The Lightning answered with two goals in the next three minutes to shut the door, but Thompson still turned in a strong night for the Sabres’ offensive centerpiece. He’s on pace for his first 50-goal season even with the team sputtering around him.
The power play still needs to find a better way to get him cleaner looks, though.
The rest of the grades painted a tough picture. Josh Doan, Peyton Krebs, Jason Zucker, Josh Norris and Ryan McLeod all landed in the middle range, while Dahlin was given a 6. The lower end included Owen Power, Beck Malenstyn, Jack Quinn, Noah Ostlund, Tyson Kozak, Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen and Colten Ellis, with Conor Timmins finishing at 1 after a rough outing.
The goaltending numbers may feel harsh given how often Buffalo’s structure broke down, but the Sabres need saves somewhere. Neither Luukkonen nor Colten Ellis has grabbed hold of the No. 1 job while Alex Lyon remains out with an injury.
There were a few smaller positives tucked into the night. Doan is trending in the right direction, and the goals should start coming more often.
McLeod looked solid in his return after a pair of healthy scratches. Timmins, who had been mostly steady since coming back from injury, had a brutal night against Tampa.
In Other News...
Sabres Loss To Tampa Exposed A Problem Fans Wont Ignore
The Sabres latest trip through Tampa Bay turned into one of those nights that can linger long after the final horn. The Lightning jumped out fast with four goals, Buffalo briefly steadied itself by scoring three straight to make things interesting, and then the game slipped away again in a way that felt all too familiar for a team still trying to find consistency in its own end.
Nikita Kucherov was at the center of the damage for Tampa Bay, and the sequence that followed Buffalos push only sharpened the frustration. After the Sabres allowed a goal on a backhand shot, the response on the bench said plenty about how the night was unfolding, and it left another reminder of how quickly a game can tilt when the margin for error disappears. [Read more 🡒]
Sabres Have A Tough Choice If Penguins Start Selling
If the Penguins decide to move veterans, Buffalo could have real reason to pay attention. Bryan Rust and Rickard Rakell both fit the kind of forward help the Sabres have been looking for, and either one would bring a different layer to a group that could use more proven scoring and playoff experience. Rust has long been valued for his all-around game, while Rakell has remained a name to watch in trade chatter because of what he can still provide offensively.
The fit is easy to see from Buffalos side, but the timing is complicated by what Pittsburgh does next. Rusts injury situation and Rakells recent surge only add to the intrigue, because the Penguins may not be in a hurry to make anything simple. For the Sabres, the question is whether they can strike if the market opens, and whether the price for that kind of upgrade becomes worth paying. [Read more 🡒]
Sabres Let This One Slip Away After Brief Third-Period Hope
Buffalo had a brief jolt of life in the third period at KeyBank Center, enough to make it feel for a moment like the Sabres might have a path back into a game that had tilted heavily toward Tampa Bay. Josh Doan, Jason Zucker and Tage Thompson each found the net for Buffalo, while Colten Ellis was left to absorb a heavy workload in a night that quickly became about chasing the puck and trying to slow down a Lightning attack that kept finding answers.
The trouble was Tampa Bay kept stacking them up, with John Carlson driving the offense and Andrei Vasilevskiy steadying things behind him. Nikita Kucherov was the headliner, and his night only grew more decisive as the third period unfolded, turning Buffalos flicker of hope into another reminder of how quickly a game can slip away when a contender starts rolling. [Read more 🡒]